1. Wallstents versus plastic stents in malignant biliary obstruction: effects of stent patency of the first and second stent on patient compliance and survival
- Author
-
A, Schmassmann, E, von Gunten, J, Knuchel, U, Scheurer, H F, Fehr, and F, Halter
- Subjects
Male ,Cholestasis ,Time Factors ,Cost-Benefit Analysis ,Palliative Care ,Equipment Design ,Stainless Steel ,Survival Analysis ,Pancreatic Neoplasms ,Bile Duct Neoplasms ,Case-Control Studies ,Humans ,Patient Compliance ,Female ,Gallbladder Neoplasms ,Stents ,Plastics ,Aged ,Follow-Up Studies ,Retrospective Studies - Abstract
In prospective trials in patients with malignant biliary obstruction, it has been reported that Wallstents prolong stent patency, but this does not translate into a significant survival benefit. Compared with prospective trials, however, survival may be different in clinical practice because of differences in patient compliance. We report on a retrospective, long term analysis comparing Wallstents versus plastic stents.Plastic endoprostheses (70 patients) and endoscopic Wallstents (95 patients) were placed in 165 consecutive patients with irresectable, malignant biliary obstruction in a first (1990-91) and second (1992-93) time period. Stent occlusion was treated by plastic stent placement.Patient characteristics were quite comparable in both stent groups. Initial placement of a Wallstent resulted in an increase of median stent patency of the first (10 vs 4 months, p0.001) and second (8 vs 3 months, p0.05) stent, a decrease of additional endoscopic procedures (20 vs 58%, p0.005), an increase of patient compliance reflected by a decrease of patients dying with untreated stent occlusion (9 vs 30%, p0.001), and an increase of survival time (6.5 vs 4 months, p0.05).Initial placement of a Wallstent results in an increase of stent patency of the first and second stent. Duration of stent patency appears to have a determinant effect on patient compliance. Increased stent patency and patient compliance seem to improve survival in clinical practice.
- Published
- 1996