Search

Objectives: To compare the effectiveness of sacral root neuromodulation with that of conservative management in ameliorating symptoms of refractory urinary urge incontinence and enhancing quality of life, to assess the objective response to neuromodulation as revealed by urodynamic testing, and to delineate the long-term outcomes of neuromodulation., Methods: Forty-four patients with refractory urge incontinence were randomized to undergo neuromodulation with an implantable impulse generator (n = 21) or to continue their prior conservative management (n = 23). At 6 months the control group was eligible for crossover to implant. Patient evaluation included voiding diaries, quality of life questionnaires, urodynamic testing, and documentation of adverse events. Long-term follow-up evaluations were conducted at 6-month intervals up to 36 months., Results: At 6 months mean leakage episodes, leakage severity and pad usage in the implant group were significantly lower by 88% (p < 0.0005), 24% (p = 0.047) and 90% (p < 0.0005), respectively, than the corresponding control group mean values. Improvements in leakage episodes and pad usage of >/=90% were attained by 75 and 85% of the implant group, respectively, but none of the control group. One third of implant patients, but none of the control patients, achieved >/=50% improvement in leakage severity. Over half of the implant patients (56%) were completely dry compared with 1 control patient (4%). Implant patients, but not control patients, exhibited significant improvement with respect to two quality of life measures. Neuromodulation resulted in increases of 220% (p < 0.0005) and 39% (p = 0.013), respectively, in urodynamically assessed bladder volume at first contraction and maximum fill. At 36 months the actuarial rate of treatment failure was 32.4% (95% CI, 17.0-56.0%). Adverse events most frequently involved pain at the implant site, and the incidence of serious complications was low., Conclusions: Neuromodulation is markedly more effective than conservative management in alleviating symptoms of refractory urge incontinence. Quality of life and urodynamic function are also improved by neuromodulation. The effects of neuromodulation are long-lasting, and associated morbidity is low.

The aim of this study was to determine the long-term clinical efficacy and complications of neuromodulation with a unilateral sacral foramen electrode in 36 patients with chronic voiding dysfunction. Following a positive effect of a percutaneous nerve evaluation test, patients underwent open surgery. A permanent electrode was implanted in 24 patients with urge incontinence, in 6 with urgency-frequency syndrome, and in 6 with nonobstructive urinary retention. After an average follow-up period of 37.8 months, 19 patients (52.8%) continue to benefit from the neuromodulation with a significant improvement of symptoms and urodynamic parameters. The median duration of the therapeutic effect for the total study population was longer than 60 months. No significant difference in the median duration of therapeutic effect with regard to sex, the type of voiding disorder, or the implant pulse generator was found. However, in patients with previous psychological disorders the median duration of therapeutic effect was only 12 months (P = 0.008). Complications were mild. In the group of patients in whom the therapeutic effect remains, 37 reoperations have had to be performed. We conclude that although reoperations were needed to overcome technical problems, patients can achieve lasting symptomatic improvement. Since technical changes in the equipment have reduced the number of complications, even better results can be expected in terms of the reoperation rate.

Objectives: Neuromodulation is a new technique that uses electrical stimulation of the sacral nerves for patients with refractory urinary urge/frequency or urge-incontinence, and some forms of urinary retention. The limiting factor for receiving an implant is often a failure of the percutaneous nerve evaluation (PNE) test. Present publications mention only about a 50% success score for PNE of all patients, although the micturition diaries and urodynamic parameters are similar. We wanted to investigate whether PNE results improved by using a permanent electrode as a PNE test. This would show that improvement of the PNE technique is feasible., Methods: In 10 patients where the original PNE had failed to improve the micturition diary parameters more than 50%, a permanent electrode was implanted by operation. It was connected to an external stimulator. In those cases where the patients improved according to their micturition diary by more than 50% during a period of 4 days, the external stimulator was replaced by a permanent subcutaneous neurostimulator., Results: Eight of the 10 patients had a good to very good result (60% to 90% improvement) during the testing period and received their implant 5 to 14 days after the first stage., Conclusions: The good results of the two-stage implant technique we used indicate that the development of better PNE electrodes may lead to an improvement of the testing technique and better selection between nonresponders and technical failures.