1. Models of Heat Loss by Marine Mammals: Thermoregulation Below the Zone of Irrelevance
- Author
-
Peter Watts, Stephen Hansen, and D. M. Lavigne
- Subjects
Statistics and Probability ,General Immunology and Microbiology ,biology ,Ecology ,Applied Mathematics ,Cetacea ,Phocoena ,General Medicine ,biology.organism_classification ,Phoca ,General Biochemistry, Genetics and Molecular Biology ,Freezing point ,Modeling and Simulation ,biology.animal ,Blubber ,Homeothermy ,Endotherm ,General Agricultural and Biological Sciences ,Porpoise - Abstract
In an effort to clarify and resolve conflicting views regarding heat loss in marine mammals, we compared four heat-flow models which have been used to predict the "lower critical temperature" (Tlc), below which an endotherm must increase its metabolic rate to maintain homeothermy. Although each model generated different results, all predicted Tlcs below the freezing point of seawater (-2°C) for large cetaceans. The differences between the models only became relevant when dealing with the small cetaceans and the much smaller pinnipeds. Slight changes in metabolic rate or blubber thickness substantially affected the behaviour of the models. We therefore compared the model predictions with observed Tlcs for five juvenile harbour seals (Phoca vitulina) for which metabolic rate, blubber thickness and other relevant parameters were known. The best predictions arose from a model which describes an animal as a simple cylinder; it was accurate within 6°C, although it consistently underestimated true Tlc . In contrast, the other models overestimated Tlc by 5-15°C. The "cylindrical" model proved less accurate when applied to data from a juvenile harbour porpoise (Phocoena phocoena), probably because of an unreliable parameter value describing the proportion of blabber in the body. "Cylindrical" predictions support the argument that marine mammals, for their size, do not have elevated metabolic rates relative to other mammals. We invoke this model to provide a possible explanation for "hauling out" behaviour by Pacific harbour seals (Phoca vitulina richardsi).
- Published
- 1993