1. Single large hepatocellular carcinoma > 5 cm with surgical indication: is it mandatory a major hepatectomy? a propensity-score weighted analysis.
- Author
-
Garancini M, Serenari M, Famularo S, Cipriani F, Ardito F, Russolillo N, Conci S, Nicolini D, Perri P, Zanello M, Iaria M, Lai Q, Romano M, La Barba G, Molfino S, Germani P, Dominioni T, Zimmiti G, Conticchio M, Fumagalli L, Zago M, Troci A, Sciannamea I, Ferrari C, Scotti MA, Griseri G, Antonucci A, Crespi M, Pinotti E, Chiarelli M, Memeo R, Hilal MA, Maestri M, Tarchi P, Baiocchi G, Ercolani G, Zanus G, Rossi M, Valle RD, Jovine E, Frena A, Patauner S, Grazi GL, Vivarelli M, Ruzzenente A, Ferrero A, Giuliante F, Aldrighetti L, Torzilli G, Cescon M, Bernasconi D, and Romano F
- Subjects
- Humans, Male, Female, Retrospective Studies, Middle Aged, Aged, Postoperative Complications etiology, Treatment Outcome, Survival Rate, Adult, Hepatectomy methods, Carcinoma, Hepatocellular surgery, Carcinoma, Hepatocellular pathology, Carcinoma, Hepatocellular mortality, Liver Neoplasms surgery, Liver Neoplasms pathology, Liver Neoplasms mortality, Propensity Score
- Abstract
Purpose: Single large hepatocellular carcinoma >5cm (SLHCC) traditionally requires a major liver resection. Minor resections are often performed with the goal to reduce morbidity and mortality. Aim of the study was to establish if a major resection should be considered the best treatment for SLHCC or a more limited resection should be preferred., Methods: A multicenter retrospective analysis of the HE.RC.O.LE.S. Group register was performed. All collected patients with surgically treated SLHCC were divided in 5 groups of treatment (major hepatectomy, sectorectomy, left lateral sectionectomy, segmentectomy, non-anatomical resection) and compared for baseline characteristics, short and long-term results. A propensity-score weighted analysis was performed., Results: 535 patients were enrolled in the study. Major resection was associated with significantly increased major complications compared to left lateral sectionanectomy, segmentectomy and non-anatomical resection (all p<0.05) and borderline significant increased major complications compared to sectorectomy (p=0.08). Left lateral sectionectomy showed better overall survival compared to major resection (p=0.02), while other groups of treatment resulted similar to major hepatectomy group for the same item. Absence of oncological benefit after major resection and similar outcomes among the 5 groups of treatment was confirmed even in the sub-population excluding patients with macrovascular invasion., Conclusion: Major resection was associated to increased major post-operative morbidity without long-term survival benefit; when technically feasible and oncologically adequate, minor resections should be preferred for the surgical treatment of SLHCC., (© 2024. The Author(s), under exclusive licence to Springer-Verlag GmbH Germany, part of Springer Nature.)
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF