1. Efficacy, economics, and sustainability of bio-based insecticides from thermochemical biorefineries
- Author
-
Mark R. Nimlos, Kylee Harris, Earl Christensen, Juan Huang, Joshua A. Schaidle, Scott R. Nicholson, Stefano Dell’Orco, Jacquelyn A Perkins, Kristiina Iisa, Matthew J. Grieshop, Joseph Roback, Abhijit Dutta, A. Nolan Wilson, David Chiaramonti, and John R. Dorgan
- Subjects
Integrated pest management ,Waste management ,business.industry ,Agrochemical ,fungi ,food and beverages ,Biomass ,Biorefinery ,Pollution ,Biofuel ,Sustainability ,Food processing ,Environmental Chemistry ,Environmental science ,Agricultural productivity ,business - Abstract
The scope of this work rests at the interface between food and energy sustainability. Thermochemical conversion of biomass is an attractive strategy for the production of low-cost biofuels, and bio-based insecticides are a more sustainable and often safer alternative for pest management in agricultural production. This work demonstrates a complimentary strategy to access both biofuels and a bio-based insecticide through a catalytic fast pyrolysis process. Technoeconomic modeling shows the bioinsecticidebio-based insecticide can be produced at a cost ≤1.7$ per kg while fully formulated bioinsecticidebio-based insecticides typically sell for ≥6$ per kg, which can significantly reduce the biofuel selling price. Supply chain analysis shows a 46–88% reduction in green-house gas emissions for this agrochemical can be achieved. By using insecticidal activity data from two well-known crop pests, spotted-wing drosophila (Drosophila suzukii, Matsumura) and oriental fruit moth (Grapholita molesta, Herbst), with an analytical analysis, which achieved ≥99% mass balance closure on the thermochemically derived distillate product, a structure–function relationship between phenol alkylation and insecticidal activity is proposed. An ecotoxicological assessment of the bio-based insecticide was performed using existing data and prediction tools across 18 metrics. It is estimated that a 2000 tonne per day biorefinery can supply 1–5% of the market, which is typical for other moderately scaled chemicals. The mixture of alkylated phenols, used as a bio-based insecticide, is an ideal coproduct that overcomes separation challenges associated with thermochemical streams, such as heterogeneity and reactivity, while providing a more sustainable source for agrochemicals. Synergistic strategies for energy and food production, such as coproduction of bio-based insecticides with biofuels, can be a viable approach to improve sustainability in both sectors.
- Published
- 2021
- Full Text
- View/download PDF