Search

Prenatal treatment of congenital adrenal hyperplasia by administering dexamethasone to a woman presumed to be carrying an at-risk fetus remains a controversial experimental treatment. Review of data from animal experimentation and human trials indicates that dexamethasone cannot be considered safe for the fetus. In animals, prenatal dexamethasone decreases birth weight, affects renal, pancreatic beta cell and brain development, increases anxiety and predisposes to adult hypertension and hyperglycemia. In human studies, prenatal dexamethasone is associated with orofacial clefts, decreased birth weight, poorer verbal working memory, and poorer self-perception of scholastic and social competence. Numerous medical societies have cautioned that prenatal treatment of adrenal hyperplasia with dexamethasone is not appropriate for routine clinical practice and should only be done in Institutional Review Board approved, prospective clinical research settings with written informed consent. The data indicate that this treatment is inconsistent with the classic medical ethical maxim to 'first do no harm'., (Copyright © 2015 Elsevier Ltd. All rights reserved.)

On February 3, 2010, a "Letter of Concern from Bioethicists," organized by fetaldex.org, was sent to report suspected violations of the ethics of human subjects research in the off-label use of dexamethasone during pregnancy by Dr. Maria New. Copies of this letter were submitted to the FDA Office of Pediatric Therapeutics, the Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) Office for Human Research Protections, and three universities where Dr. New has held or holds appointments. We provide a critical appraisal of the Letter of Concern and show that it makes false claims, misrepresents scientific publications and websites, fails to meet standards of evidence-based reasoning, makes undocumented claims, treats as settled matters what are, instead, ongoing controversies, offers "mere opinion" as a substitute for argument, and makes contradictory claims. The Letter of Concern is a case study in unethical transgressive bioethics. We call on fetaldex.org to withdraw the letter and for co-signatories to withdraw their approval of it.

11beta-Hydroxylase deficiency is a common form of congenital adrenal hyperplasia causing virilization of the female fetus and hypertension. DNA analysis of the gene (CYP11B1) encoding 11beta-hydroxylase has been reported previously to be effective in the prenatal diagnosis of one affected female fetus. In that case, prenatal treatment with dexamethasone resulted in normal female genitalia. We now report five new pregnancies that underwent prenatal diagnosis for 11beta-hydroxylase deficiency. In the first family, the proband is homozygous for a T318M mutation and all fetuses from four subsequent pregnancies are carriers. In a second family, the mother is homozygous for a A331V mutation and was started on dexamethasone, but identification of a homozygous normal fetus led to the discontinuation of treatment. In another family, the fetus was a male homozygous for R384Q and treatment was discontinued. Lastly, a novel G444D mutation in exon 8 was identified and proven to reduce 11beta-hydroxylase activity.

Prenatal treatment based on administration of dexamethasone to the mother during pregnancy was initiated early during nine pregnancies with a high risk of congenital adrenal hyperplasia due to 21-hydroxylase deficiency. The purpose of this treatment was to prevent fetal virilization by reducing production of androgens by the adrenal glands. Prenatal diagnosis was achieved by comparing amniotic fluid cell HLA genotypes and more recently by subjecting trophoblasts to molecular genetic studies. Together with prenatal determination of fetal sex, this allowed to determine that only two female fetuses were affected. Efficacy of continued prenatal treatment in these two cases was good in one case and mediocre in the other. The treatment was well tolerated by the mothers and fetuses.

A mother at risk for 21-hydroxylase deficiency was treated with oral dexamethasone (0.5 mg 12 hourly) from early pregnancy, in an attempt to prevent in utero virilization in case of a female fetus. Fetal karyotype was 46,XX, and because of a possible intra HLA recombination, treatment was continued to term. The newborn had a modest virilization and hormonal studies confirmed the diagnosis of congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH). This observation and review of the literature suggest that efficient prenatal treatment of CAH requires a higher and more frequent dosage of dexamethasone.

Congenital adrenal hyperplasia due to 21-hydroxylase deficiency can result in marked virilization of the external genitalia of affected female subjects. Theoretically, suppression of the fetal pituitary-adrenal axis with glucocorticoid during gestational weeks 9 to 17 should prevent the development of ambiguous genitalia in the female fetus. Prenatal diagnosis of congenital adrenal hyperplasia can be made on elevated amniotic fluid 17-hydroxyprogesterone and adrenal androgen concentrations, and HLA typing of cultured amniotic fluid cells. However, these tests cannot be completed before 16 to 17 weeks of gestation, and maternal therapy would have to be instituted before the exact genetic status of the fetus is known. Chorionic villus sampling during the first trimester provides an alternative to second trimester diagnosis in patients who are at risk for bearing offspring with congenital adrenal hyperplasia. We report the use of dexamethasone suppression at 8 weeks of gestation in a 34-year-old woman whose son had congenital adrenal hyperplasia due to severe salt-losing 21-hydroxylase deficiency and whose biopsy revealed a 46XX chromosomal pattern. Cultured cells from the biopsy confirmed the fetus to be of identical HLA haplotype to the previous affected sibling. At 41 weeks the patient delivered a female neonate with minimal prominence of the clitoris, mildly rugated labia, a single perineal opening and minimal posterior labial fusion. Postnatal tapering of maternal steroids was performed with no long-term sequelae.