Search

This article discusses the bizarre and contrary effects of thiocyanate, the major detoxication product of hydrogen cyanide inhaled from tobacco smoke or liberated from cyanogenic foods, e.g. cassava. Thiocyanate both (1) promotes inflammatory disease in rats and (2) facilitates the anti-inflammatory action of historic metal therapies based on gold (Au) or silver (Ag) in three models of chronic polyarthritis in rats. Low doses of nanoparticulate metallic silver (NMS) preparations, i.e. zerovalent silver (Ag°) administered orally, suppressed the mycobacterial ('adjuvant')-induced arthritis (MIA) in rats. Similar doses of cationic silver, Ag(I), administered orally as silver oxide or soluble silver salts were inactive. By contrast, NMS only inhibited the development of the collagen-induced arthritis (CIA) and pristane-induced arthritis (PIA) in rats when thiocyanate was also co-administered in drinking water. These (a) arthritis-selective and (b) thiocyanate-inducible effects of Ag° were also observed in some previous, and now extended, studies with the classic anti-arthritic drug, sodium aurothiomalate (ATM, Myocrisin(®)) and its silver analogue (STM), administered subcutaneously to rats developing the same three forms of polyarthritis. In the absence of either Ag° or ATM, thiocyanate considerably increased the severity of the MIA, CIA and PIA, i.e. acting as a pro-pathogen. Hitherto, thiocyanate was considered relatively harmless. This may not be true in rats/people with immuno-inflammatory stress and concomitant leukocyte activation. Collectively, these findings show how the drug action of a xenobiotic might be determined by the nature (and severity) of the experimental inflammation, as an example of conditional pharmacology. They also suggest that an incipient toxicity, even of normobiotics such as thiocyanate, might likewise be modulated beneficially by well-chosen xenobiotics (drugs, nutritional supplements, etc.), i.e. conditional toxicology (Powanda 1995). Thus, both the disease and the environment may determine (1) the therapeutic action and/or (2) adverse effect(s) of xenobiotics--and even some normobiotics.

The objective of this study was to quantify the ability of sublethal concentrations of several gold compounds to differentially modulate the monocytic secretion of key cytokines that are important in the etiology of rheumatic diseases. Human THP1 monocytic cells were exposed to the anti-rheumatic drugs auranofin (AF), gold sodium thiomalate (GSTM) or HAuCl4 (Au(III)) for 24-72 h. Succinate dehydrogenase (SDH) activity of the monocytes was used to determine sublethal concentrations. Monocytes were then exposed to sublethal concentrations of gold compounds for 72 h, and the activator lipopolysaccharide (LPS) was added (or not) to cultures for the last 6h. The secretion of IL6, IL8, IL10, and TNFalpha were measured in cell supernatants using ELISA. Cytokine secretion was compared among concentrations and gold compounds. SDH experiments established a sublethal concentration range of 0-75 microM for GSTM and Au(III) and 0-0.5 microM for AF. In cytokine experiments, none of the compounds alone activated secretion of any of the cytokines, but all differentially (50-440%, p<0.05) increased LPS-induced secretion of IL6 and IL8 over TNFalpha and IL10. In conclusion, sublethal concentrations of AF, GSTM, and Au(III) all may differentially modulate activation of monocytic cells, and this differential modulation may be important in the mechanisms of action of these compounds.

Two gold compounds, gold sodium thiomalate (AuTM) and auranofin, are presently in clinical use in therapy of rheumatoid arthritis. In these studies, AuTM administered to Sprague-Dawley rats and three strains of mice, Swiss-Webster, C3H/HeJ, and DBA/2J, were studied with regard to its effect on liver and renal monooxygenases, metallothionein contents, and serum levels of alanine aminotransferase and urea nitrogen. These effects of AuTM were compared to those of cadmium, since the latter metal has exhibited tissue and species differences in the induction of metallothionein. Benzo(a)pyrene hydroxylase and benzphetamine N-demethylase activities were not altered by AuTM in livers of rats and the three strains of mice. Benzo(a)pyrene hydroxylase activity was significantly decreased in rat kidney, whereas this enzyme activity was not affected in the kidneys of mice. In rats, AuTM caused a sevenfold induction in liver metallothionein, while in mice, liver metallothionein was induced twofold in Swiss-Webster mice and about fivefold in the inbred strains. AuTM caused minimal changes in renal metallothionein contents in the three strains of mice studied. Serum alanine amino-transferase, an indicator of hepatotoxicity, was not altered by AuTM in rats and mice studied. Blood urea nitrogen, an indicator of kidney dysfunction, was increased threefold in rats, but not in AuTM-treated mice. These data demonstrate that AuTM, a nephrotoxic agent in rats and humans, showed no nephrotoxic effects in the mouse strains studied here.

The oxidizing capacity of phagocytic cells is suspected to play a major role in the generation of immunogenic drug metabolites, in particular those that cause extrahepatic immunopathological lesions. In the case of the antirheumatic drug gold(I) disodium thiomalate (Na2Au(I)TM), oxidation of the Au(I) ion to Au(III) appears to be responsible for the adverse immune reactions which may develop during gold therapy. Here, we show that the reactive metabolite Au(III) may be generated by mononuclear phagocytes (M phi) exposed to Au(I). The generation of Au(III) was analyzed by means of the adoptive transfer popliteal lymph node assay (PLNA) in mice, using T lymphocytes previously sensitized to Au(III) as a detection probe. Donors of the Au(III)-primed T cells were either directly sensitized to Au(III) by injection of tetrachloroauric acid (HAu(III)Cl4), or indirectly via chronic treatment with Na2Au(I)TM. As donors of peritoneal cells (PC), we used mice which had received weekly i.m. injections of Na2Au(I)TM for 12 weeks and contained increased numbers of activated B cells. The PC of these mice were found to elicit a significant secondary response when used as antigenic material for the restimulation of Au(III)-primed T cells. The immunogenicity of PC obtained from Na2Au(I)TM-treated mice paralleled the total gold content of these cells. Noteworthily, M phi exposed to Au(I) in vitro also proved capable of eliciting a specific secondary response of Au(III)-primed T cells. Hence, M phi exposed to Au(I) generate the reactive intermediate Au(III) which, apparently via oxidation of self proteins, sensitizes T cells. As M phi are constituents of many different organs and, moreover, communicate with T cells, their capacity to generate Au(III) may account for the various extrahepatic adverse immune reactions induced by Au(I) drugs.