Search

The French Health Products Safety Agency organized in 2005, for the scheme of the national external quality assessment, a survey on antibodies against thyroid constituents which included for the first time the quantitative assay. The purpose of this survey was to assess the quality of the different methods of these assays. The overall qualitative results are satisfactory. However, this survey pointed out a lower performance for immunodot which appeared to have been misused. Concerning the titer of antibodies, results show a broad dispersion between reagents. This confirms the lack of a real standardisation despite of the existence of the international MRC standards.

In 2003, for the scheme of the French national external quality assessment, Afssaps organized for the first time a survey on auto-antibodies detected on liver, kidney and stomach tissues. This survey had two purposes: first to make an inventory of the methodology applied by the medical laboratories and secondly to assess the quality of the results. The survey sample contained M2 anti-mitochondrial antibodies. Overall results are satisfactory. Concerning the titer of antibodies, a broad dispersion of results was observed (12% of titers were upper than the expected titer). Delivered information to the participants, at the end of the survey, should improve analytical procedures applied by the biologists. An effort of standardization by using titrated internal controls would be suitable.

We report the case of a 67-year-old woman in whom onset and regression of acute hepatitis were closely related to the time of administration and withdrawal of the smooth muscle relaxant alverine. Antinuclear antibodies were positive, and their titer followed the course of hepatitis. They presented a smooth rim-like nuclear immunofluorescence staining pattern. Immunoblot assay showed that they were directed against lamin A and lamin C. This suggests that alverine should be added to the list of drugs known to produce acute hepatitis, and that drug-induced liver injury is a possible cause of antinuclear antibodies specific for lamin A and lamin C.

Our objective was to evaluate performance of the clinical laboratories for the detection of antinuclear antibodies (ANA) by using indirect immunofluorescence method (IIF), in France. A national external quality assessment (EQA) on ANA detection was organized by the French health products safety agency once a year since 1998. Between 606 to 687 laboratories together with six university reference laboratories experienced in performing tests in autoimmunity participated in the six-year consecutive survey. Each laboratory had to answer to methodological procedures and give coded responses. Variability in IIF methodological procedure was observed. Use of inappropriate microscope magnifications for reading slides or nonconventional cutoff dilution of serum were pointed out to concerned laboratories. Concerning ANA measurement, the rate of good responses ranged from 92.7% to 99.5% of the laboratories when the samples contained ANA. A wide dispersion of ANA titers obtained on a same sample was repeatly observed every year. Misinterpretation of particular fluorescence pattern was noticed. On ANA negative sample, the rate of good responses was 94.3%. In conclusion, ANA detection in routine practice is far from being standardized. However, EQA may have an impact on ANA detection performance when it is conducted on several consecutive year surveys, by providing advice for participating laboratories to limit inter laboratory variations related to methodological procedures. [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]