1. Determinants and correlates of cognitive performance: A pre-registered study of the relationship between aggression and self-assessed and psychometrically detected intelligence
- Author
-
Varchavskaia, Olga
- Subjects
Anger as Disposition ,Self assessed Intelligence ,replication ,trait-anger ,objectively assessed inteligence ,self assessed inteligence ,anger ,Disposition ,intelligence ,Social and Behavioral Sciences ,self-assessment ,Intelligenz ,Objectively Assessed Intelligence ,FOS: Psychology ,Psychology ,personality trait ,narcissism ,neuroticism - Abstract
Angry people tend to overestimate their intelligence. These and other questions were dealt with by Zajenkowski and Gignac (2018). The aim of the present study is to replicate the results of the above named study. Zajenkowski and Gignac (2018) found a positive correlation between self-assessed intelligence (SAI) and trait-anger and a negative correlation between SAI and neuroticism. Other main goals of this work are to investigate further connections between anger, neuroticism, SAI and narcissism. To explore those connections, I will use a questionnaire consisting of two intelligence tests, an SAI- and three personality questionnaires. For the replication I will use the German versions of the same measures (paper-pencil) as in the original study (paper-pencil). Participants will also be students (n~200). Hypotheses and questions come from the original study. Two standardized tests are used to test for objective intelligence. The term trait-anger is adopted from the descriptions in Zajenkowski and Gignac (2018) following the State Trait Model by Spielberger et al., 1985, Spielberger, 1988. Theory Trait-Anger is described as a negative emotionality trait. However, there seems to be some evidence that it produces similar effects as some positive emotionality traits or emotions on self-assessment. “Although Trait-Anger has shown a weak, negative correlation with objective intelligence test scores (e.g. Austin et al., 2002), there is indirect evidence to suggest that angry people may not exhibit a corresponding tendency toward reporting relatively low SAI.” (Zajenkowski and Gignac, 2018) Furthermore, personality and social psychological research show that the tendency to overestimate oneself is not limited to clinical groups (Schütz, Marcus & Sellin, 2004). Farwell and Wohlwend-Lloyd (1998) found that students with high NPI scores overestimate their grades. In this study I have also adopted the following concepts Anger Anger is an elemental emotion that plays an important role in daily life (Izard, 1991, Novaco, 1975). Anger as a characteristic describes the presentation of interindividual differences in the dispositional tendency of individuals to perceive a variety of situations as disturbing or frustrating and to react with increasing anger in such a situation. The anger disposition is not necessarily a homogeneous feature, but can be distinguished in at least two subdimensions, a temperament (angry temperament) and a behavioral dimension (angry reaction) (Spielberger, 1988, zit Rohrmann, 2013). Neuroticism According to Henning (2005), neuroticism is a stable construct of personality psychology. Neuroticism is referred to as a personality trait and includes six facets: anxiety, angry hostility, depression, self-esteem, impulsivity, and vulnerability (Asendorpf, 2007). Narcissism Asendorpf (2007) refers to narcissism as a personality disorder, but also as a dimension of normal personality characterized by overconsciousness, lack of empathy, mood swings, hypersensitivity to praise and criticism. Narcissistic personality disorder is described in the Diagnostic and Statistical Handbook of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV, 1998) as a profound pattern of magnificence, admiration, and lack of empathy (Schütz, Marcus & Sellin, 2004). In the study of personality and social psychology, narcissism is called a personality construct. Narcissists tend to overestimate themselves (Schütz, Marcus & Sellin, 2004). Grandiose narcissists are characterized by a positive self-image, self-confidence, a high self-esteem, self-admiration. A number of studies have confirmed that narcissists tend to overestimate their own intelligence (Asendorpf, 2007). The more narcissistic the participants were, the more they overestimated their performance. Neuroticism, Narcissism and Trait-Anger are predictors of the SAI. Narcissism is a mediator of neuroticism and SAI, anger and SAI effects. Anger-Trait and Neuroticism are independent variables. SAI is dependent variable.
- Published
- 2022
- Full Text
- View/download PDF