Search

Faithful degradation of mRNAs is a critical step in gene expression, and eukaryotes share a major conserved mRNA decay pathway. In this major pathway, the two rate-determining steps in mRNA degradation are the initial gradual removal of the poly(A) tail, followed by removal of the cap structure. Removal of the cap structure is carried out by the decapping enzyme, containing the Dcp2 catalytic subunit. Although the mechanism and regulation of mRNA decay is well understood, the consequences of defects in mRNA degradation are less clear. Dcp2 has been reported as either essential or nonessential. Here, we clarify that Dcp2 is not absolutely required for spore germination and extremely slow growth, but in practical terms it is impossible to continuously culture dcp2∆ under laboratory conditions without suppressors arising. We show that null mutations in at least three different genes are each sufficient to restore growth to a dcp2∆, of which kap123∆ and tl(gag)g∆ appear the most specific. We show that kap123∆ and tl(gag)g∆ suppress dcp2 by mechanisms that are different from each other and from previously isolated dcp2 suppressors. The suppression mechanism for tL(GAG)G is determined by the unique GAG anticodon of this tRNA, and thus likely by translation of some CUC or CUU codons. Unlike previously reported suppressors of decapping defects, these suppressors do not detectably restore decapping or mRNA decay to normal rates, but instead allow survival while only modestly affecting RNA homeostasis. These results provide important new insight into the importance of decapping, resolve previously conflicting publications about the essentiality of DCP2, provide the first phenotype for a tl(gag)g mutant, and show that multiple distinct mechanisms can bypass Dcp2 requirement.

Eukaryotes share a conserved messenger RNA (mRNA) decay pathway in which bulk mRNA is degraded by exoribonucleases. In addition, it has become clear that more specialized mRNA decay pathways are initiated by endonucleolytic cleavage at particular sites. The transfer RNA (tRNA) splicing endonuclease (TSEN) has been studied for its ability to remove introns from pre-tRNAs. More recently it has been shown that single amino acid mutations in TSEN cause pontocerebellar hypoplasia. Other recent studies indicate that TSEN has other functions, but the nature of these functions has remained obscure. Here we show that yeast TSEN cleaves a specific subset of mRNAs that encode mitochondrial proteins, and that the cleavage sites are in part determined by their sequence. This provides an explanation for the counterintuitive mitochondrial localization of yeast TSEN. To identify these mRNA target sites, we developed a "comPARE" (comparative parallel analysis of RNA ends) bioinformatic approach that should be easily implemented and widely applicable to the study of endoribonucleases. The similarity of tRNA endonuclease-initiated decay to regulated IRE1-dependent decay of mRNA suggests that mRNA specificity by colocalization may be an important determinant for the degradation of localized mRNAs in a variety of eukaryotic cells.

Faithful degradation of mRNAs is a critical step in gene expression, and eukaryotes share a major conserved mRNA decay pathway. In this major pathway, the two rate determining steps in mRNA degradation are the initial gradual removal of the poly(A) tail, followed by removal of the cap structure. Removal of the cap structure is carried out by the decapping enzyme, containing the Dcp2 catalytic subunit. While the mechanism and regulation of mRNA decay is well-understood, the consequences of defects in mRNA degradation are less clear. Dcp2 has been reported as either essential or nonessential. Here we clarify that Dcp2 is essential for continuous growth and use experimental evolution to identify suppressors of this essentiality. We show that null mutations in at least three different are each sufficient to restore viability to adcp2Δ, of whichkap123Δ andtl(gag)gΔ appear the most specific. Unlike previously reported suppressors of decapping defects, these suppressor do not restore decapping or mRNA decay to normal rates, but instead allow survival while only modestly affecting transcriptome homeostasis. These effects are not limited to mRNAs, but extend to ncRNAs including snoRNAs and XUTs. These results provide important new insight into the importance of decapping and resolves previously conflicting publications about the essentiality ofDCP2.

Pontocerebellar hypoplasia type 1b (PCH1b) is an autosomal recessive disorder that causes cerebellar hypoplasia and spinal motor neuron degeneration, leading to mortality in early childhood. PCH1b is caused by mutations in the RNA exosome subunit gene, EXOSC3. The RNA exosome is an evolutionarily conserved complex, consisting of nine different core subunits, and one or two 3′-5′ exoribonuclease subunits, that mediates several RNA degradation and processing steps. The goal of this study is to assess the functional consequences of the amino acid substitutions that have been identified in EXOSC3 in PCH1b patients. To analyze these EXOSC3 substitutions, we generated the corresponding amino acid substitutions in the Saccharomyces cerevisiae ortholog of EXOSC3, Rrp40. We find that the rrp40 variants corresponding to EXOSC3-G31A and -D132A do not affect yeast function when expressed as the sole copy of the essential Rrp40 protein. In contrast, the rrp40-W195R variant, corresponding to EXOSC3-W238R in PCH1b patients, impacts cell growth and RNA exosome function when expressed as the sole copy of Rrp40. The rrp40-W195R protein is unstable, and does not associate efficiently with the RNA exosome in cells that also express wild-type Rrp40. Consistent with these findings in yeast, the levels of mouse EXOSC3 variants are reduced compared to wild-type EXOSC3 in a neuronal cell line. These data suggest that cells possess a mechanism for optimal assembly of functional RNA exosome complex that can discriminate between wild-type and variant exosome subunits. Budding yeast can therefore serve as a useful tool to understand the molecular defects in the RNA exosome caused by PCH1b-associated amino acid substitutions in EXOSC3, and potentially extending to disease-associated substitutions in other exosome subunits.

Summary The RNA exosome is a 3′–5′ ribonuclease complex that is composed of nine core subunits and an essential catalytic subunit, Rrp44. Two distinct conformations of Rrp44 were revealed in previous structural studies, suggesting that Rrp44 may change its conformation to exert its function. In the channeling conformation, (Rrp44 ch ), RNA accesses the active site after traversing the central channel of the RNA exosome, whereas in the other conformation, (Rrp44 da ), RNA gains direct access to the active site. Here, we show that the Rrp44 da exosome is important for nuclear function of the RNA exosome. Defects caused by disrupting the direct access conformation are distinct from those caused by channel-occluding mutations, indicating specific functions for each conformation. Our genetic analyses provide in vivo evidence that the RNA exosome employs a direct-access route to recruit specific substrates, indicating that the RNA exosome uses alternative conformations to act on different RNA substrates.

Eukaryotes maintain fidelity of gene expression by preferential degradation of aberrant mRNAs that arise by errors in RNA processing reactions. In Saccharomyces cerevisiae, Ski7 plays an important role in this mRNA quality control by mediating mRNA degradation by the RNA exosome. Ski7 was initially thought to be restricted to Saccharomyces cerevisiae and close relatives because the SKI7 gene and its paralog HBS1 arose by whole genome duplication (WGD) in a recent ancestor. We have recently shown that the preduplication gene was alternatively spliced and that Ski7 function predates WGD. Here, we use transcriptome analysis of diverse eukaryotes to show that diverse eukaryotes use alternative splicing of SKI7/HBS1 to encode two proteins. Although alternative splicing affects the same intrinsically disordered region of the protein, the pattern of splice site usage varies. This alternative splicing event arose in an early eukaryote that is a common ancestor of plants, animals, and fungi. Remarkably, through changes in alternative splicing and gene duplication, the Ski7 protein has diversified such that different species express one of four distinct Ski7-like proteins. We also show experimentally that the Saccharomyces cerevisiae SKI7 gene has undergone multiple changes that are incompatible with the Hbs1 function and may also have undergone additional changes to optimize mRNA quality control. The combination of transcriptome analysis in diverse eukaryotes and genetic analysis in yeast clarifies the mechanism by which a Ski7-like protein is expressed across eukaryotes and provides a unique view of changes in alternative splicing patterns of one gene over long evolutionary time.

Nonstop decay is the mechanism of identifying and disposing aberrant transcripts that lack in-frame stop codons. It is hypothesized that these transcripts are identified during translation when the ribosome arrives at the 3' end of the mRNA and stalls. Presumably, the ribosome stalling recruits additional cofactors, Ski7 and the exosome complex. The exosome degrades the transcript using either one of its ribonucleolytic activities, and the ribosome and the peptide are both released. Additional precautionary measures by the nonstop decay pathway may include translational repression of the nonstop transcript after translation, and proteolysis of the released peptide by the proteasome. This surveillance mechanism protects the cells from potentially harmful truncated proteins, but it may also be involved in mediating critical cellular functions of transcripts that are prone to stop codon read-through. Important advances have been made in the past decade as we learn that nonstop decay may have implications in human disease.

Two general pathways of mRNA decay have been characterized in yeast. In one pathway, the mRNA is degraded by the cytoplasmic form of the exosome. The exosome has both 3′ to 5′ exoribonuclease and endoribonuclease activity, and the available evidence suggests that the exonuclease activity is required for the degradation of mRNAs. We confirm here that this is true for normal mRNAs, but that aberrant mRNAs that lack a stop codon can be efficiently degraded in the absence of the exonuclease activity of the exosome. Specifically, we show that the endo- and exonuclease activities of the exosome are both capable of rapidly degrading nonstop mRNAs and ribozyme-cleaved mRNAs. Additionally, the endonuclease activity of the exosome is not required for endonucleolytic cleavage in no-go decay. In vitro, the endonuclease domain of the exosome is active only under nonphysiological conditions, but our findings show that the in vivo activity is sufficient for the rapid degradation of nonstop mRNAs. Thus, whereas normal mRNAs are degraded by two exonucleases (Xrn1p and Rrp44p), several endonucleases contribute to the decay of many aberrant mRNAs, including transcripts subject to nonstop and no-go decay. Our findings suggest that the nuclease requirements for general and nonstop mRNA decay are different, and describe a molecular function of the core exosome that is not disrupted by inactivating its exonuclease activity.

Eukaryotic mRNAs harboring premature translation termination codons are recognized and rapidly degraded by the nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) pathway. The mechanism for discriminating between mRNAs that terminate translation prematurely and those subject to termination at natural stop codons remains unclear. Studies in multiple organisms indicate that proximity of the termination codon to the 3' poly(A) tail and the poly(A) RNA-binding protein, PAB1, constitute the critical determinant in NMD substrate recognition. We demonstrate that mRNA in yeast lacking a poly(A) tail can be destabilized by introduction of a premature termination codon and, importantly, that this mRNA is a substrate of the NMD machinery. We further show that, in cells lacking Pab1p, mRNA substrate recognition and destabilization by NMD are intact. These results establish that neither the poly(A) tail nor PAB1 is required in yeast for discrimination of nonsense-codon-containing mRNA from normal by NMD.

Translation is an important mechanism to monitor the quality of messenger RNAs (mRNAs), as exemplified by the translation-dependent recognition and degradation of transcripts harboring premature termination codons (PTCs) by the nonsense-mediated mRNA decay (NMD) pathway. We demonstrate in yeast that mRNAs lacking all termination codons are as labile as nonsense transcripts. Decay of “nonstop” transcripts in yeast requires translation but is mechanistically distinguished from NMD and the major mRNA turnover pathway that requires deadenylation, decapping, and 5′-to-3′ exonucleolytic decay. These data suggest that nonstop decay is initiated when the ribosome reaches the 3′ terminus of the message. We demonstrate multiple physiologic sources of nonstop transcripts and conservation of their accelerated decay in mammalian cells. This process regulates the stability and expression of mRNAs that fail to signal translational termination.

The exosome is a protein complex consisting of a variety of 3'-to-5' exonucleases that functions both in 3'-to-5' trimming of rRNA precursors and in 3'-to-5' degradation of mRNA. To determine additional exosome functions, we examined the processing of a variety of RNAs, including tRNAs, small nuclear RNAs (snRNAs), small nucleolar RNAs (snoRNAs), RNase P, RNase MRP, and SRP RNAs, and 5S rRNAs in mutants defective in either the core components of the exosome or in other proteins required for exosome function. These experiments led to three important conclusions. First, exosome mutants accumulate 3'-extended forms of the U4 snRNA and a wide variety of snoRNAs, including snoRNAs that are independently transcribed or intron derived. This finding suggests that the exosome functions in the 3' end processing of these species. Second, in exosome mutants, transcripts for U4 snRNA and independently transcribed snoRNAs accumulate as 3'-extended polyadenylated species, suggesting that the exosome is required to process these 3'-extended transcripts. Third, processing of 5.8S rRNA, snRNA, and snoRNA by the exosome is affected by mutations of the nuclear proteins Rrp6p and Mtr4p, whereas mRNA degradation by the exosome required Ski2p and was not affected by mutations in RRP6 or MTR4. This finding suggests that the cytoplasmic and nuclear forms of the exosome represent two functionally different complexes involved in distinct 3'-to-5' processing and degradation reactions.

In plants, as in other eukaryotes, most synonymous codons of the genetic code are not used with equal frequency, but instead some codons are preferred, whereas others are rare. Circumstantial evidence led to the suggestion that rare codons have a negative influence on mRNA stability. To address this question experimentally, rare codons encoded by a Bacillus thuringiensis (B.t.) toxin gene (cryIA(c)) or a synthetic sequence were introduced into a phytohemagglutinin (PHA) reporter gene. In neither case was the mRNA stability appreciably diminished in stably transformed tobacco cell cultures nor was the accumulation of mRNA in transgenic plants affected. Thus rare codons do not appear to be sufficient to cause rapid degradation of the PHA mRNA and potentially other mRNAs in plants.

Premature termination of translation has often been associated with decreased mRNA accumulation in plants, but the affected step in gene expression has not been identified. To investigate this problem, the expression of wild-type and mutant alleles of the bean phytohemagglutinin (PHA) gene has been examined in tobacco cells and transgenic plants. Measurement of mRNA decay rates in stably transformed cell lines demonstrated that premature nonsense codons markedly destabilized the mRNA. This decreased stability was also reflected by decreased accumulation of transcripts containing premature nonsense codons in transgenic plants. The positional dependence of the nonsense codon effect was evaluated by introducing premature nonsense codons at different distances from the PHA AUG start codon. Transcripts with nonsense codons about 20, 40 or 60% of the way through the normal PHA coding region yielded highly unstable mRNAs, whereas a transcript with a nonsense codon at 80% was as stable as wild-type. The ability to recognize and rapidly degrade certain transcripts with early nonsense codons could provide plant cells with a means to minimize the production of wasteful and possible deleterious truncated proteins.

The RNA exosome is responsible for a wide variety of RNA processing and degradation reactions. The activity and specificity of the RNA exosome is thought to be controlled by a number of cofactors. Mtr4 is an essential RNA-dependent adenosine triphosphatase that is required for all of the nuclear functions of the RNA exosome. The crystal structure of Mtr4 uncovered a domain that is conserved in the RNA exosome cofactors Mtr4 and Ski2 but not in other helicases, suggesting it has an important role related to exosome activation. Rrp6 provides the nuclear exosome with one of its three nuclease activities, and previous findings suggested that the arch domain is specifically required for Rrp6 functions. Here, we report that the genetic interactions between the arch domain of Mtr4 and Rrp6 cannot be explained by the arch domain solely acting in Rrp6-dependent processing reactions. Specifically, we show that the arch domain is not required for all Rrp6 functions, and that the arch domain also functions independently of Rrp6. Finally, we show that the arch domain of Ski2, the cytoplasmic counterpart of Mtr4, is required for Ski2's function, thereby confirming that the arch domains of these cofactors function independently of Rrp6.

The mechanisms responsible for mRNA decay in mammalian cells, and how specific sequence elements accelerate decay, are unknown. Recent work indicates that ‘ARE’ instability elements recruit the exosome to promote rapid 3′-to-5′ degradation of the mRNA.

One role of messenger RNA (mRNA) degradation is to maintain the fidelity of gene expression by degrading aberrant transcripts. Recent results show that mRNAs without translation termination codons are unstable in eukaryotic cells. We used yeast mutants to demonstrate that these “nonstop” mRNAs are degraded by the exosome in a 3′-to-5′ direction. The degradation of nonstop transcripts requires the exosome-associated protein Ski7p. Ski7p is closely related to the translation elongation factor EF1A and the translation termination factor eRF3. This suggests that the recognition of nonstop mRNAs involves the binding of Ski7p to an empty aminoacyl-(RNA-binding) site (A site) on the ribosome, thereby bringing the exosome to a mRNA with a ribosome stalled near the 3′ end. This system efficiently degrades mRNAs that are prematurely polyadenylated within the coding region and prevents their expression.

Defective mRNAs are degraded more rapidly than normal mRNAs in a process called mRNA surveillance. Eukaryotic cells use a variety of mechanisms to detect aberrations in mRNAs and a variety of enzymes to preferentially degrade them. Recent advances in the field of RNA surveillance have provided new information regarding how cells determine which mRNA species should be subject to destruction and novel mechanisms by which a cell tags an mRNA once such a decision has been reached. In this review, we highlight recent progress in our understanding of these processes.

Nonstop mRNA decay, a specific mRNA surveillance pathway, rapidly degrades transcripts that lack in-frame stop codons. The cytoplasmic exosome, a complex of 3′–5′ exoribonucleases involved in RNA degradation and processing events, degrades nonstop transcripts. To further understand how nonstop mRNAs are recognized and degraded, we performed a genomewide screen for nonessential genes that are required for nonstop mRNA decay. We identified 16 genes that affect the expression of two different nonstop reporters. Most of these genes affected the stability of a nonstop mRNA reporter. Additionally, three mutations that affected nonstop gene expression without stabilizing nonstop mRNA levels implicated the proteasome. This finding not only suggested that the proteasome may degrade proteins encoded by nonstop mRNAs, but also supported previous observations that rapid decay of nonstop mRNAs cannot fully explain the lack of the encoded proteins. Further, we show that the proteasome and Ski7p affected expression of nonstop reporter genes independently of each other. In addition, our results implicate inositol 1,3,4,5,6-pentakisphosphate as an inhibitor of nonstop mRNA decay.

One of two general pathways of mRNA decay in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae occurs by deadenylation followed by 3'-to-5' degradation of the mRNA body. Previous results have shown that this degradation requires components of the exosome and the Ski2p, Ski3p, and Ski8p proteins, which were originally identified due to their superkiller phenotype. In this work, we demonstrate that deletion of the SKI7 gene, which encodes a putative GTPase, also causes a defect in 3'-to-5' degradation of mRNA. Deletion of SKI7, like deletion of SKI2, SKI3, or SKI8, does not affect various RNA-processing reactions of the exosome. In addition, we show that a mutation in the SKI4 gene also causes a defect in 3'-to-5' mRNA degradation. We show that the SKI4 gene is identical to the CSL4 gene, which encodes a core component of the exosome. Interestingly, the ski4-1 allele contains a point mutation resulting in a mutation in the putative RNA binding domain of the Csl4p protein. This point mutation strongly affects mRNA degradation without affecting exosome function in rRNA or snRNA processing, 5' externally transcribed spacer (ETS) degradation, or viability. In contrast, the csl4-1 allele of the same gene affects rRNA processing but not 3'-to-5' mRNA degradation. We identify csl4-1 as resulting from a partial-loss-of-function mutation in the promoter of the CSL4 gene. These data indicate that the distinct functions of the exosome can be separated genetically and suggest that the RNA binding domain of Csl4p may have a specific function in mRNA degradation.

The abundance of a given mRNA is an important determinant of gene expression. This steady-state level is determined by a combination of the rates of synthesis and degradation of mRNA. Control at the level of message stability is of particular importance for genes whose expression is tightly regulated. Rapid degradation of transcripts in concert with transcriptional repression allows for the level of a transcript in the cytoplasm to be quickly diminished. This precise control of gene expression, afforded by rapid mRNA turnover, likely plays a significant role for plants, since as sessile organisms they must be able to quickly adapt to changes in the environment.

A report on the Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory meeting 'Eukaryotic mRNA Processing', Cold Spring Harbor, USA, 20-24 August 2003.