Search

H146-like goose-origin calicivirus (H146-like GCV) is a novel Caliciviridae family member in the Sanovirus genus that was recently discovered and proposed to cause runting-stunting syndrome and urate deposition in geese. At present, however, there is a lack of epidemiological information pertaining to the dynamics and distribution of H146-like GCV. The development of novel molecular diagnostic approaches capable of rapidly and accurately detecting this virus would support the strengthening, the prevention, and control of H146-like GCV infection. In the present study, we therefore used a TaqMan probe and primers specific for the viral nonstructural (NS) gene to develop a highly sensitive and specific PCR assay capable of detecting this H146-like GCV. The assay reproducibly detected 5.07 × 102 copies of a recombinant DNA plasmid containing the NS gene, with a dynamic range of 8 orders of magnitude (102–109 copies). Importantly, no cross-reactivity was observed with common viruses that affected waterfowl, and when we used this assay to evaluate clinical samples, we found it to be more sensitive and faster than traditional PCR. In summary, herein, we developed a novel TaqMan-based real-time PCR approach that could reliably detect and diagnose H146-like GCV. This tool will allow for the real-time diagnosis of H146-like GCV infections, enabling researchers to better understand the epidemiology and clinical presentation of this disease.

Duckling short beak and dwarfism syndrome virus (SBDSV), an emerging goose parvovirus, has caused short beak and dwarfism syndrome (SBDS) in Chinese duck flocks since 2015. Presently, there is no commercial vaccine against SBDS. In the present study, a virus-like particle (VLP)-based candidate vaccine was developed against this disease. A baculovirus expression system was used to express the SBDSV VP2 protein in Sf9 cells. Immunofluorescence assay, sodium dodecyl sulphate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) and Western blotting were used to confirm protein expression. Furthermore, transmission electron microscopy was used to observe the formation of VLPs. VLPs were formulated into an oil-adjuvanted maternal vaccine to evaluate humoral responses in breeding ducks via latex particle agglutination inhibition assay (LPAI) and microneutralization assay. The offspring were challenged with SBDSV to test the protective efficacy. A single dose of SBDSV was able to induce the high level of LPAI antibodies in ducks, with LPAI and neutralization peak titres of 4.9 ± 1.20 log2 and 7.1 ± 1.20 log2, respectively, at 4 weeks post-vaccination (wpv). The average LPAI titre of yolk antibodies in duck eggs receiving 2 doses (first and boost doses) of the vaccine was 5.3 ± 1.09 log2 at 4 weeks post-boost. The protective efficacy of the maternal vaccine was 87.5%-100%. These results indicate that SBDSV VLPs can be a promising vaccine candidate for controlling SBDS.

Muscovy duck reovirus (MDRV) is highly pathogenic to young Muscovy ducklings. Although MDRV infection results in ducklings' acute watery diarrhea, the effect of MDRV infection on the composition of host's intestinal microbiota remains poorly understood. This study was conducted to investigate the impacts of MDRV on the composition of Muscovy ducklings' intestinal bacterial community. Three-day-old Muscovy ducklings were inoculated with either the virulent MDRV strain MW9710 or sterile Hank's solution, respectively. The cecal microbiota was analyzed between control and mock MDRV-infected ducklings using Illumina MiSeq sequencing at 6 dpi and 17 dpi, respectively. The results indicated that MDRV infection damaged the intestinal mucosa. In addition, MDRV infection caused severe perturbations of gut microbiota by decreasing microbial richness, altering the abundance of certain genera of the gut microbiota at 6 dpi. Specifically, the relative abundance of short chain fatty acids-producing bacteria (including Shuttleworthia, Streptococcus, and Ruminococcus) was reduced in MDRV-infected ducklings than those of control group, whereas, with an enrichment of Enterobacteriaceae (including Plesiomonas, Escherichia_Shigella and Proteus). Furthermore, microbiota analysis showed that the gut microbiota dysbiosis caused by MDRV infection was basically recovered at 17 dpi. Collectively, this study demonstrated that the gut microbiota of Muscovy ducklings were altered due to MDRV infection, mainly featuring as a net loss of beneficial bacteria and a compensatory proliferation of pathogenic bacteria, which may lead to severe pathology to the intestinal mucosa, and ultimately acute diarrhea. These results will provide insights into the pathology of MDRV infection.

The Muscovy duck reovirus (MDRV) is a highly pathogenic virus that causes substantial economic losses in the Muscovy duck industry. While MDRV poses a significant threat to Muscovy ducklings, no vaccine candidates are available to date to alleviate MDRV infection throughout the world. The present study presents efforts toward establishing an attenuated vaccine for MDRV. For this purpose, a live attenuated vaccine strain named CA was obtained via alternate propagation of the MDRV isolate MW9710 in both Muscovy duck embryo fibroblasts (MDEFs) and chicken embryo fibroblasts (CEFs) for 90 passages. The CA strain achieved an adaptive growth capacity in CEFs with a viral titer that ranged between 105.0–105.5 TCID50/100 μL and lost its pathogenicity in 1-day-old Muscovy ducklings. Compared to the parent strain MW9710, the CA strain has 42 scattered amino acid substitutions, most of which are located in the λB, λC, μB, σB, and σC protein. The CA strain maintained its attenuation and showed no gene mutation or virulence reversion after back propagation into 1-day-old ducklings for five rounds. The minimum protective dose was calculated to be 300 TCID50 of the CA strain. Furthermore, a single dose of CA vaccine protected immunized ducklings against lethal challenge by the virulent MDRV strain MW9710 and significantly decreased viral loads. In summary, the CA strain exhibited striking genetic stability, excellent safety, and effective immunogenicity. This CA strain of MDRV is a promising vaccine candidate for the prevention and control of MDRV infection.

H146-like goose-origin calicivirus (H146-like GCV) is a novel Caliciviridae family member in the Sanovirus genus that was associated with gosling growth retardation syndrome growth retardation syndrome complicated by visceral urate deposition. However, there is no accurate and high throughput real-time quantitative reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (qRT-PCR) available for the rapid and highly sensitive identification of H146-like GCV. In this study, a pair of specific primers and a TaqMan minor groove binder (MGB) probe were designed based on a conserved region in the nonstructural (NS) gene sequence. The TaqMan-MGB probe-based one-step qRT-PCR assay was capable of detecting quite low number of targeting nucleic acid as low as 5.07 copies/μL and had excellent intra-assay and inter-assay repeatability with the coefficient of variation (CV) value from 0.558% to 1.293%. The assay was highly specific for H146-like GCV, without cross-reactions with other non-targeted goose-origin viruses, and 62 suspicious tissue samples infected with H146-like GCV from different regions of Fujian Province were used in this study to verify the feasibility and effectiveness of this assay in clinical diagnosis. The results indicated that our assay for the diagnosis and quantification of H146-like GCV was highly sensitive and specific, and should provide a reliable real-time tool for epidemiological and pathogenetic study of H146-like GCV infection, enabling researchers to better understand the epidemiology and clinical presentation of this disease.

Muscovy duck reovirus (MDRV) belongs to the Orthoreovirus genus of the Reoviridae family, which is a significant poultry pathogen leading to high morbidity and mortality in ducklings. However, the pathogenesis of the virus is not well understood. In the present study, two-dimensional (2D) polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (PAGE) combined with LC-MS-MS was used to identify differentially expressed proteins between Muscovy duck embryo fibroblasts (MDEF) infected with virulent (MV9710 strain) and attenuated (CA strain) MDRV and non-infected MDEFs. A total of 115 abundant protein spots were identified. Of these, 59 of differentially expressed proteins were detected, with functions in metabolism and utilization of carbohydrates and nucleotides, anti-stress, and regulation of immune and cellular process. GO analysis of the identified proteins showed that they belonged to the classes molecular function (141 proteins), cellular component (62 proteins), and biological process (146 proteins). The results were validated by qRT-PCR, which suggests that the analysis method of 2D PAGE combined with LC-MS-MS used in this study is reliable. This study lays a foundation for further investigation of the biology of MDRV infection in MDEF.

Background Waterfowl parvoviruses, including goose parvovirus (GPV) and Muscovy duck parvovirus (MDPV), can cause seriously diseases in geese and ducks. Developing a fast and precise diagnosis assay for these two parvoviruses is particularly important. Results A duplex SYBR Green I-based quantitative real-time PCR assay was developed for the simultaneous detection and differentiation of GPV and MDPV. The assay yielded melting curves with specific single peak (Tm = 87.3 ± 0.26 °C or Tm = 85.4 ± 0.23 °C) when GPV or MDPV was evaluated, respectively. When both parvoviruses were assessed in one reaction, melting curves with specific double peaks were yielded. Conclusion This duplex quantitative RT-PCR can be used to rapid identify of GPV and MDPV in field cases and artificial trials, which make it a powerful tool for diagnosing, preventing and controlling waterfowl parvovirus infections.

Many mule duck and Cherry Valley duck flocks in different duck-producing regions of China have shown signs of an apparently new disease designated "short beak and dwarfism syndrome" (SBDS) since 2015. The disease is characterized by dyspraxia, weight loss, a protruding tongue, and high morbidity and low mortality rates. In order to characterize the etiological agent, a virus designated SBDSV M15 was isolated from allantoic fluid of dead embryos following serial passage in duck embryos. This virus causes a cytopathic effect in duck embryo fibroblast (DEF) cells. Using monoclonal antibody diagnostic assays, the SBDSV M15 isolate was positive for the antigen of goose parvovirus but not Muscovy duck parvovirus. A 348-bp (2604-2951) VP1gene fragment was amplified, and its sequence indicated that the virus was most closely related to a Hungarian GPV strain that was also isolated from mule ducks with SBDS disease. A similar disease was reproduced by inoculating birds with SBDSV M15. Together, these data indicate that SBDSV M15 is a GPV-related parvovirus causing SBDS disease and that it is divergent from classical GPV isolates.

To determine the origin and evolution of goose parvovirus (GPV) and Muscovy duck parvovirus (MDPV) in the Mainland of China, phylogenetic and recombination analyses in the present study were performed on 32 complete VP1 gene sequences from China and other countries. Based on the phylogenetic analysis of the VP1 gene, GPV strains studied here from Mainland China (PRC) could be divided into three genotypes, namely PRC-I, PRC-II and PRC-III. Genotype PRC-I is indigenous to Mainland China. Only one GPV strain from Northeast China was of Genotype PRC-II and was thought to be imported from Europe. Genotype PRC-III, which was the most isolated genotype during 1999-2012, is related to GPVs in Taiwan and has been the predominant pathogen responsible for recent Derzy's disease outbreaks in Mainland China. Current vaccine strains used in Mainland China belong to Genotype PRC-I that is evolutionary distant from Genotypes PRC-II and PRC-III. In comparison, MDPV strains herein from Mainland China are clustered in a single group which is closely related to Taiwanese MDPV strains, and the full-length sequences of the VP1 gene of China MDPVs are phylogenetic closely related to the VP1 sequence of a Hungarian MDPV strain. Moreover, We also found that homologous recombination within VP1 gene plays a role in generating genetic diversity in GPV evolution. The GPV GDFSh from Guangdong Province appears to be the evolutionary product of a recombination event between parental GPV strains GD and B, while the major parent B proved to be a reference strain for virulent European GPVs. Our findings provide valuable information on waterfowl parvoviral evolution in Mainland China.

The complete sequence of a reovirus, strain NP03 associated with necrotic focus formation in the liver and spleen of Muscovy ducklings in Fujian Province, China in 2009, was determined and compared with sequences of other waterfowl and chicken-origin avian reoviruses (ARVs). Sequencing of the complete genomes of strain NP03 showed that they consisted of 23,418 bp and were divided into 10 segments, ranging from 1191 bp (S4) to 3959 bp (L1) in length, and all segments contained conserved sequences in the 5' non-coding region (GCUUUU) and 3' non-coding region (UCAUC). Pairwise sequence comparisons demonstrated that NP03 strain showed the highest similarity with novel waterfowl origin reoviruses (WRVs). The genome analysis revealed that the S1 segment of novel WRV is a tricistronic gene, encoding the overlapping open reading frames (ORFs) for p10, p18, and σC, similar to the ARV S1 gene, but distinct from classical WRV S4 genome segment, which contained two overlapping ORFs encoding p10 and σC. Phylogenetic analyses of the nucleotide sequences of all 10 segments revealed that NP03 strain was clustered together with other novel WRVs and were distinct from classical WRVs and chicken-origin ARVs. The analyses also showed possible intra-segmental reassortment events in the segments encoding λA, λB, μB, μNS, σA, and σNS between novel and classical WRVs. Potential recombination events detection in segment L1 suggests that NP03 strain may be recombinants of novel WRVs. Based on our genetic analyses, multiple reassortment events, intra-segmental recombination, and accumulation of point mutations have possibly contributed to the emergence of this novel genotype of WRV, identified in China.

A real-time reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR) for the detection of Muscovy duck reovirus (MDRV) RNA in clinical samples is described. The assay is based on TaqMan-MGB technology, consisting of two primers and one probe labeled with the reporter dye 6-carboxyfluorescein that binds selectively to the sigma B-protein gene of MDRV. This technique also includes an Internal Positive Control (IPC). The real-time RT-PCR assay was able to detect MDRVs, whereas other common waterfowl-origin viral pathogens were not recognised by the established oligonucleotide set, thus showing that the test was specific for MDRV. The sensitivity of the assay was 2.83 × 101 copies/μL and was 100 times higher than that of the conventional RT-PCR. The variation coefficients of intra-assay and inter-assay were less than 1.5% which verified sufficient repeatability of this assay. The use of β-actin mRNA as an IPC in order not to reduce the efficiency of the assay was adopted. The detection for 100 clinical samples showed that the positive rate of the established TaqMan-MGB real-time RT-PCR method was 87% (87/100), while the positive rate of the conventional RT-PCR was 83% (83/100), with the coincidence rate was 97.14%. Sensitivity and positive rate for clinical samples of TaqMan fluorescent quantitative RT-PCR were higher than conventional RT-PCR. The high specificity, sensitivity, and rapidity TaqMan-MGB real-time RT-PCR assay with the use of IPC to monitor for false negative results can make this method suitable for the pathogenic surveillance and epidemiological investigation of MDRV infection.

An unclassified calicivirus (CV) detected in geese was recently reported and proposed as a new member of the family Caliciviridae. There is limited information about the epidemiology, etiology and detection method of goose-origin CV (GCV) to date. In this study, an EvaGreen based fluorescence quantitative real-time RT-PCR assay was developed and optimized for the detection of GCVs. The assay sensitively detected GCV RNA template with a good linear standard curve. We also demonstrated the specificity and reproducibility of the detection method for GCVs. Thus, the method developed in this study will benefit the investigation of possible sporadic outbreaks of CV infections in geese, as well as epidemiological and etiological studies of GCVs.

Duckling short beak and dwarfism syndrome virus (SBDSV), a newly identified goose parvovirus, causes devastating disease in domestic waterfowl and considerable economic losses to Chinese waterfowl industry. The molecular pathogenesis of SBDSV infection, nature and dynamics of host immune responses against SBDSV infection remained elusive. In this study, we systematically explored the relative mRNA expression profiles of major innate immune-related genes in SBDSV infected duck embryo fibroblasts. We found that SBDSV infection effectively activated host innate immune responses and resulted in significant up-regulation of IFN-β and several vital IFN-stimulated genes (ISGs). These up-regulation responses were mainly attributed to viral genomic DNA and dsRNA replication intermediates. Importantly, the expression of cGAS was significantly induced, whereas the expression of other DNA receptors including DDX41, STING, ZBP1, LSM14A and LRRFIP1 have no significant change. Furthermore, SBDSV infection also activates the up-regulation of TLR3 and inhibited the expression of TLR2 and TLR4; however, no effect was observed on the expression of TLR1, TLR5, TLR7, TLR15 and TLR21. Intriguingly, SBDSV infection significantly up-regulated the expression of RNA sensors such as MDA5 and LGP2, and resulted in a delayed but significant up-regulation of RIG-I gene. Taken together, these data indicate that host multiple sensors including DNA sensor (cGAS) and RNA sensors (TLR3, MDA5 and LGP2) are involved in recognizing a variety of different pathogen associated molecular patterns (PAMPs) including viral genomic ssDNA and dsRNA replication intermediates, which trigger an effective antiviral innate immune response.

Novel duck reovirus (NDRV) is pathogenic to young ducks, which is characterized by hemorrhagic spots and necrotic foci of the livers and necrotic foci of spleens. However, the effect of NDRV infection on the composition of the host's intestinal microbiota remains poorly understood. In this study, three-day-old Muscovy ducklings were inoculated with either the virulent NDRV strain NP03 or sterile Hank's solution. Through Illumina MiSeq sequencing, the whole cecal microbiota of healthy and NDRV infected ducklings was examined. The results showed that the gut microbiota was mainly dominated by Firmicutes, Proteobacteria and Bacteroidestes in both healthy and NDRV infected ducks. NDRV infection altered the relative abundance of bacteria. Specifically, families Ruminococcaceae and Lachnospiraceae were remarkably reduced, whereas Escherichia_Shigella belonging to family Enterobacteriaceae was significantly increased. Collectively, NDRV infection in Muscovy ducks resulted in a shift of the gut microbiota, including a net loss of probiotic bacteria with a compensatory expansion of pathogenic bacteria. These results provide new insights into the potential pathogenic mechanisms of NDRV.

To obtain a deletion mutant of Muscovy duck-origin goose parvovirus (MDGPV) and to analyze its biological characteristics, the pMDGPVPT plasmid, which contains a full-length DNA infectious clone of the MDGPV PT strain, was used in this study as the template. The E-box at nt 315 of the left inverted terminal repeat sequence (L-ITR) was deleted by overlap extension PCR to obtain the infectious recombinant plasmid p-PTΔE315. The p-PTΔE315 plasmid was transfected into 9-day-old non-immune Muscovy duck embryos via the yolk sac and the rescued deletion mutant virus r-PTΔE315 was generated. Experiments to demonstrate the novel deletion mutant virus' biological characteristics showed that r-PTΔE315 can cause typical lesions after infection of Muscovy duck embryos. Compared with its parent strain PT, the virulence of r-PTΔE315 and its proliferation ability in Muscovy duck embryos were attenuated, but its ability to replicate in MDEF cells was enhanced. This study laid the foundation for further understanding of the relationship between E-box deletion in the L-ITR and MDGPV virulence.

Muscovy duck-origin goose parvovirus (MDGPV) is a causative agent of MDGPV-associated Derzsy's disease. To evalute the role of the cis-acting element E-box (CACATG) deletion on MDGPV eplication, an infectious plasmid clone p-PTΔE287, having one E-box deletion at nucleotide (nt) 287 of the left inverted terminal repeat sequence (L-ITR), was constructed by overlap extension PCR deleting the 287CACATG292 motif from the plasmid pMDGPVPT containing the full-length genome of the virulent MDGPV strain PT. The p-PTΔE287 plasmid was transfected into 9-day-old non-immune Muscovy duck embryos via the yolk sac, resulting in successful rescue of the deletion mutant virus r-PTΔE287. Compared with its parental virus PT, the virulence and the replication ability of r-PTΔE287 were reduced. In addition, we examined the ability of r-PTΔE287 to manipulate cell cycle progression. The results showed that r-PTΔE287 replication results in G0/G1 phase accumulation of infected duck embryo liver mesenchymal stem cells (BMSCs) and that this accumulation is caused by the prevention of cell cycle entry from G0/G1 phase into S phase. Taken together, introducing 287CACATG292 element deletion into MDGPV PT genomic DNA that induced rescued mutant virus (r-PTΔE287) cell cycle arrest function at the G0/G1 phase, which might inhibit MDGPV replication and virus progeny production. This study laid the foundation for further understanding of the relationship between E-box deletion in the L-ITR and MDGPV virulence.

Short beak and dwarfism syndrome virus (SBDSV) is a newly emerging distinct duck-origin goose parvovirus that belongs to the genus Dependovirus. Our previous studies have found that SBDSV was highly pathogenic to Cherry Valley ducklings and mule ducklings. However, little is known about its pathogenicity to other waterfowls. In the present study, the pathogenicity of SBDSV was evaluated in domesticated waterfowl including Muscovy ducklings, Sheldrake ducklings and domestic goslings. All experimentally infected birds exhibited remarkable growth retardation, anorexia and diarrhea similar to naturally infected birds. Interestingly, atrophic beaks and protruded tongues were not observed in all infection groups. At necropsies, no diagnostic pathological lesions were observed. Viral antigens existed in most organ tissues such as heart, liver, spleen, kidney, pancreas and intestine. All ducks in Muscovy duckling and Sheldrake duckling infected groups and 70% goslings in infected groups were seropositive for goose parvovirus (GPV) antibodies at 21dpi with the average titers as 28.4, 26.9, 24.0, respectively. Muscovy ducklings were more prominent in viral load and weight loss with a higher GPV antibodies titer than Sheldrake ducklings and goslings. Taken together, SBDSV exhibits a wide range of pathogenicity to main domesticated waterfowl with variable symptoms and cause considerable economic losses in China.

To investigate the possible role of recombination in the evolution of Muscovy duck parvovirus (MDPV) and goose parvovirus (GPV) in Taiwan, we analyzed a potentially significant recombination event that occurred only in GPV by comparing thirteen complete sequences of the capsid gene VP2 of GPV and MDPV. The recombination event occurred between GPV strain 06-0239 as the minor parent and strains 99-0808 as the major parent, which resulted in the GPV recombinant V325/TW03. GPV V325/TW03 is likely to represent a new genotype among the Taiwanese GPV strains. This represents the first evidence that intergenotype recombination within the VP2 gene cluster contributes to the genetic diversity of the VP2 genes of Taiwanese GPV field strains.

Tembusu virus (TMUV) has been a causative agent of an acute egg-drop syndrome found in Chinese duck populations since at least 2010. In this paper, we report the characterization of a TMUV-like flavivirus (named CJD05) isolated from naturally infected egg-laying fowl. The virus was identified and then isolated from hens suffering from severe egg drop and fever in Fujian Province, China. The virus replicated well in MDEF and CEF cells, and its cytopathogenic effect (CPE) was apparent. Hemagglutinating activity (HA) was negative for this virus using erythrocytes from both chickens and pigeons. Viral particles were enveloped and approximately 45 nm in diameter, as observed by electron microscopy. Phylogenetic analysis of the full-length nucleotide sequence of CJD05 indicated that this virus is closely related to the duck-origin TMUV, belonging to Ntaya group of flavivirus. Most importantly, pathogenicity studies showed that CJD05 is highly virulent in 1-day-old chicks, 1-day-old Muscovy ducks, egg-laying chickens and shelducks. Our research highlights the increase in epidemic disease caused by avian TMUV, and subsequent outbreaks are becoming more complicated to treat. The pathogenic mechanisms of the virus are still not fully understood, further research is needed.

We report a novel goose parvovirus (MDGPV/PT) isolated from an affected Muscovy duck in Fujian Province, China. In this study, the NS1 sequence analyses indicated a close genetic relationship between MDGPV/PT and Muscovy duck parvovirus (MDPV) strains, although MDGPV/DY, which was isolated from a Muscovy duck in 2006 in Sichuan Province, could be divided into GPV-related groups. Phylogenetic analysis showed that except for differences in the NS1 gene, MDGPV strains PT and DY are closely related to a parvovirus that infects domestic waterfowls. This is the first demonstration of recombination between goose and Muscovy duck parvoviruses in nature, and MDGPV/PT might have led to the generation of a novel waterfowl parvovirus strain circulating in Muscovy duck flocks in China.

Poultry Flavivirus (PF) was a recently emerged virus with high morbidity rates and mortality rates in China. It is the causative agent of egg drop syndrome at present. Development of the reverse transcription loop-mediated isothermal amplification (RT-LAMP) assay was the most efficient way to prevent and control the PF disease. The assay was performed at 64 °C for 45 min, using six specific primers that recognized eight targets of the PF E gene. The RT-LAMP assay, compared to conventional reverse transcription polymerase chain reaction, has 100-fold-greater sensitivity, with a detection limit of 1 × 10(-3) copies per μL RNA and no cross-reaction with poultry other viruses. The RT-LAMP assay is a valuable tool for detected PF without requiring any sophisticated equipment, and the detection has potential usefulness for clinical diagnosis in the field.

We read with particular attention the article “Isolation and Characterization of Porcine Epidemic Diarrhea Viruses Associated with the 2013 Disease Outbreak among Swine in the United States” by Chen and colleagues, published in January 2014 in the Journal of Clinical Microbiology. Chen et al. proposed that the full-length spike (S) gene or the S1 portion of it is a suitable phylogenetic marker to reflect evolutionary relationships between emergent U.S. and Chinese strains of porcine epidemic diarrhea viruses (PEDVs). This viewpoint proposed by the authors deserves more discussion.