Abstract: Breeding site selection can be linked to population dynamics through pre-emptive site selection, by which an individual selects the best (in terms of fitness) available site, preventing others from sharing it. We examined the pattern of territorial settlement and its fitness consequences during a study of sedge warblers Acrocephalus schoenobaenus inhabiting two study plots in the Nida Wetlands (southern Poland). Throughout all 7 years of the study (1997–2003), male sedge warblers repeatedly occupied sites in sequence from best to worst, according to the amount of cover by reedmace and common reed on one plot, and the amount of common reed on the other plot. As individuals aged, they occupied sites with increasingly higher proportions of reedmace and common reed. On the first plot, where the within-habitat heterogeneity was greater, settlement date and consequently reedmace and common reed cover at the sites occupied by a male had a positive influence on that male''s fitness components: the probability of mating, nesting success, and the number of offspring recruited to the breeding population in succeeding years. On the second plot, which was more homogenous, there was no such evident relationship between fitness and the proportion of cover by reeds. [Copyright &y& Elsevier]