1. Limitations of a Metabolic Network-Based Reverse Ecology Method for Inferring Host–Pathogen Interactions
- Author
-
Kazuhiro Takemoto and Kazuki Aie
- Subjects
0301 basic medicine ,Insecta ,Metabolic network ,Computational biology ,Metabolic networks ,Biology ,lcsh:Computer applications to medicine. Medical informatics ,Biochemistry ,Genome ,03 medical and health sciences ,User-Computer Interface ,0302 clinical medicine ,Structural Biology ,Oxygen breathing ,RNA, Ribosomal, 16S ,Animals ,Humans ,Reverse ecology ,Molecular Biology ,Genome size ,lcsh:QH301-705.5 ,Phylogeny ,Internet ,Bacteria ,Ecology ,Applied Mathematics ,Fungi ,Plants ,Computer Science Applications ,030104 developmental biology ,Logistic Models ,ROC Curve ,lcsh:Biology (General) ,Area Under Curve ,Host-Pathogen Interactions ,lcsh:R858-859.7 ,Species–species interactions ,Systems biology ,030217 neurology & neurosurgery ,Metabolic Networks and Pathways ,Research Article - Abstract
Background Host–pathogen interactions are important in a wide range of research fields. Given the importance of metabolic crosstalk between hosts and pathogens, a metabolic network-based reverse ecology method was proposed to infer these interactions. However, the validity of this method remains unclear because of the various explanations presented and the influence of potentially confounding factors that have thus far been neglected. Results We re-evaluated the importance of the reverse ecology method for evaluating host–pathogen interactions while statistically controlling for confounding effects using oxygen requirement, genome, metabolic network, and phylogeny data. Our data analyses showed that host–pathogen interactions were more strongly influenced by genome size, primary network parameters (e.g., number of edges), oxygen requirement, and phylogeny than the reserve ecology-based measures. Conclusion These results indicate the limitations of the reverse ecology method; however, they do not discount the importance of adopting reverse ecology approaches altogether. Rather, we highlight the need for developing more suitable methods for inferring host–pathogen interactions and conducting more careful examinations of the relationships between metabolic networks and host–pathogen interactions. Electronic supplementary material The online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12859-017-1696-7) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.
- Published
- 2017
- Full Text
- View/download PDF