Irrigation cools near surface air temperature by increasing evapotranspiration from wetter soil. However, elevated evapotranspiration can also increase atmospheric albedo and enhance the local greenhouse effect via increased atmospheric water vapor. Their net effects on daily air temperature remains controversial. Here we show that in several considered regions, Northwest India and Central Valley of California, irrigation could result in warmer air temperature if night‐time warming is stronger than daytime cooling by irrigation. During the daytime, air temperature reduces through evaporative cooling and reduced solar radiation from increased atmospheric albedo outweighing the local greenhouse effect. At night‐time, the increased atmospheric water vapor by irrigation tends to make a stronger local greenhouse effect that increases night‐time temperature. Our results highlight the possible increase of air temperature by irrigation and the importance of considering sub‐daily processes when assessing the impact of irrigation on daily air temperature and temperature related socioeconomic phenomena. Plain Language Summary: Irrigation can influence air temperature in two contrasting ways. Evaporative cooling from wetter soil can reduce air temperature. However, evaporated water is a greenhouse gas, which can increase air temperature. The impact of these two influences differs for daytime and night‐time air temperature. Here, we examine the impact of irrigation on daytime and night‐time air temperature under two different assumptions. Our simulations show that the warming influence of irrigation on night‐time temperature could be greater than the cooling influence on daytime temperature in several considered regions, Northwest India and Central Valley of California. Our results underline that the impact of irrigation is a complex interplay of evaporative cooling and greenhouse warming and still needs to be further investigated. Key Points: Irrigation may result in warmer night‐time temperature by enhancing the local greenhouse effectThe temperature response of local irrigation can be influenced by irrigation practices over nearby areasHighlight the importance of water vapor as a greenhouse gas in climate change [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]