Search

We reviewed the charts of 393 consecutive patients referred to the Toronto-Bayview Regional Cancer Centre and the Ontario Cancer Institute between January 1, 1978, and December 31, 1982, with clinical stage I malignant melanoma to determine the predictive value of routine staging investigations. The investigations reviewed included physical examination, liver function tests, radionuclide liver-spleen and bone scans, chest x-ray, whole-lung tomograms, CT chest scans, CT brain scans, and bipedal lymphangiograms. The clinical stage of nine patients was changed, eight as a result of physical examination and one as a result of lymphangiogram. No other investigations detected metastatic melanoma at referral. We recommend that staging investigations for patients referred with clinical stage I malignant melanoma be restricted to a complete physical examination and a baseline chest x-ray for all patients.

The purpose of this study was to determine the value of staging and serial follow-up investigations in newly diagnosed patients with completely excised primary cutaneous malignant melanoma. We reviewed the records of the 393 patients with completely excised primary malignant melanoma who were referred to the Ontario Cancer Institute and the Toronto-Bayview Regional Cancer Centre between 1 January 1978 and 31 March 1982. Initial investigations included history and physical examination in all 393 patients, complete blood count (199 patients), liver function tests (198 patients), urinary melanins (159 patients), chest X-rays (345 patients), whole lung tomography (182 patients), radionuclide liver-spleen scans (207 patients), and bone scans (116 patients), bipedal lymphangiograms (78 patients), CT scans of the chest (59 patients), and CT brain scans (51 patients). The clinical stage of ten patients was changed as a result of history and physical examination or lymphangiogram. All other investigations failed to detect metastatic melanoma. Follow-up investigations included history and physical examinations, complete blood counts, liver function tests, radionuclide liver spleen and bone scans. History and physical examinations, chest X-rays and patients' awareness of abnormalities were responsible for detection of subsequent melanoma recurrences. All other tests failed to identify metastatic melanoma at the time of its occurrence. Therefore, we recommend that initial staging investigations be limited to history and physical examination with clinical photographs, and baseline chest X-ray. We recommend that subsequent follow-up include only history and physical examinations and chest X-rays.