Search

In a series of 137 patients with methylmalonic acidaemia (MMA) and propionic acidaemia (PA) diagnosed since the early 1970s, we report in more detail 81 patients (51 MMA and 30 PA) diagnosed between 1988 and 2005. In this series, 14% of patients died at initial access revealing the disease before or despite treatment, 18% died later, and the remainder (68%) are still alive. All patients were treated with the same protocol of enteral feeds with a low-protein diet adjusted to individual tolerance, carnitine, antibiotics, and only occasional use of an amino acid (AA) mixture. There was intensive follow-up and monitoring using measurements of urinary urea. Thirty-nine patients with severe forms, followed for more than 3 years, are analysed in particular detail. Of the 17 PA patients, 6 had moderate disability (all neonatal-onset forms), whereas 11 were normal or slightly delayed in their mental development. Four presented with cardiomyopathy, of whom 2 died. Of the 22 MMA patients, 13 presented in the neonatal period, of whom 3 died later, 2 are in renal failure and only 5 are still alive and have a normal or slightly delayed mental development. In the 9 patients with late-onset forms, there were no deaths and all patients but one have normal mental development. Among the 39 patients, only 40% were given an AA supplement at 3 years, and 50% between 6 and 11 years. The actual intake of natural protein was 0.92, 0.78 and 0.77 g/kg per day at 3, 6 and 11 years, respectively, in patients without AA supplementation, whereas it was 0.75, 0.74 and 0.54 g/kg per day in the group who received small quantities of AA (0.4-0.6 g/kg per day). In both groups, feeding disorders were frequent: 55% at 3 years, 35% at 6 years and 12% at 11 years. Many patients were given a food supplement by tube overnight or were even exclusively tube fed: 60% at 3 years, 48% at 6 years and still 27% at 11 years. Growth velocity was near the normal values. Plasma valine and isoleucine were low to very low, as were leucine and phenylalanine but to a lesser extent. Albumin, vitamins, trace elements and markers of bone metabolism were within the normal values. IGF1, 24-hour urine calcium and body mass density were low. Body composition showed a normal to low lean mass and a normal to high fat mass.

Organic acidurias comprise many various disorders. Methylmalonic aciduria (MMA) and propionic aciduria (PA) are the most frequent diseases and the two organic acidurias for which we have better knowledge of the long-term outcome. Comparing the outcome of patients born before and after 1990, it appears that better neonatal and long-term management have improved the survival rate. Less than 20% of the patients died in either the neonatal period or before the age of 10 years. However, most surviving patients showed poor nutritional status with growth retardation and about 40% present some kind of visceral or neurological impairment. The developmental outcome may have improved in MMA patients, with IQ higher than 75 in about 40% patients aged more than 4 years. Conversely, poor intellectual development is the rule in PA patterns, with 60% having an IQ less than 75 and requiring special education. Successful liver and/or renal transplantations, in a few patients, have resulted in better quality of life but have not necessarily prevented neurological and various visceral complications. These results emphasize the need for permanent metabolic follow-up whatever the therapeutic strategy.

Despite the improvement in dietary therapy during the past 20 years, the overall outcome of severe forms of propionic acidaemia (PA) remains often disappointing. Good results can be obtained at a very high price in terms of medical attention, family burden and high cost. In most early onset forms of PA, the intake of natural protein must be rigidly restricted to 8-12 g/day for the first 3 years of life, and then slowly increased to 15-20 g/day by the age of 6-8 years. Supplementation with a precursor-free aminoacid mixture to provide 1.5 g/kg protein per day is generally recommended, although remains controversial. From the age of 1 year onward, these children are often severely anorectic and most of the diet must be delivered by nocturnal gastric drip feeding or gastrostomy. Metronidazole is very effective in reducing the excretion of propionate metabolites derived from the gut. L-carnitine (50 to 100 mg/kg) is systematically given to promote propionylcarnitine synthesis and excretion. We report here a retrospective study of 33 patients with PA diagnosed during the last 20 years in our hospital. Of them, 2 have been liver transplanted. In these two patients who presented frequent severe and unexpected metabolic decompensations despite good compliance with the dietary therapy, orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) was done at 7 and 9 years respectively. One child died 15 months after transplantation due to a severe lymphoproliferative disorder; the other child now aged 13.5 years is doing well. Despite a persistent methylcitrate excretion, she is under normal moderate daily protein intake (40-50 g/day) and still on carnitine supplementation. Interestingly, another patient who filled the criteria for OLT (very frequent and severe decompensations leading to frequent admissions to the intensive care unit despite excellent dietary management) was also placed on the list for OLT. From the time he was registered onward, he experienced no further episodes of metabolic decompensation, there was almost no interruption in his daily intake and he gained height and weight and developed well. He was finally removed from the list and is still doing very well 2 years thereafter. Correction of propionylCoA carboxylase deficiency restricted to hepatic tissues seems to induce a change towards clinical normalisation and a milder biochemical phenotype. Liver transplanted PA patients still require slight protein restriction and carnitine treatment. We consider that at the moment OLT should only be performed in severe forms of PA, mostly characterised by frequent and unexpected episodes of metabolic decompensation despite good dietary therapy. However, a strict appreciation of these criteria is difficult. A more generalised indication for OLT in PA will require more information about the long-term outcome of transplanted patients. We should also await other alternatives like auxiliary partial OLT from living donors or transplantation of isolated allogenic hepatocytes, genetically modified or not.

Unlabelled: A retrospective study was performed on the clinical outcome and long-term treatment of 17 patients with propionic acidaemia diagnosed during the last 20 years in our hospital. The study group consisted of 12 patients with early onset type of disease and 5 patients with late onset. Seven (41%) patients died, five with early onset and two with late onset. The deceased early onset patients had a median survival of 0.4 years while the deceased late onset patients died at the age of 2.8 and 4 years respectively. Median age of the living early onset patients was 5.2 (1-9.25) years, the late onset patients were 4, 7 and 23 years old. Patients were all treated with natural protein restriction and in most cases carnitine and metronidazole were added. The early onset patients were almost all treated with daily home tube feeding. The mean natural protein intake of early onset patients (6.3 +/- 1.5 g/day) was significantly lower than the natural protein intake of late onset patients (17.6 +/- 5.3 g/day). Supplemental protein intake was higher in early onset patients. The general neurological outcome of our study group was satisfactory with a better outcome for early onset patients. As to growth, many patients showed a failure to thrive, this was particularly for height. The strong protein restriction during the first years of life probably contributed to this., Conclusion: The prognosis for patients with propionic acidaemia appeared to be satisfactory in terms of survival and outcome characteristics such as neurological and mental development. Despite these results the authors feel that the prognosis and quality of life of these patients might be improved with liver transplantation or possibly somatic gene therapy in the future.

Orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) was performed in two patients with propionic acidaemia, a 7-year-old boy and a 9-year-old girl, diagnosed with a severe neonatal form with high risk of metabolic decompensation. In both cases the metabolic liver functions recovered within the 12 postoperative hours; no clinical symptoms of propionic acid toxicity, metabolic acidosis, severe hyperammonaemia, hyperglycinaemia or haematological abnormalities were observed. In both cases insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus occurred early after OLT (persisting in the boy's case). Severe post-transplantation complications were observed (acute rejection and CMV infection in both patients) which did not trigger metabolic decompensation. The boy developed chronic rejection and vanishing bile duct syndrome due to incomplete hepatic arterial thrombosis. He required permanent in-patient care with chronic hyperammonaemia and neurological sequelae involving the basal ganglia and died 15 months after OLT. The girl left hospital after 2 months and is presently leading a normal life with almost no dietary protein restriction (40 g protein per day). Urinary urea excretion and daily protein intake increased after liver transplantation. Propionyl- and tiglylglycine disappeared immediately after OLT. Urinary methylcitrate and 3-hydroxypropionate remained at concentrations corresponding to those before OLT. However, the total of all characteristic metabolites of organic acid analysis was reduced to 50-60% of the values before OLT in both patients. Propionylcarnitine was still detected at significant concentrations. Plasma odd-chain fatty acid concentrations decreased continuously after OLT only in the girl's case. Tissue of both transplanted livers showed increased odd-chain fatty acid concentrations 9 and 15 months after OLT, respectively, in both patients. We consider that at present OLT should only be performed in severe forms of propionic acidaemia.

Citrulline synthesis, mostly regulated at the carbamoyl-phosphate synthase I (EC 6.3.4.16) step by the intramitochondrial concentration of ATP and/or N-acetylglutamate is tested with four organic acids: propionate, alpha-ketobutyrate, dipropyl-acetate and 4-pentenoate. In the presence of 10 mM succinate, as the oxidizable substrate, citrullinogenesis was only inhibited by propionate and 4-pentenoate. With 10 mM L-glutamate, a significant inhibition was observed with the four acids. After the addition of ATP and N-acetylglutamate to uncoupled mitochondria, no inhibition could be demonstrated with dipropylacetate and 4-pentenoate. However, a slight inhibition remained with propionate and alpha-ketobutyrate. When mitochondria were incubated with 10 mM L-glutamate, ATP decreased with propionate, dipropylacetate and 4-pentenoate. Under the same conditions, N-acetylglutamate synthesis was strongly inhibited by each organic acid. The decrease of N-acetylglutamate synthesis was related to the constant diminution of intramitochondrial acetyl-coenzyme A (CoA) and to the increase of propionyl-CoA with propionate and alpha-ketobutyrate. Acetyl-CoA and propionyl-CoA are respectively substrate and competitive inhibitor of the N-acetylglutamate synthase (EC 2.3.1.1). Each acid displayed its optimum inhibition at concentrations between 1 and 2 mM. At these acid concentrations, mitochondria had the lowest acetyl-CoA content and the highest propionyl-CoA content.

Prenatal diagnosis of propionic acidemia was achieved by the direct assay of propionyl CoA carboxylase in chorionic villi. The diagnosis was confirmed by determination of methylcitrate in amniotic fluid and measurement of propionyl CoA carboxylase in the liver from the abortion. Discrepancy between [14C]-propionate incorporation into protein of chorionic villi or cultured chorionic cells and propionyl CoA carboxylase activity is reported.