Search

Thumb pain secondary to arthritis at the basal joint of the thumb is a common condition, especially in women, and can be quite disabling. An accurate diagnosis can be readily made from the history and examination. Radiographs are used to stage the severity of the arthritis. Splinting is the mainstay of conservative care. Reconstructive procedures for each stage of the disease are aimed at restoring thumb motion and strength. Partial or complete trapeziectomy with tendon interposition and ligament reconstruction to stabilize the metacarpal base is used for advanced disease. Secondary metacarpophalangeal joint hyper-extension deformity may need to be addressed. Surgery can reliably improve function and engender high patient satisfaction.

It has been hypothesized that instability of the thumb trapeziometacarpal joint is a major factor in the etiology of degenerative disease. Theoretically, surgically stabilized joints should be subject to less shear force and, hence, will be less likely to develop degenerative changes. The long-term results of volar ligament reconstruction were assessed in 19 patients (24 thumbs). The average age at surgery was 33 years (range, 18-55 years). Twenty-three thumbs were radiographic stage I; a preoperative x-ray was not available in 1. The follow-up period averaged 15 years (range, 10-23 years). At the final follow-up visit 15 thumbs were stage I, 7 were stage II, and 2 were stage III. Fifteen patients were at least 90% satisfied with the results of the surgery. Only 8% of thumbs advanced to radiographic arthritic disease, which compares favorably with the 17% to 33% reported incidence of stage III/IV basal joint arthritis in the general population., (Copyright 2000 by the American Society for Surgery of the Hand.)

Although much has been written about surgical treatment of arthritis of the first carpometacarpal joint, no literature exists on splinting as a conservative treatment. One hundred fourteen patients (130 thumbs) were retrospectively reviewed to determine the efficacy of splinting. Patients were grouped according to their stage of disease and whether they had carpometacarpal joint surgery. Seventy-six percent of patients with stage I and II disease and 54% of patients with stage III and IV disease had improvement in their symptoms with splinting. There was no significant difference in the degree of improvement between the 2 groups. All patients who had initial improvement in their symptoms with splinting had between 54% and 61% average improvement in symptom severity 6 months after splinting. All groups were found to be equally tolerant of the splinting protocol and no group had a significantly higher rate of activity modification. Overall, splinting was found to be a well-tolerated and effective conservative treatment to diminish, but not completely eliminate, the symptoms of carpometacarpal joint arthritis and inflammation.

The trapeziometacarpal joint is particularly prone to osteoarthritis due to the great amount of stress applied with everyday activities with the hands. In this essay, radiologic assessment and staging of "basal joint" osteoarthritis, treatments based on radiologic staging and intraoperative findings, and surgical complications are described.

Visualization of the scaphotrapezial joint during basal joint arthroplasty has been recommended to establish the stage of degeneration. This study attempts to clarify that recommendation and evaluate whether moderate wear of the joint precludes a good result of trapeziometacarpal hemiarthroplasty. To assess the need for inspection of the scaphotrapezial joint, x-ray films, tomograms, and operative findings in 23 cases of basal joint arthroplasty were reviewed. X-ray findings agreed with operative findings at the scaphotrapezial joint in only 76% of the cases. We also evaluated 18 thumbs in 15 patients who underwent interposition arthroplasty of the trapeziometacarpal joint and at surgery had moderate degenerative changes of the scaphotrapezial joint. The scaphotrapezial joints were left intact and the trapeziometacarpal joints were reconstructed. Follow-up averaged 8 years. In no case was there x-ray or symptomatic progression of the disease at the scaphotrapezial joint. Clinically, 78% were rated excellent, 17% good, and 5% fair.

Arthrosis of the trapeziometacarpal joint of the thumb is a predictable sequelae of ligament laxity. A new technique of tendon interposition arthroplasty with ligament reconstruction using the flexor carpi radialis tendon for a painful arthritic trapeziometacarpal joint of the thumb is described. Twenty-one patients had 25 operative procedures; 14 were women and seven were men. All of the patients presented with intractable pain, crepitus, and varying degrees of laxity of the basal joint. Pinch strength was diminished. Follow-up averaged 37 1/2 months. After surgery, 91.7% of patients had good to excellent results, and 56% were completely pain free. Range of motion and grip and pinch strengths were equal on the operated and unoperated sides.

An extraarticular ligament reconstruction to stabilize the painful, hypermobile trapeziometacarpal (basal) joint by routing a portion of the flexor carpi radialis (FCR) through the thumb metacarpal has been performed in 25 "prearthritic" (Stage I) and 17 minimally involved (Stage II) basal joints. At an average follow-up examination of 5.2 years, 100% of the Stage I patients had achieved good or excellent results, having little or no pain with return of strength and stability. Eighty-two percent of Stage II patients had similar results. Intractable pain was the primary surgical indication. Pain was dramatically relieved in all Stage I cases and in 70% of the Stage II cases. The presence and degree of crepitus correlated closely to the result and was a good prognostic indicator. Direct inspection of both the basal and scaphotrapezial joints is essential to determine whether ligament reconstruction or another surgical procedure is the procedure of choice. The procedure was particularly useful in patients with untreated Bennett's fractures. Follow-up roentgenograms showed no further degeneration, suggesting that the procedure was reliable, reproducible, and durable, and that it might even retard future joint degeneration.

Forty-six patients (fifty hands) had replacement of the trapezium by a silicone implant that incorporated a local tendon strip to stabilize the device. The patients had intractable pain due to degenerative changes of multiple facets of the trapezium. The over-all rate of subluxation and dislocation was 10 per cent. In all hands, pain-free improved movement resulted. The pinch strength approximated the normal, averaging six kilograms for women and eight kilograms for men.

Thirteen patients had thumb metacarpophalangeal (MP) capsulodesis in conjunction with basal joint arthroplasty. The indication for capsulodesis was an MP hyperextension deformity of at least 30 degrees. The minimum follow-up period was 12 months, and the average follow-up was 39 months. Nine patients had an excellent result, three had a good result, and one patient had a result that was rated as fair. Ten patients had complete correction of the MP hyperextension deformity. The average increase in pinch strength was 50%. This procedure enhances the result of a basal point arthroplasty by improving the transmission of force along the thumb ray and by correcting the metacarpal collapse, which produces dorsal subluxation stress on the metacarpotrapezial joint.

An extra-articular ligament reconstruction to stabilize the thumb carpometacarpal (CMC) (basal) joint by routing a portion of the flexor carpi radialis (FCR) through the base of the thumb metacarpal has been performed on more than 100 patients since 1967. This study reviews the first 50 consecutive reconstructions with an average follow-up of 7 years. Intractable pain was the primary indication for surgery. Each joint was examined both pre and postoperatively and rated as a stage I through stage IV according to the radiographic appearance. Of the patients with zero or minimal articular changes (stages I and II), 95% achieved good or excellent results because of having little or no postoperative pain. Of the patients with moderate to advanced degenerative changes (stages III and IV), 74% achieved good or excellent results. All stage I cases and 82% of stage II cases were free of recognizable degeneration on follow-up radiographs up to 13 years postoperatively. These findings suggest that ligament reconstruction that is now recommended only for stage I or stage II disease will restore stability, reduce pain, and possibly even retard joint degeneration in a large proportion of patients with painful instability of the thumb CMC joint.