Search

The neglected tropical disease leishmaniasis, caused by Leishmania spp., is becoming more problematic due to the emergence of drug-resistant strains. Therefore, new drugs to treat leishmaniasis, with novel mechanisms of action, are urgently required. Strathclyde minor groove binders (S-MGBs) are an emerging class of anti-infective agent that have been shown to have potent activity against various bacteria, viruses, fungi and parasites. Herein, it is shown that S-MGBs have potent activity against L. donovani, and that an N-oxide derivation of the tertiary amine tail of typical S-MGBs leads to selective anti-leishmanial activity. Additionally, using S-MGB-219, the N-oxide derivation is shown to retain strong binding to DNA as a 2:1 dimer. These findings support the further study of anti-leishmanial S-MGBs as novel therapeutics.

Traditional cytotoxic agents which act through a DNA-alkylating mechanism are relatively non-specific, resulting in a small therapeutic window and thus limiting their effectiveness. In this study, we evaluate a panel of 24 non-alkylating Strathclyde Minor Groove Binders (S-MGBs), including 14 novel compounds, for in vitro anti-cancer activity against a human colon carcinoma cell line, a cisplatin-sensitive ovarian cancer cell line and a cisplatin-resistant ovarian cancer cell line. A human non-cancerous retinal epithelial cell line was used to measure selectivity of any response. We have identified several S-MGBs with activities comparable to cis-platin and carboplatin, but with better in vitro selectivity indices, particularly S-MGB-4, S-MGB-74 and S-MGB-317. Moreover, a comparison of the cis-platin resistant and cis-platin sensitive ovarian cancer cell lines reveals that our S-MGBs do not show cross resistance with cisplatin or carboplatin and that they likely have a different mechanism of action. Finally, we present an initial investigation into the mechanism of action of one compound from this class, S-MGB-4, demonstrating that neither DNA double strand breaks nor the DNA damage stress sensor protein p53 are induced. This indicates that our S-MGBs are unlikely to act through an alkylating or DNA damage response mechanism.

Aggregated states have been alluded to for many DNA minor groove binders but details of the molecule-on-molecule relationship have either been under-reported or ignored. Here we report our findings from ITC and NMR measurements carried out with AIK-18/51, a compound representative of the thiazotropsin class of DNA minor groove binders. The free aqueous form of AIK-18/51 is compared with that found in its complex with cognate DNA duplex d(CGACTAGTCG)2. Molecular self-association of AIK-18/51 is consistent with anti-parallel, face-to-face dimer formation, the building block on which the molecule aggregates. This underlying structure is closely allied to the form found in the ligand’s DNA complex. NMR chemical shift and diffusion measurements yield a self-association constant Kass = (61 ± 19) × 103 M- 1 for AIK-18/51 that fits with a stepwise self-assembly model and is consistent with ITC data. The deconstructed energetics of this assembly process are reported with respect to a design strategy for ligand/DNA recognition.

A range of minor groove binders (MGBs) and the intermediates formed in their synthesis was screened against infectious agents including bacteria and parasites. Activity was found against Trypanosoma brucei. Of particular interest is a molecule which does not contain a typical basic flexible tail group found in MGBs, but instead has an unprotected carboxylic acid group at that position (compound 4), which has activity of 63 nM against T. brucei.

The synthesis and biological activity of a variety of analogues to the naturally occurring antibacterial and antifungal Distamycin A were explored by a number of authors. These compounds were subject to a large array of assays. Some of these compounds showed high activity against a range of Gram-positive, Gram-negative bacteria as well as fungi. To explore the anti-parasitic activity of this class of compounds, specific modifications had to be made. A number of these compounds proved to be active against Trypanosoma brucei. The binding of a number of these compounds to short sequences of DNA were also examined using footprinting assays as well as NMR spectroscopy. Computer modelling was employed on selected compounds to understand the way these compounds bind to specific DNA sequences. A large number of variations were made to the standard structure of Distamycin. These changes involved the replacement of the pyrrole moieties as well as the head and tail groups with a number of heterocyclic compounds. Some of these minor groove binders (MGBs) were also investigated for their capability for the treatment of cancer and in particular lung cancer.

We have used DNA footprinting and fluorescence melting experiments to study the sequence specific binding of an imidazole-containing isopropyl-substituted thiazole polyamide (thiazotropsin B) to DNA. While the parent compound (thiazotropsin A) binds to the hexanucleotide sequence ACTAGT, changing one of the N-methylpyrrole groups to N-methylimidazole changes the preferred binding sequence to (A/T)CGCG(T/A). Experiments with DNA fragments that contain variants of this sequence suggest that the ligand can also bind, with lower affinity, to sequences which differ from this by 1 bp in any position.

We have used DNA footprinting and fluorescence melting experiments to study the sequence-specific binding of a novel minor groove binding ligand (thiazotropsin A), containing an isopropyl substituted thiazole polyamide, to DNA. In one fragment, which contains every tetranucleotide sequence, sub-micromolar concentrations of the ligand generate a single footprint at the sequence ACTAGT. This sequence preference is confirmed in melting experiments with fluorescently labelled oligonucleotides. Experiments with DNA fragments that contain variants of this sequence suggest that the ligand also binds, with slightly lower affinity, to sequences of the type XCYRGZ, where X is any base except C, and Z is any base except G.

A set of 31 DNA minor groove binders (MGBs) with diverse structural features relating to both physical chemical properties and DNA binding sequence preference has been evaluated as potential drugs to treat Plasmodium falciparum infections using a chloroquine sensitive strain (3D7) and a chloroquine resistant strain (Dd2) in comparison with human embryonic kidney (HEK) cells as an indicator of mammalian cell toxicity. MGBs with an alkene link between the two N-terminal building blocks were demonstrated to be most active with IC50 values in the range 30 – 500 nM and therapeutic ratios in the range 10 - > 500. Many active compounds contained a C-alkylthiazole building block. Active compounds with logD7.4 values of approximately 3 or 7 were identified. Importantly the MGBs tested were essentially equally effective against both chloroquine sensitive and resistant strains. The results show that suitably designed MGBs have the potential for development into clinical candidates for antimalarial drugs effective against resistant strains of Plasmodia.

The design and synthesis of a new class of minor groove binder (MGBs) in which, the cationic tail group has been replaced by a neutral, polar variant including cyanoguanidine, nitroalkene, and trifluoroacetamide groups. Antibacterial activity (against Gram positive bacteria) was found for both the nitroalkene and trifluoroacetamide groups. For the case of the nitroalkene tail group, strong binding of a minor groove binder containing this tail group was demonstrated by both DNA footprinting and melting temperature measurements, showing a correlation between DNA binding and antibacterial activity. The compounds have also been evaluated for binding to the hERG ion channel to determine whether non-cationic but polar substituents might have an advantage compared with conventional cationic tail groups in avoiding hERG binding. In this series of compounds, it was found that whilst non-cationic compounds generally had lower affinity to the hERG ion channel, all of the compounds studied bound weakly to the hERG ion channel, probably associated with the hydrophobic head groups.

The structural and thermodynamic basis for the strength and selectivity of the interactions of minor-groove binders (MGBs) with DNA is not fully understood. In 2003 we reported the first example of a thiazole containing MGB that bound in a phase shifted pattern that spanned 6 base-pairs rather than the usual 4 (for tricyclic distamycin-like compounds). Since then, using DNA footprinting, nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy, isothermal titration calorimetry and molecular dynamics, we have established that the flanking bases around the central 4 being read by the ligand have subtle effects on recognition. We have investigated the effect of these flanking sequences on binding and the reasons for the differences and established a computational method to rank ligand affinity against varying DNA sequences.

Two closely related lexitropsin analogues that differ only in the form of the headgroup functionality (CHO (for 1) vs. Ac (for 2)) have been studied in their DNA-binding capacity for the sequence d(GCATATATGC) using 1H-NMR spectroscopy. DNA-Complex formation for the CHO derivative was apparent from the observation of new NMR signals on titration of DNA with ligand. Detailed investigation and assignment of the data for a ligand/DNA-duplex ratio of 2 : 1 clearly delineated the structure as one associated with the minor groove class of DNA complexes. The structure of the complex was determined on the basis of the acquired NMR data. Features characteristic of typical 2 : 1 minor-groove complexes were apparent. In a similar experimental approach, the Ac analogue ligand-DNA binding response was investigated. Despite the close similarity in chemical structure to the CHO case, the Ac analogue was found to produce NMR data of a much poorer quality. This was attributed to more rapid on/off chemical exchange equilibrium between ligand and DNA. From close analysis and comparison of the NMR data for the Ac and CHO headgroup ligand-DNA complexes, it was possible to ascertain that the same type of complex formed in each case but with different relative binding constants. Consideration of the nature and form of these complexes has been made with reference to a previously determined structure from our laboratory for the related lexitropsin analogue thiazotropsin A.

Isopropyl-thiazole ((iPr)Th) represents a new addition to the building blocks of nucleic acid minor groove-binding molecules. The DNA decamer duplex d(CGACTAGTCG)(2) is bound by a short lexitropsin of sequence formyl-PyPy(iPr)Th-Dp (where Py represents N-methyl pyrrole, (iPr)Th represents thiazole with an isopropyl group attached, and Dp represents dimethylaminopropyl). NMR data indicate ligand binding in the minor groove of DNA to the sequence 5'-ACT(5)AG(7)T-3' at a 2:1 ratio of ligand to DNA duplex. Ligand binding, assisted by the enhanced hydrophobicity of the (iPr)Th group, occurs in a head-to-tail fashion, the formyl headgroups being located toward the 5'-ends of the DNA sequence. Sequence reading is augmented through hydrogen bond formation between the exocyclic amine protons of G(7) and the (iPr)Th nitrogen, which lies on the minor groove floor. The B(I)/B(II) DNA backbone equilibrium is altered at the T(5) 3'-phosphate position to accommodate a B(II) configuration. The ligands bind in a staggered mode with respect to one another creating a six base pair DNA reading frame. The introduction of a new DNA sequence-reading element into the recognition jigsaw, combined with an extended reading frame for a small lexitropsin with enhanced hydrophobicity, holds great promise in the development of new, potentially commercially viable drug lead candidates for gene targeting.

Forty-eight heterocyclic amino acid trimers, analogues of distamycin, with a number of features that enhance lipophilicity are described. They contain alkyl or cycloalkyl groups larger than methyl; some are N-terminated by acetamide or methoxybenzamide and are C-terminated by dimethylaminopropyl or aliphatic heterocylic aminopropyl substituents. The ability of these compounds to bind principally to AT tracts of DNA has been evaluated using capillary zone electrophoresis. Significant antimicrobial activity against key organisms such as MRSA and Candida albicans is shown by several compounds, especially those containing a thiazole. Moreover, these compounds have low toxicity with respect to several mammalian cell lines.

Solution-phase self-association characteristics and DNA molecular-recognition properties are reported for three close analogues of minor-groove-binding ligands from the thiazotropsin class of lexitropsin molecules; they incorporate isopropyl thiazole as a lipophilic building block. Thiazotropsin B (AcImPy(iPr) ThDp) shows similar self-assembly characteristics to thiazotropsin A (FoPyPy(iPr) ThDp), although it is engineered, by incorporation of imidazole in place of N-methyl pyrrole, to swap its DNA recognition target from 5'-ACTAGT-3' to 5'-ACGCGT-3'. Replacement of the formamide head group in thiazotropsin A by nicotinamide in AIK-18/51 results in a measureable difference in solution-phase self-assembly character and substantially enhanced DNA association characteristics. The structures and associated thermodynamic parameters of self-assembled ligand aggregates and their complexes with their respective DNA targets are considered in the context of cluster targeting of DNA by minor-groove complexes.

Four new ligands that bind to the minor groove of DNA have been designed, synthesized, and evaluated by DNA footprinting. Two of the ligands are polyamides containing central regions with five or six N-methylpyrrole units, conferring hydrophobicity and good binding affinity but without retaining the correct spacing for hydrogen bonding in the base of the minor groove. The two remaining ligands have central regions which are head-to-head-linked polyamides, in which the linker is designed to improve the phasing of hydrogen bonding of the ligand with the floor of the minor groove. The highest affinity was obtained with the two polypyrroles without headgroup spacers, indicating that H-bond phasing is secondary in determining affinity compared to the major hydrophobic driving force. With a dimethylaminoalkyl group, representing a moiety with modest base strength, at both ends, water solubility is good and pH-partition theory predicts that penetration through lipid membranes will be enhanced, compared to strongly basic amidine analogues of the alkaloid precursors. All four compounds bind to DNA, with strong selectivity for AT sequences but some tolerance of GC base pairs and subtle individual preferences. The data show that very high affinities can be anticipated for future compounds in this series, but drug design must take account of overall physicochemical properties as well as the details of hydrogen bonding between ligands and the floor of the minor groove.

A series of head to head linked dimers of heterocyclic amino acids has been prepared for investigation of affinity and selectivity in binding to the minor groove of DNA. The selection of targets for synthesis was led by computer based design. Several novel dicarboxylic acid linkers including indoles, phenanthrenes, a fluorenone, and a bisbenzothiophene have been included. Analysis of binding to DNA by footprinting showed high affinity for compounds derived from 2,7-dihydrophenanthrene dicarboxylic acid and a predominant selectivity for AT rich regions containing at least 4 AT pairs but with the ability to span up to two CG base pairs.

DNA-sequence and structure dependence on the formation of minor groove complexes at 5′-XCYRGZ-3′, where Y = T and R = A, by the short lexitropsin thiazotropsin A are explored based on NMR spectroscopy, isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC), circular dichroism (CD) and qualitative molecular modelling. The structure and solution behaviour of the complexes are similar whether X = A, T, C or G and Z = T, A, I (inosine) or C, 5′-CCTAGI-3′ being thermodynamically the most favoured (ΔG = −11.1 ± 0.1 kcal mol−1). Binding site selectivity observed by NMR for 5′-ACTAGT-3′ in the presence of 5′- TCTAGA-3′ when both accessible sequences are concatenated in a 15-mer DNA duplex construct is consistent with thermodynamic parameters (|ΔG|ACTAGT > |ΔG|TCTAGA) measured separately for the binding sites and with predictions from modelling studies. Steric bulk in the minor groove for Z = G causes unfavourable ligand–DNA interactions reflected in lower Gibbs free energy of binding (ΔG = −8.5 ± 0.01 kcal mol−1). ITC and CD data establish that thiazotropsin A binds the ODNs with binding constants between 106 and 108 M−1 and reveal that binding is driven enthalpically through hydrogen bond formation and van der Waals interactions. The consequences of these findings are considered with respect to ligand self-association and the energetics responsible for driving DNA recognition by small molecules in the DNA minor groove.

Antibacterial minor groove binders related to the natural product, distamycin, are development candidates for novel antibiotics. Alkenes have been found to be effective substitutes for the isosteric amide links in some positions and alkyl groups larger than methyl have been found to increase binding to DNA in both selectivity and affinity. However the impact of other isosteres such as diazenes and the position of an alkyl group with respect to DNA binding and antibacterial activity are not known. The effects of some systematic variations in the structure of polyamide minor groove binders are investigated. Isosteres of the amide link (alkenes and diazenes) are compared: it is shown that all three are competent for binding to DNA but that alkene links give the tightest binding and highest antibacterial activity; no significant antibacterial activity was found for compounds with a diazene link. Within a series of alkene linked compounds, the effect of branched N-alkyl substituents on binding to DNA and antibacterial activity is investigated: it was found that C3 and C4 branched chains are acceptable at the central pyrrole residue but that at the pyrrole ring adjacent to the basic tail group, a C4 branched chain was too large both for DNA binding and for antibacterial activity. The active branched alkyl chain compounds were found to be especially active against Mycobacterium aurum, a bacterium related to the causative agent of tuberculosis.

In 2004, we used NMR to solve the structure of the minor groove binder thiazotropsin A bound in a 2:1 complex to the DNA duplex, d(CGACTAGTCG)2. In this current work, we have combined theory and experiment to confirm the binding thermodynamics of this system. Molecular dynamics simulations that use polarizable or non-polarizable force fields with single and separate trajectory approaches have been used to explore complexation at the molecular level. We have shown that the binding process invokes large conformational changes in both the receptor and ligand, which is reflected by large adaptation energies. This is compensated for by the net binding free energy, which is enthalpy driven and entropically opposed. Such a conformational change upon binding directly impacts on how the process must be simulated in order to yield accurate results. Our MM-PBSA binding calculations from snapshots obtained from MD simulations of the polarizable force field using separate trajectories yield an absolute binding free energy (-15.4 kcal mol(-1)) very close to that determined by isothermal titration calorimetry (-10.2 kcal mol(-1)). Analysis of the major energy components reveals that favorable non-bonded van der Waals and electrostatic interactions contribute predominantly to the enthalpy term, whilst the unfavorable entropy appears to be driven by stabilization of the complex and the associated loss of conformational freedom. Our results have led to a deeper understanding of the nature of side-by-side minor groove ligand binding, which has significant implications for structure-based ligand development.

A practical synthesis of alkene-containing minor-groove binders for DNA, related to distamycin, with potential for wide structural diversity is described, based upon the Wittig chemistry of N-alkylpyrrole aldehydes. The compounds prepared have been evaluated for binding to DNA by physical methods (melting temperature and NMR) and for their antibacterial activity. Significantly, it was found that alkenes linking the aryl head group of the minor-groove binder promote strong binding to DNA and high antibacterial activity against Gram-positive bacteria. Conversely, a minor-groove binder containing an alkene located towards the alkylamino tail group has a low affinity for DNA and does not show antibacterial activity. These observations suggest an important role for specific hydrogen bonds in the binding of compounds of this type to DNA, and in their antibacterial activity.

Footprinting, capillary electrophoresis, molecular modelling and NMR studies have been used to examine the binding of a short polyamide to DNA. This molecule, which contains an isopropyl-substituted thiazole in place of one of the N-methylpyrroles, is selective for the sequence 5′-ACTAGT-3′ to which it binds with high affinity. Two molecules bind side-by-side in the minor groove, but their binding is staggered so that the molecule reads six base pairs, unlike the related natural products, which tend to bind to four-base-pair sequences. The result suggests that high affinity and selectivity may be gained without resort to very large molecules, which may be difficult to deliver to the site of action.

Molecular modelling studies showed that indole dicarboxylic acids are potential linkers for the synthesis of bis-netropsin analogues with a good fit to the minor groove of DNA. To test this hypothesis, 2-carboxyindole-6-acetic acid, indole-2,6-dicarboxylic acid, 6-(2-carboxyethyl)indole-2-carboxylic acid, 6-(2-carboxy-1-ethenyl)indole-2-carboxylic acid were prepared and coupled to 3-[1-methyl-4-(1-methyl-4-aminopyrrole-2-carboxamido)pyrrole-2-carboxamido]dimethylaminopropane. Similarly indole-2,5-dicarboxylic acid was prepared and coupled to 3-[1-methyl-4-(1-methyl-4-aminopyrrple-2-carboxamido)pyrrole-2-carboxamido]propionamidine hydrochloride. The derivatives of 26–28 showed especially strong binding to AT rich regions as shown by footprinting studies.