Search

We conducted a survey among two random samples of Dutch doctors in order to determine whether they acted prudently with regard to euthanasia and assisted suicide. The doctors completed an anonymous questionnaire and those who at one time or another had applied euthanasia or assisted suicide (52%) were asked about several aspects of the requirements for prudent practice. 'Pointless suffering' was the most important and most common reason for requesting euthanasia or assisted suicide; 'pain' was rarely the most important reason. In 7% of the cases alternative forms of treatment were still available; these were hardly ever therapeutic. A total of 12% of the doctors had applied euthanasia or assisted suicide without having had any kind of consultation or discussion with a colleague, a nurse or any other health care professional; 26% had not issued a certificate testifying to death from natural causes. We conclude that some of the family doctors do not observe the procedural requirements, but that the majority satisfies the material requirements for prudent practice.

A survey was conducted among family doctors to determine the frequency with which they were requested to administer euthanasia or assist in suicide, and how often they actually applied these procedures. Two random samples (in each n = 521) were taken from the population of Dutch family doctors (n = 6300) and requested to complete an anonymous questionnaire. The response was 67%. The entire body of Dutch family doctors practices euthanasia or assisted suicide about 2000 times per annum; 48% have never engaged in these practices. An average of 40% of all requests are complied with. We conclude that far fewer family doctors are involved in euthanasia and assisted suicide than was previously supposed. Euthanasia or assisted suicide was administered to 1 in 25 persons who died in their own homes.

The development of the debate on euthanasia in The Netherlands, the role of the courts and proposals for legislation are discussed. In foreign newspapers and other publications an erroneous picture of the Dutch situation on euthanasia is sometimes given. In Parliament two proposals for legislation are pending. The parliamentary debate is expected to be reopened in 1989.