Search

Spinycheek crayfish (Faxonius limosus) and signal crayfish (Pacifastacus leniusculus) are successful North American invasive crayfish species distributed throughout Europe. Both species compete with native benthic fish for shelter. In a laboratory approach, we assessed competition for shelter and antagonistic interactions between these invasive crayfish species and the native benthic fish species, stone loach (Barbatula barbatula) and bullhead (Cottus gobio). This allows for studying the potential impacts of invasive crayfish on native benthic fish. Spinycheek crayfish and signal crayfish were able to gain control of the shelter and could successfully displace both benthic fish species. For stone loach, the presence of crayfish significantly decreased their shelter use and caused several behavioural changes such as reduced activity and increased hiding behaviour outside the shelter. Although the shelter use by bullheads was not reduced, they displayed similar behavioural changes, if less intense. Invasive crayfish species showed remarkable combative interactions against both species of benthic fishes, evidenced by the high number of aggressive interactions, especially concerning stone loach. Our results highlight the pronounced dominance of invasive crayfish over benthic fish in terms of shelter competition and aggressive interactions under laboratory conditions, which consequently might promote the latter’s exposure to predation.

The aim of this study was to support the development of ecological stream quality assessment tools in order to provide a method for sustainable water management in Turkey. Therefore, we present two new or adapted indices based on benthic invertebrates. To develop and adapt the indices, 17 streams were studied and separated into three quality classes, which were supported by four community indices (EPT [%], EPTCBO [%], number of Individuals, evenness), and 23 taxa were identified as indicators for these three quality classes. As a first biological index, we adapted the Hindu Kush-Himalaya biotic score (HKHbios) to the Euphrates catchment by establishing a new and ecoregion-specific score list (Euph-Scores) by scoring 93 taxa depending on their distribution between the quality classes. Based on these scores, several average score per taxon values (ASPT value) were calculated. All ASPT values of the Euph-Scores separated the quality classes significantly. After a comparison of the different ASPT values we recommend to use the weighted ASPT, because the weighting enabled a sharper differentiation between the quality classes and named it Euphrates Biotic Score (EUPHbios). As a second biological index, we propose the proportion of habitat specialists. To calculate this index, a habitat score was developed by analysing the habitat preferences of several benthic invertebrates. Habitat score values were assigned to the 20 most common taxa from the streams in the best quality class (natural streams). The proportion of habitat specialists, identified using the new habitat score, differed significantly between the three quality classes, with higher values in natural streams than in polluted streams. In the light of the results, the presented methods appear to be suitable for developing a multi-metric index for assessment programs for the mountainous regions of the Middle East.

Dikerogammarus villosus, one of the most successful invaders in European river systems, is commonly regarded as a threat to native biodiversity and a main factor structuring the benthic community of invaded systems. The impact of D. villosus has been intensively studied in small-scale experiments and field observations, but its impact on natural communities on a larger scale remains unclear. Here, we investigated the benthic community structure at ten sites covering a broad range of habitats along the River Rhine (Central Europe) and its tributaries, to determine whether D. villosus is one of the main factors structuring the benthic community. Community composition was analysed using non-metric multidimensional scaling, distance-based redundancy analysis, and correlation analyses. D. villosus was one of nine relevant taxa present that altogether reflected a large part of the variation in the benthic samples, but further analyses indicated that the species might be less important for the community structure than other relevant taxa. Moreover, all nine relevant taxa together can explain only a similar amount of variation in our samples than the five relevant non-faunal environmental factors (water temperature, pH, conductivity, percentage of medium-sized gravel and macrophytes). Overall, our results suggested that rather a combination of non-faunal environmental factors than D. villosus mainly structure the benthic community composition on this larger spatial scale.

The caddisfly species Micropterna lateralis is an abundant representative of limnephilids in intermittent streams. Yet, its basic life history characteristics and adaptations related to environmental factors, such as stream drying, are comparatively understudied. Here, we investigated larval growth and metabolic energy reserves (glycogen, triglycerides) through development in their natural habitat. We concentrated on the larval development because this period represents the important phase of energy accumulation necessary for growth, metamorphosis and embryogenesis. Besides larval physiology, female adults were studied in terms of ovarian maturation. Our results indicate that adult females lack an imaginal diapause, which is otherwise often observed in intermittent stream-inhabiting Limnephilidae. Further, M. lateralis is univoltine and exhibits a relatively fast larval development with five distinct instars, of which four are characterised here (instars II–V). Accrual of biomass occurs in final instars, where a high amount of glycogen is accumulated. Lipid concentrations, on the other hand, are kept constant in final stages and slightly lower than in preceding instars. This dominance of glycogen in final instars found in M. lateralis is highly unusual in insects and of potential adaptive significance for the species’ ability to exploit intermittent habitats.

The characterisation of natural stream conditions is the first important step to analyse ecological quality of streams in the Euphrates basin. We found that the community indices correspond to very good ecological conditions in five natural streams of that region. The macroinvertebrates composition differed significantly between September and May. Number of taxa and Shannon index were significantly higher in autumn than in spring. FPOM and biofilm were the most relevant basal resources of benthic invertebrates.

Summary The quantification of periphyton growth in situ poses numerous difficulties. The RNA/DNA ratio is widely used as a growth indicator in marine ecology. We tested its applicability as a growth indicator of periphyton in streams of different sizes. Periphyton-covered stones sampled from two different watercourses during two seasons were exposed in laboratory flumes to different light levels to induce different growth rates. The relationship between rate of biomass accrual and RNA/DNA ratio was analysed by measuring the chlorophyll-a content and the RNA and DNA content of total nucleic acid extract of the periphyton respectively. The RNA/DNA ratios showed a linear relationship with the biomass accrual at all sampling times. The slopes of these relationships varied significantly between the two watercourses, but not between seasons within the same watercourse. These results indicate that the RNA/DNA ratio can be used as a growth indicator for the periphyton studied here. We recommend that it be used to detect differences in growth rate of the same periphyton community either over time or between different treatments in ecological or ecotoxicological experiments. However, for long-term monitoring studies, we recommend taxonomic analyses of the assemblages because the observed differences in the relationship between the RNA/DNA ratio and growth rate might be attributed to community structure differences in the assemblages.

The estuarine maximum turbidity zone (MTZ) can be assumed to be a stressful environment featuring special conditions of great biological importance with an excess of organic matter, high-deposition rates, large variations in salinity, and dredging activities. Under such harsh conditions, populations may remain below the carrying capacity and competition is assumed to be of little importance, as predicted by the stress-gradient hypothesis. Therefore, we hypothesized that invertebrates of similar feeding types may utilize the same resources. To test our hypothesis, we chose the three most abundant taxa classified in literature as deposit feeders (Bathyporeia pilosa, Boccardiella ligerica, Marenzelleria sp.) and two taxa classified as predominately predacious (Palaemon longirostris, Crangon crangon) and determined their isotopic niches based on a stable isotope analysis for the MTZ of the Elbe Estuary (Germany). We expected the isotopic niches of similar feeding types to show a clear overlap if our hypothesis was true. Our results showed that the isotopic niches of no two taxa overlapped within each feeding group, indicating different resource use and the absence of competition. The sediment analysis revealed that two of the deposit feeders inhabited significantly different mean grain sizes. The lack of overlap of isotopic niches within each feeding group may be due to differences in habitat and feeding behavior in the case of the deposit feeders and due to different migration behavior in the case of the predominately predacious species. However, competition may have occurred in the past, resulting in a divergence of feeding niches during evolution.

The prey selectivity of fish depends largely on traits of the prey and the predator. Preferable prey traits might be different for visual predators (such as drift-feeding salmonids) and rather non-visual predators (such as benthic feeders). We evaluated the explanatory power of five prey traits and prey long-term abundance for the prey selection of small benthivorous fish by analysing the macroinvertebrate community and the diet of gudgeon (Gobio gobio) and stone loach (Barbatula barbatula) in two small submontane streams. Fuzzy principal component analyses, as well as electivity indices, revealed that the fish fed selectively. Prey size and feeding type were the most descriptive variables for the fish diet, followed by mean abundance, whereas microhabitat preference, locomotion mode and current velocity preference were less important. The fish preferred prey that was both small and consistently abundant, grazers and sediment feeders. Larger prey and shredders were avoided. The selection patterns of both fish species differed from those of visual fish predators but strongly resembled each other. Supporting this, in gudgeon which feeds slightly more visually than the strictly nocturnal stone loach, selectivity concerning prey traits as well as prey mean abundance was slightly more pronounced. We analyzed also selectivity for prey clusters based on the three most important variables. The observed selectivity patterns concerning these clusters were less pronounced but supported the other results. The maximum (neutral) electivity index was that of gudgeon for small, abundant grazers or sediment feeders, including chironomids. We conclude that prey selection of benthivorous fish that forage mainly non-visually can largely be explained by a small number of prey traits which probably work in combination. The prey preferences of these predators seem to be closely connected to their active foraging mode and to depend partly on the ability to detect prey visually.

Diverse benthic communities in streams include a wide variety of predators with different habitat preferences, e.g. for pools or riffles. We hypothesised that these preferences result in mesohabitat-specific predator community structures with quantitative differences concerning predation intensity by vertebrate and invertebrate predators, importance of intraguild predation, or top–down pressure. This hypothesis was evaluated for a small submontane stream by means of mesohabitat-specific quantification of prey consumption by two benthivorous fish species (Gobio gobio and Barbatula barbatula) and several invertebrate predators. The estimation was based on daily food rations and diet composition of predators and mesohabitat-specific predator biomass. We found clear differences between the two mesohabitat types. Predator food webs were less complex in pools than in riffles. Fish predation was more important than invertebrate predation in pools, and intraguild predation had a higher relative importance in these mesohabitats. These differences were probably caused by the mesohabitat use of G. gobio, the largest top predator, which preferred pools. Consequently, the predator food webs were more similar between the mesohabitats when fish were absent. Top–down pressure on primary consumers by all predators together was lowest in pools without fish, but the effect was not significant. Omnivory (including cannibalism) was intense, but its potentially destabilising effects were probably counterbalanced by mesohabitat connectivity. From the results of our experimental study, we conclude that even in small stream ecosystems, food web structures and predation pathways can differ between mesohabitats and that a mesohabitat-specific consideration will help to explain the variety of top–down effects on benthic communities.

Flexibility is an important adaptive attribute of the feeding periodicity of grazing mayfly larvae because most natural environments offer a wide variation in local predation risk in terms of space, time or predator species. In this study any changes of diel feeding periodicity and consumption rates of Baetis rhodani (Ephemeroptera) were analysed in response to different densities of benthivorous fish ( Barbatula barbatula , Gobio gobio ) by quantifying gut fullness using the fluorescence of algal pigments. Laboratory experiments with the grazer species B. rhodani were conducted by using different concentrations of chemical fish cues. In order to assess the transferability of the results to a larger scale, the experimental results were compared with field observations in two second order streams using different densities of freely foraging benthivorous fish. During the presence of chemical fish cues in the laboratory experiments the feeding periodicity of the B. rhodani larvae were mostly diurnal while in the absence of fish chemicals nocturnal feeding was observed. The same patterns could be detected in the field during the experiments with the different fish densities. These findings indicate that the larvae were able to assess variations in the predation risk and to alter their feeding habits by making flexible behavioural adjustments. The results from the laboratory experiments further suggested that the behavioural response is controlled by fish density. Behavioural changes were observed for medium and high concentrations of the fish cues but not for a very low concentration. In the field however, the mere presence of fish seemed to be sufficient to induce the observed behavioural shifts. Although the presence of benthivorous fish seemed to cause a lower consumption rate of the B. rhodani larvae in the field, such a reduction could not be found in the laboratory experiments. A conclusion from this study is that the identification of behavioural modifications is an essential component needed for a better understanding of complex trophic interactions in benthic communities. Accurate evaluation and detailed observation of direct and indirect effects cannot be made without the consideration of such behavioural mechanisms.

Summary We conducted a paired large-scale predation experiment over 32 months in two streams being seasonally shaded by deciduous riparian trees, using the benthivorous fish species gudgeon (Gobio gobio) and stone loach (Barbatula barbatula) as top predators. The biomass of benthic grazers and periphyton in the presence/absence of fish was measured and the periphyton production was compared with the consumption rates using a model-based approach. A three-level trophic cascade from benthivorous fish via benthic grazers to periphyton was evident from the field experiment. Integrated over the whole study period, fish reduced the biomass of benthic grazers and indirectly increased the periphyton biomass. Scenario analyses, using a simple dynamic model, indicated top-down control of periphyton to be strongest during autumn, when periphyton growth was light-limited, and weaker in the spring, when periphyton growth was not light-limited. The seasonal light supply variation was caused by shading due to deciduous riparian trees during the vegetation period. This asymmetry in temporal processes weakened the top-down control in a natural benthic community. Even though grazer biomass is naturally reduced in summer, due to the emergence of the most abundant species (mayflies), a grazer biomasses high enough to reduce the spring periphyton peak could not be sustained by the low summer periphyton growth. We suppose that the temporal decoupling of grazer biomass from periphyton biomass might be caused by the very short generation time of the primary producers (days) compared with the long generation time of the primary consumers (mostly 1 year).

Omnivory is prevalent in terrestrial and aquatic food webs. However, the extent and seasonality of predatory feeding by omnivores in stream food webs is largely unknown. To understand better these aspects of omnivory in stream food webs, we investigated seasonal changes in the trophic positions of 2 omnivores in a small forested stream. We selected the amphipod, Gammarus pulex, and the caddisfly larvae, Hydropsyche spp., as key organisms because both taxa are common, reach high biomasses in many stream ecosystems, and have broad food spectra. We used stable-isotope analysis of the most prevalent taxa in the benthic macroinvertebrate community to assess the trophic positions of the 2 omnivorous taxa in different seasons. We estimated the degree of predatory feeding by quantifying the importance of different food resources with a stable-isotope mixing model (IsoSource). The predation capacity of omnivores, defined as the fraction of omnivore biomass associated with predation, was compared to the bio...

Regulating mobility by actively entering the drift under imminent predation risk is an avoidance strategy employed by aquatic macroinvertebrate species that is widely accepted within the scientific community. This response was most evident with respect to diurnal predators that feed in the water column, such as many salmonids. We investigated the role of the nocturnal benthivorous gudgeon [Gobio gobio (L.)] on the drift activity of two macroinvertebrate species known to display this behaviour: Baetis rhodani (PICTET) and Gammarus pulex (L.). Laboratory drift experiments using gudgeon kairomones were conducted with the results determining significant altered activity in the presence of gudgeon kairomones for both macroinvertebrate species. B. rhodani showed reduced drift activity in the kairomone treatment compared to the kairomone-free control, with a distinct nocturnal pattern being observed for both. G. pulex shifted from a similar day/night movement pattern to a nocturnal movement pattern with decreased activity during the day. Reduce activity during the day, whilst maintaining normal activity at night would not reduce the probability of encountering a nocturnal predator under natural conditions and therefore appears to not be a meaningful anti-predator response. To assess the relevance of these findings under natural conditions, we compared the experimental results with drift measurements from field observations. These show a significant reduction in drift activity for G. pulex and slight tendencies for reduced night-time drift for B. rhodani, under seasonal variations. We conclude that the behaviour in response to the physical contact or the hydrodynamic stimuli of nocturnal predators is the most likely explanation for the differences between the results from our laboratory experiment and the field observation. We further discuss that the observed migration patterns might have different species specific consequences for density stabilisation on a population level.

Summary 1. We assessed sex-specific seasonal changes in major energy storage compounds (triglycerides, glycogen) in Gammarus fossarum and Gammarus pulex collected from the field, with respect to their reproductive activity. 2. The dynamics of stored energy followed a seasonal pattern in both species and sexes. Moreover, over a 4-year period, these changes were independent of the year in which they were investigated. Stored energy reached a peak in late winter, but was depleted in late summer and early autumn, coinciding with the reproductive periods. 3. Triglyceride (annual mean ± SD) accounted for 79.7 ± 11.9% of the total stored energy and was responsible for the seasonal pattern. In contrast, glycogen contributed a lesser percentage (20.3 ± 11.9%). Over the study period, the amount of stored energy ranged between 0.39 and 4.08 kJ g−1 dry mass (triglyceride: 0.19–3.69 kJ g−1 dry mass; glycogen: 0.14–0.80 kJ g−1 dry mass). 4. In both species, the energy reserves of males were drastically depleted shortly before the cessation of precopulatory mate guarding in the field, thus offering a bioenergetic explanation for the reproductive period in these two widespread species.

Freshwater ecosystems are polluted with various environmental chemicals. For example, pesticides enter the aquatic environment via spray drift or surface runoff from catchment areas used for industrialised agriculture. In the present study, we investigated the response of the grazeraufwuchs interaction when exposed to the herbicide terbutryn in a microcosm experiment. Terbutryn induced a trophic cascade with negative effects on grazers by inhibiting growth of pri- mary producers. We determined a no-observed-effect concentration (measured as particulate organic carbon, NOECPOC) of 0.21 µg l �1 for aufwuchs biomass and a lowest-observed-effect con- centration (LOECPOC) of 2.01 µg l �1 . Furthermore, a shift in the aufwuchs community was detected in all terbutryn treatments nearly 4 wk after exposure, and this shift persisted until the end of the experiment in the treatment with the highest terbutryn concentration. In addition, reduced energy stores (triglycerides, TG) of the grazer Rhithrogena semicolorata (Heptageniidae: Ephemeroptera) were found (NOECTG = 0.03 µg l �1 , LOECTG = 0.21 µg l �1 ), which was interpreted as an indication of moderate starvation during the experiment. While starvation did not result in reduced larval growth as might have been expected, the ob served reduction of TG content in larvae (24%) is consistent with results from a separate experiment in which starvation alone induced a 15% reduction of TG content as well as reduced emergence, reduced size at emergence, and reduced egg production.

Summary 1. The spatial heterogeneity of ecosystems as well as temporal activity patterns of organisms can have far-reaching effects on predator–prey relationships. We hypothesised that spatiotemporal constraints in mesohabitat use by benthic fish predators would reduce habitat overlap with benthic invertebrates and lead to mesohabitat-specific predation risks. 2. We analysed the spatiotemporal activity patterns of two small-bodied benthivorous fishes, gudgeon (Gobio gobio) and stone loach (Barbatula barbatula), and of benthic invertebrates in a small temperate stream during three 24-h field experiments. By applying a novel method of field video observation, we monitored the spatiotemporal foraging behaviour of the fish in their natural environment. A parallel analysis of invertebrate mesohabitat use by means of small area Hess sampling allowed a direct estimation of habitat overlap at a pool–riffle scale. 3. Gudgeon showed a dominant spatial activity pattern preferring pools at all times of day, whereas stone loach used both mesohabitats but with a distinct temporal (nocturnal) activity pattern. The patterns of residence were not identical with those of active foraging. Invertebrate community composition differed significantly between mesohabitats but not between times of day. More than half of the total dissimilarity between pools and riffles was accounted for by six invertebrate taxa. Five of these were subject to higher fish predation in pools than in riffles. The total prey consumption of the two fish species together in pools was about three times as high as in riffles. Trophic niche breadth of stone loach and thus its predation range was broader than that of gudgeon. 4. These results indicate that the potential predation risk for stream invertebrates depends on the combination of spatial and temporal patterns of both predator and prey. Given the distinct differences in predation risk found between pools and riffles, we conclude that spatial heterogeneity at the mesohabitat scale can influence mechanisms and consequences of selective predation. We also suggest that the analysis of spatiotemporal predator–prey relationships should not be based on the premise that the main residence habitat and active foraging habitat of a predator are identical.

Physiological indicators of fitness present a measure of an organism’s response to a changing environment. An analysis of how these organisms allocate and store their energy resources provides an understanding of how they cope with such environmental changes. Each individual has to balance the investment necessary to acquire a certain resource with the energy gained by it. This trade-off can be monitored by measuring several physiological indicators of fitness such as energy storage components, metabolic state or RNA/DNA ratio. Because environmental adaptations and ecological strategies of survival are best examined within the natural environment, our research has to rely on the physiological indicators that are easily accessible in the field. The physiological indicators presented here are significant for an individual’s fitness and in turn lead to reliable values in field-collected samples. Based on our own expertise and on a literature survey, the physiological relevance of the presented indicators is explained. Furthermore, some consideration to the analytical methods used to obtain the physiological indicators is given, and possible errors introduced at the sampling site and during the laboratory procedures are discussed. This work demonstrates that the integration of ecological and physiological expertise facilitates the identification of future ecological problems much earlier than separate approaches of both disciplines alone.

Summary 1. We conducted an experimental study of predation by benthivorous fish on a natural community of stream invertebrates using a reach-scale approach. Over a 2-year period (experimental phase), the benthic invertebrate community of a stretch containing two species of benthivorous fish was compared with a fishless stretch. Thereafter, all fish were removed and benthic community structure was analysed again to account for natural differences between the two stretches (reference phase). 2. Benthivorous fish at the moderate densities investigated did not affect total benthic biomass or density, but did alter species composition. In addition, the fish effect differed between pool and riffle habitats, with larger effects in the pools indicating a habitat-specific predation effect. In the reference phase, when all fish were removed from the stream, the difference between the two stretches was reduced. 3. The benthivorous fish reduced the densities of four taxa (Pisidium sp., Dugesia gonocephala, Gammarus pulex, Limoniidae), representing 29% of total biomass. It is possible that density reductions of other species were masked by prey migration despite the relatively large spatial scale. Indeed, higher drift activity in the upstream fishless stretch could have increased the density of Baetis rhodani in the fish stretch, as indicated by the results of a drift model. 4. Our results provide insights into stream food web ecology because fish predation showed effects even in a natural system where habitat complexity was high, environmental factors were highly variable and many predator and prey species interacted and because benthivorous fish were the focus, whereas the majority of previous predation experiments in streams have used drift-feeding trout.

Defining the reference condition is one of the most critical aspects of ecosystem investigations since it describes the baseline against which the experimental sites will be evaluated and compared. In large-scale ecosystem experiments, this reference is ideally another ecosystem which is similar to the experimental system. We investigated two streams for their potential as experimental sites for a full-size pairwise ecosystem experiment. Temporal (2 years) and spatial (pool, riffle) variabilities of abiotic factors and as biotic element the structure of the macroinvertebrate communities were investigated. Criteria of similarity that we applied at the two streams were: (1) high similarity in abiotic factors, (2) only small differences in the faunal assemblages (abundance structures, composition, feeding types), and (3) that the differences between the two systems should not exceed the temporal and spatial differences within each system. Among the abiotic factors investigated, only the inorganic nutrients (nitrate and soluble reactive phosphorus), major ions (magnesium, calcium), electric conductivity, and pH showed significant differences between the two streams. Discharge rate, current velocity, temperature, and oxygen concentrations did not significantly differ between the streams. Also, the community structure did not differ in species richness, abundance, and biomass; and only small differences in dominance structure and feeding-type composition were observed. The differences between habitats within each stream were always higher than those between the streams. Thus, both the streams are characterized by a similar structure of the macroinvertebrate community, a main component of the stream food-web, which make them suitable for a full size pairwise ecosystem experiment. The present case study can form a basis for other full-size field experiments.

Whole-ecosystem experiments may reach statistical pertinence when reference and treatment sites are compared. Therefore at least two similar systems must be found. To this aim we tried to answer the question if the hyporheic zones of both streams have similar features. We postulated that both streams would be unsuitable for a comparison in an ecosystem experiment if the structure of their hyporheic invertebrate communities differs significantly. Although pH, electrical conductivity and nitrate concentration differed in the surface water, variability of all chemical criteria studied in the hyporheic zones was much lower between the two streams compared to the variability within each stream. Thus the structure of both hyporheic invertebrate communities did not differ significantly. Because of this uniformity both streams are regarded to be suitable for a comparison in a whole-ecosystem experiment.

We investigated lethal and sublethal predation effects of the benthivorous gudgeon (Gobio gobio) on the grazing mayfly Rhithrogena semicolorata and the shredding amphipod Gammarus pulex over 21 months in a largely detritus-based small stream. We hypothesised that shredders are generally less vulnerable to fish predation and therefore less likely to be predation-controlled than grazers, because the latter are visible to the predators during their feeding on stone surfaces, while shredders may hide between leaves during foraging. The hypothesis was tested in two 400 m experimental reaches of a natural stream, which were manipulated in order to contain and to lack fish, respectively. Biomass of G. pulex was significantly reduced in the fish section while that of R. semicolorata was not. Since approximately 91% of the annual production of G. pulex but only 12% of R. semicolorata production was consumed by gudgeon, the observed biomass difference of G. pulex is likely due to a lethal predation effect. However, no sublethal predation effects such as reduced concentration of storage components (triglycerides, glycogen) or reduced reproductive success were observed for both species. Lower mean body length of the R. semicolorata larvae in the fish section did not result in a lower number of eggs in the abdomen of the last instar larvae. Hence, in contrast to our initial hypothesis, in the studied stream the shredder was top-down-controlled, while the grazer was not. It is concluded that top-down control depends on the ecological characteristics of a specific predator–prey pair rather than on trophic guild of the prey.

Many predation experiments in streams are carried out in enclosures. Hence, the relevance of their results to predict population dynamics is often unclear due to the relatively small spatial and temporal scale of the experiments. To enhance the transferability of experimental results on the ecosystem scale the impact of fish predators on a prey population was observed in a reach scale approach over 2 years in a natural stream. A 400-m reach inhabited by the small benthivorous fishes gudgeon ( Gobio gobio ) and stone loach ( Barbatula barbatula ) was compared with a fishless reference reach. It was shown that fish predation may affect the population of the grazing mayfly Rhithrogena semicolorata on the ecosystem scale. Although the larvae grew slower in the fish reach than in the fishless reach, the adults reached the same size and fecundity because they emerged 2–3 weeks later. By this compensation, the prey species avoided a reduction of their individual fecundity. On the other hand, the extended exposure to the fish predators resulted in an enhanced mortality and a reduced density of adult mayflies. Thus, there was obviously a trade-off between maximising fecundity and minimising mortality from fish predation. The observed differences were almost certainly caused be fish predation and not by natural differences of the reaches. This was concluded from results gained after eliminating all benthivorous fish from the former fish reach. With the help of scenario analyses based on our empirical data and simple model assumptions we could demonstrate that compensating the potential loss in fecundity by extending development time led to higher average fitness of the prey population than emerging at an earlier fixed time to avoid additional predation losses. Therefore, we concluded that this strategy was adaptive in the presence of benthivorous fish.