Search

30 patients with writer's cramp were examined by a neurologist and a psychiatrist. The syndrome was frequently associated with a postural tremor. We found no evidence for a peripheral causation. Electromyographical recordings showed co-contractions of agonists and antagonists as well as individual patterns of increased muscle activity during writing. CT and MRI scans were normal in most patients. The psychiatric examination revealed a history of situational stress at the onset of the disease and also some abnormalities in the biography and personality traits. Since the latter findings were not consistently present we have no evidence that the disease is a neurotic manifestation. We consider it likely that secondary psychoreactive processes may have some significance in the individual patient.

As there is a variety of psychic and somatic variables in its genesis, the writer's cramp could be a syndrome of different subtypes. Therefore 62 former psychotherapy-patients with writer's cramp were examined according to a design of several dimensions in order to find out if there were any subtypes. The parts of the examination were exploration, structural interview, neurological examination, psychological examination of the personality, examination of some electrolytes in serum and radiograph of neck spinal column. Different multivariate statistical methods isolated two subtypes of patients with writer's cramp. The first group comprises patients with fine and/or big dysfunctions of motor activity, the symptoms are independent of psychic factors or of psychotherapy. The second group is characterized of a monosymtomatic writer's cramp, of a neurosis and of remissions of motoric symptoms following psychotherapy. The examination shows that fine and/or big dysfunctions of motor activity which often co-occur the writer's cramp are important criteria for differential diagnosis and indications.

In recent publications writer's cramp is mostly seen as a "focal dystonia", which denotes a group of organic-degenerative disorders of the basal ganglia. In opposite to this view psychoanalysts have pointed out since many years the psychogenesis of the syndrome. Our investigation starts with the descriptive analysis of three own cases. It will be shown how clinical facts present a complex situation, which allows the hypothesis, that somatic and psychogenetic factors coincide in the pathogenesis of occupational cramps. Finally a proposition is made how empirical evaluation of the hypothesis is possible.

The purpose of this study was to determine if patients with focal hand dystonia have any significant psychopathology. We studied 20 patients with hand cramps who were participating in a therapeutic trial of botulinum toxin injections. Patients were interviewed and administered the Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory (MMPI). Beck Depression Inventory, Spielberger State-Trait Anxiety Scale, a finger tapping test, and a choice serial reaction time test. Behavioral ratings were also obtained. Group statistics indicated that all personality scale scores and performances on motor tasks were within normal limits. Four out of 20 patients demonstrated mild depression. Trait anxiety scores were higher than state anxiety scores, suggesting that receiving medical treatment had a beneficial effect on mood. The number of depressive symptoms endorsed on the MMPI was correlated with reaction time speed but not finger dexterity. None of the 20 patients reported a remarkable psychiatric history. These results indicate that hand cramps are not associated with serious psychopathology.

Although its aetiopathogenesis is still unknown, writer's cramp is meanwhile regarded essentially an organically induced disorder. However, as shown by this interdisciplinary study, psychodynamic factors should not be neglected. Special attention should be given to the patients' experience of the syndrome and secondary psychoreactive processes.

An unusual case of writer's cramp in a 12-year-old deaf girl is reported. Possible aetiological and contributing factors in her environment are discussed, with particular relevance to a hysterical conversion reaction.

A theoretical model of writer's cramp is presented. In addition to the original emotional arousal and subsequent conditioned stimuli inherent in a classical conditioning paradigm, this model stresses the role of operant behaviors in the maintenance of the disorder. The immediate consequences of the actual cramp and subsequent escape behaviors are emphasized. An extinction procedure consisting of response-cost and response-prevention measures is tested using an A-B-A-B design. Two patients totally unable to write, were able to increase cramp latency and were gradually retrained to write. Follow-up assessments at 6, 9 and 12 months confirmed the treatment gains.

The author reports on two sisters suffering from writer's cramp. Genetic, somatic and psychic factors are discussed regarding their pathogenetic importance.

Eleven patients with writer's cramp were studied during the performance of a series of writing and non-writing tasks. Their performance in the tasks and the intensity of contraction in the flexor and extensor muscles of the fingers and elbow (recorded electromyographically) were compared with the results from a group of matched normal controls. The patients showed highly significant increases in muscle activation especially in the triceps muscle which was overactive in all but one of the tasks undertaken. Psychometric testing showed no difference between patients and controls. The results support the view that writer's cramp is a form of focal dystonia in which the disorder of motor control is not confined to writing activities.

The paper gives the results of a follow-up study of 58 patients after psychotherapeutic treatment as in-patients for writer's cramp. Where as immediately after discharge 74.1% of the patients felt an improvement in their condition, at the time of the follow-up study only 17.2% were demonstrably improved, with 37.9% subjectively feeling an improvement over their state before treatment as in-patients. These results suggest that the customary psychotherapeutic methods employed have less effect on the evidently multifactorial extrapyramidal-motor basic complaint but rather have the effect of improving the patient's ability to cope with this in daily life.