Search

To understand whether the distinct VHDJH gene utilization by natural polyreactive Abs reflects the developmentally restricted Ig VHDJH rearrangements putatively expressed by B-1 cells, we generated 11 (8 IgM, 1 IgG3, 2 IgA1), 7 (6 IgM, 1 IgG1), and 7 (2 IgM, 3 IgG1, 2 IgG3) mAb-producing lines using B-1a (surface CD5+, CD45RAlow), B-1b (surface CD5-, CD45RAlow, CD5 mRNA+), and B-2 (surface CD5-, CD45RAhigh, CD5 mRNA-) cells, respectively, sorted from adult human peripheral blood. Most B-1a and B-1b, but no B-2, cell-derived mAbs were polyreactive; i.e., they bound different self and foreign Ags with different affinities. B-1a and B-2 mAbs preferentially utilized VH4 (p = 0.003) and VH3 (p = 0.010) genes, respectively. All three mAb populations utilized DXP, DLR, DN DH genes, and JH6, but no mAb utilized DHQ52. There were fewer unencoded nucleotide (N) additions in the VHDJH junctions of B-1b (3.00 +/- 2.52, mean +/- SD) than of B-1a (12.45 +/- 3.93, p = 1.23 x 10(-5)) or B-2 (8.29 +/- 4.75, p = 0.020) mAbs. Partly due to the fewer N additions and a paucity of D-D fusions, the B-1b mAb CDR3s were significantly shorter than the B-1a mAb CDR3s (p = 0.013), which contained a nonrandom Tyr distribution (p = 0.003). Finally, all but two B-1 cell-derived mAbs were mutated, in a fashion similar to that of the Ag-selected B-2 mAbs. Thus, in the human adult, B-1 cells that make natural polyreactive Abs may not be representative of the predominantly B-1 developmental waves of colonization of the fetal and neonatal B cell repertoires, and are somatically selected.

The delineation of distinct subsets committed to the production of antibodies with different antigen-binding activities supports the view of a compartmentalization and specialization of function in the B cell repertoire and is consistent with the hypothesis of a developmentally layered immune system; as originally proposed by Herzenberg and Herzenberg. On the basis of the data by Solvason and Kearney in the human fetus and our data in the adult, and in agreement with the findings of Herzenberg et al. and Hardy et al. in the mouse, we propose that the human B cell repertoire includes at least three distinct B cell subsets: B-1a cells, which develop from progenitors in the fetal splanchnic district, namely the omentum, and are maintained in adult life by virtue of their self-replenishing nature; B-1b cells, progenitors of which can be found in the splanchnic district and, perhaps, adult bone marrow; and, finally, B-2 cells, which arise in the fetal liver and are continuously replenished in adult life by progenitors in the bone marrow (Figure 5). The different B cells types are distinguished by their differential expression of surface CD5 and, perhaps, CD11b and CD14, their differential expression of CD5 mRNA, and the different classes and specificities of the Ig they produce (Figure 5). B-1 lymphocytes play a major role in autoimmunity and constitute the physiological equivalent of the neoplastic forms in various lymphoproliferative disorders, such as CLL and SLL, which are often associated with the production of monoclonal antibodies to self antigens. Human B-1a (CD5+ B) and B-1b (CD5- CD45RAlo B) cells are responsible for the production of natural (polyreactive and monoreactive) antibodies in the fetus, neonate, and adult, and can give rise to the autoantibody-producing cells characteristic of several autoimmune disease states. Our recent findings suggest that while in healthy subjects the majority of natural polyreactive antibodies is encoded in V genes in germline configuration, some polyreactive antibodies are encoded in somatically mutated V genes, in a fashion consistent with an antigen-driven process of selection of such mutations. The nature of the antigen(s) involved in these selection processes remains to be determined. Under possibly different circumstances, the application of an antigen-driven process of clonal selection to B-1a and/or B-1b cells, previously committed to natural antibody production, can result in the generation of monoreactive high affinity and possibly pathogenic autoantibodies (Figures 5A and 5B).(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

The production of "natural" autoantibodies or antibodies, i.e., Ig that bind a variety of self- and/or exogenous Ag and arise independently of known immunization, is though to be a feature of CD5+ B lymphocytes. To determine whether other lymphocyte subsets exist that might be committed to the production of natural antibodies, human peripheral blood B cells were sorted on the basis of surface CD5 expression and differential expression of surface CD45RA (CD5+CD45RAintermediate(int), CD5-CD45RAlow(lo), and CD5-CD45RAhigh(hi)), and analyzed for the type of Ig produced after EBV infection and culture. Like their CD5+ counterparts, most CD5-CD45RAlo B lymphocytes were precursors of cells producing IgM, a major proportion of which displayed the Ag-binding features of natural antibodies. In contrast, CD5-CD45RAhi B cells comprised a high frequency of IgG-producing cell precursors, possibly including memory B lymphocytes. Six of seven IgM mAb generated from sorted CD5-CD45RAlo B cells and three of four IgM mAb from sorted CD5+ B cells were polyreactive, binding with different affinities (Kd, 10(-5) to 10(-8) M) to two or more Ag; the remaining mAb from CD5-CD45RAlo and the mAb from CD5+ B cells each bound to a single Ag (Kd, 10(-7) to 10(-8) M), beta-galactosidase and ssDNA, respectively. CD5-CD45RAlo B cells account for 4.1 +/- 1.2% (mean +/- SD in 11 healthy subjects; CD5+ B cells, 23.3 +/- 6.9%) of total B lymphocytes and display the features of quiescent cells. In a given individual, the number of CD5-CD45RAlo B cells remains constant over time. CD5-CD45RAlo and CD5+ B cells bear surface CD11b and CD14, at densities and/or frequencies apparently higher than those of CD5-CD45RAhi B lymphocytes. Despite their surface CD5- phenotype, CD45RAlo B cells express CD5+ mRNA at levels comparable with those of CD5+ B lymphocytes, whereas CD5-CD45RAhi B cells express only trace amounts of CD5 mRNA. The commitment to natural antibody production and the degree of CD5 mRNA expression suggest that the newly defined CD5-CD45RAlo B cell subset is related to CD5+ B lymphocytes, and may constitute the human homologue of the mouse Ly-1-"sister" B cell population.