Search

Direct acting dopamine agonists are generally less effective than levodopa in relieving symptoms of Parkinson's disease. In an attempt to quantitate and explain this situation, the acute motor responses to intravenous injections of the dopamine agonist, (-)-N-n-propyl-norapomorphine hydrochloride (NPA), were compared with those of the dopamine precursor, levodopa. At optimum dose levels, the acute anti-Parkinsonian efficacy of NPA averaged only about 50% of maximum, while essentially total symptom suppression was obtained with levodopa in patients previously treated with the amine precursor. Dyskinesia severity, however, was similar with the two drugs. These differences in anti-Parkinsonian efficacy may reflect the fact that while NPA acts mainly on D-2 dopamine receptors, levodopa results in stimulation of both the D-1 and D-2 subsets of receptors at a more physiological ratio. Future efforts to develop dopamine agonists for the treatment of Parkinsonian symptoms may thus have to consider focusing on drugs having pharmacological profile more similar to that of dopamine.

Levodopa combined with carbidopa (Sinemet) remains the most effective approach to the symptomatic relief of Parkinson's disease. Over time, however, an increasing number of parkinsonian patients evidence motor response complications, notably abnormal involuntary movements and motor fluctuations. Clinical pharmacologic studies suggest that these phenomena may arise as a consequence of factors reflecting both natural disease progression and levodopa toxicity. Simple wearing-off responses appear primarily related to advancing degenerative changes afflicting the dopamine system. The appearance of peak-dose dyskinesias and complex, random motor fluctuations of the on-off type, on the other hand, may signal secondary postjunctional changes arising as a consequence of chronic intermittent excitation of postsynaptic dopamine receptors that are normally tonically stimulated. Therapeutically, prompt correction of wearing-off fluctuations can ordinarily be achieved by measures that deliver dopaminomimetics continuously to the central nervous system. In contrast, fluctuations of the on-off type initially persist despite stable circulating levodopa levels. With continuous levodopa treatment, however, the threshold for dyskinesias begins to rise and the dose-response relation shifts to the right; clinically, the severity of both dyskinesias and on-off fluctuations tends to diminish. It is thus tempting to speculate that the early and continuing treatment of Parkinson's disease with compounds providing a relatively constant level of central dopamine stimulation will preclude wearing-off phenomena and mitigate on-off fluctuations and severe dyskinesias.