Search

A new, aromatic analogue of the EPSP synthase enzyme reaction intermediate 1 has been identified, which contains a 3-hydroxymalonate moiety in place of the usual 3-phosphate group. This simplified inhibitor was readily prepared in five steps from ethyl 3,4-dihydroxybenzoate. The resulting tetrahedral intermediate mimic 9 is an effective, competitive inhibitor versus S3P with an apparent Ki of 0.57 +/- 0.06 microM. This result demonstrates that 3-hydroxymalonates exhibit potencies comparable to aromatic inhibitors containing the previously identified 3-malonate ether replacements and can thus function as suitable 3-phosphate mimics in this system. These new compounds provide another example in which a simple benzene ring can be used effectively in place of the more complex shikimate ring in the design of EPSP synthase inhibitors. Furthermore, the greater potency of 9 versus the glycolate derivative 10 and the 5-deoxy-analog 11, again confirms the requirement for multiple anionic charges at the dihydroxybenzoate 5-position in order to attain effective inhibition of this enzyme.

A novel EPSP synthase inhibitor 4 has been designed and synthesized to probe the configurational details of glyphosate recognition in its herbicidal ternary complex with enzyme and shikimate 3-phosphate (S3P). A kinetic evaluation of the new 3-dephospho analog 12, as well as calorimetric and (31)P NMR spectroscopic studies of enzyme-bound 4, now provides a more precise quantitative definition for the molecular interactions of 4 with this enzyme. The very poor binding, relative to 4, displayed by the 3-dephospho analog 12 is indicative that 4 has a specific interaction with the S3P site. A comparison of Ki(calc) for 12 versus the Ki(app) for 4 indicates that the 3-phosphate group in 4 contributes about 4.8 kcal/mol to binding. This compares well with the 5.2 kcal/mol which the 3-phosphate group in S3P contributes to binding. Isothermal titration calorimetry demonstrates that 4 binds to free enzyme with an observed Kd of 0.53 +/- 0.04 microM. As such, 4 binds only 3-fold weaker than glyphosate and about 150-fold better than N-methylglyphosate. Consequently, 4 represents the most potent N-alkylglyphosate derivative identified to date. However, the resulting thermodynamic binding parameters clearly demonstrate that the formation of EPSPS x 4 is entropy driven like S3P. The binding characteristics of 4 are fully consistent with a primary interaction localized at the S3P subsite. Furthermore, (31)P NMR studies of enzyme-bound 4 confirm the expected interaction at the shikimate 3-phosphate site. However, the chemical shift observed for the phosphonate signal of EPSPS x 4 is in the opposite direction than that observed previously when glyphosate binds with enzyme and S3P. Therefore, when 4 occupies the S3P binding site, there is incomplete overlap at the glyphosate phosphonate subsite. As a glyphosate analog inhibitor, the potency of 4 most likely arises from predominant interactions which occur outside the normal glyphosate binding site. Consequently, 4 is best described as an S3P-based substrate-analog inhibitor. These combined results corroborate the previous kinetic model [Gruys, K. J., Marzabadi, M. R., Pansegrau, P. D., & Sikorski, J. A. (1993) Arch. Biochem. Biophys. 304, 345-351], which suggested that 4 interacts well with the S3P subsite but has little, if any, interaction at the expected glyphosate phosphonate or phosphoenolpyruvate-Pi subsites.

A new analog of the EPSP synthase enzyme reaction intermediate 1, containing a 3-malonate ether moiety in place of the usual 3-phosphate group, was synthesized from 3,5-dihydroxybenzoic acid. This simple, synthetically accessible aromatic compound (5) is an effective competitive inhibitor versus S3P with an apparent Ki of 1.3 +/- 0.22 microM. This result demonstrates that a simple benzene ring can be a suitable achiral substitute for the more complex shikimate ring in the design of EPSP synthase inhibitors. Furthermore, the greater potency of 5 versus the phenol 6, glycolate 7 and the gallic acid analog 8 demonstrates the requirement for multiple anionic charges at the dihydroxybenzoate 5-position in order to attain effective inhibition of this enzyme. However, this 3-malonate ether substituted compound was at least 10-fold less effective as a bisubstrate inhibitor than the corresponding 3-phosphate. This suggests that tetrahedral intermediate mimics possessing a 3-malonate ether moiety are less effective than their corresponding 3-phosphates in accessing the optimal enzyme conformation stabilizing 1.

Numerous studies have confirmed that glyphosate forms a tight ternary complex with EPSP synthase and shikimate 3-phosphate. It has been proposed [Anton, D., Hedstrom, L., Fish, S., & Abeles, R. (1983) Biochemistry 22, 5903-5908; Steinrücken, H. C., & Amrhein, N. (1984) Eur. J. Biochem. 143, 351-357] that in this complex glyphosate functions as a transition-state analog of the putative phosphoenolpyruvoyl oxonium ion. For this to be true, glyphosate must occupy the space in the enzyme active site that is normally associated with PEP and, through turnover, the carboxyvinyl group of the product EPSP. According to this model, one would predict that, in the reverse EPSP synthase reaction with EPSP and phosphate as substrates, there should be little if any interaction of glyphosate with enzyme or enzyme.substrate complexes. In contrast to this expectation, rapid gel filtration experiments provided direct evidence that glyphosate could be trapped on the enzyme in the presence of EPSP to form a ternary complex of EPSPS.EPSP.glyphosate. The experimentally determined stoichiometry for this complex, 0.62 equiv of glyphosate/mole of EPSPS, is similar to that found for the EPSPS.S3P.glyphosate ternary complex (0.66). This direct binding result was corroborated and quantitated by fluorescence titration experiments which demonstrated that glyphosate forms a reasonably tight (Kd = 56 +/- 1 microM) ternary complex with enzyme and EPSP. This finding was further verified, and its impact on substrate turnover analyzed, by steady-state kinetics. Glyphosate was found to be an uncompetitive inhibitor versus EPSP with Kii(app) = 54 +/- 2 microM.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Aromatic analogues of the EPSP synthase enzyme substrate (S3P), reaction intermediate (1), and product (EPSP) were synthesized from 3,5-dihydroxybenzoic acid and were evaluated as inhibitors of E. coli EPSP synthase. These simple, synthetically accessible aromatic analogues are highly effective competitive inhibitors versus S3P with an apparent Ki for the tetrahedral intermediate analogue 4 of 160 +/- 40 nM. This demonstrates that a simple benzene ring is a quite suitable substitute for the complex shikimate ring in the design of EPSP synthase inhibitors.

Recently it has been found that the kinetic mechanism for Escherichia coli 5-enolpyruvoylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase (EPSPS) in the forward direction is random with synergistic binding of substrates and inhibitors (K. J. Gruys, M. C. Walker, and J. A. Sikorski, 1992, Biochemistry 31, 5534). This work, however, did not address the reverse reaction with 5-enolpyruvoylshikimate-3-phosphate (EPSP) and phosphate (Pi) as substrates where a similar question of random versus ordered addition of substrates remained. Previous transient-state kinetic results led to a proposal for an equilibrium-ordered mechanism, where binding of EPSP occurs first followed by Pi (K. S. Anderson, and K. A. Johnson, 1990, Chem. Rev. 90, 1131). Steady-state kinetic results of the reverse reaction presented here suggest that, like the forward reaction, addition of substrates occurs randomly. Initial velocity studies with EPSP and Pi show a normal intersecting pattern in the reciprocal plots, consistent with a random or steady-state-ordered mechanism, but not with equilibrium-ordered addition of substrates. Inhibition of the EPSPS reverse reaction by 5-amino-S3P or the S3P-glyphosate hybrid molecule gave the expected competitive patterns versus EPSP, but mixed noncompetitive patterns versus Pi. These results also disfavor an equilibrium-ordered model, but again are consistent with a random or steady-state-ordered mechanism. A more quantitative mechanistic analysis of the inhibition data to determine the true rather than apparent Ki values provides evidence for a random over a steady-state-ordered addition of substrates. These results in combination with previous findings lead to the conclusion that the mechanism is random addition of EPSP and Pi since it is the only possible model for substrate addition that is consistent with the cumulative data from all kinetic (transient- as well as steady-state) and direct binding studies.

The thermal denaturation of native Escherichia coli 5-enolpyruvoyl shikimate-3-phosphate (EPSP) synthase, its binary complex with shikimate-3-phosphate (S3P) and its ternary complex with S3P and glyphosate have been studied using highly-sensitive differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). All observed transitions are strongly scanning-rate-dependent and irreversible. Consistent with these observations, the data were better fit by a simple irreversible model than by the controversial reversible model more commonly employed. The results obtained provide additional support for the application of irreversible models to the thermal denaturation of proteins. The calculated parameters, activation energy (Ea), enthalpy of denaturation (delta H) and transition temperature (Tm), obtained from fitting to an irreversible model agree well with values obtained from approximation techniques. Further, the results show that the formation of the ternary complex greatly enhances the thermal stability of the enzyme (delta Tm = 10.6 degrees C), while the binding of S3P alone increases the transition temperature only slightly (delta Tm = 3 degrees C). The heat of binding calculated at the transition temperature also demonstrates the greater stability of the ternary complex (delta H = -70 kcal/mol) versus the binary complex (delta H = -10 kcal/mol).

Isothermal titration calorimetry measurements are reported which give important new binding constant (Kd) information for various substrate and inhibitor complexes of Escherichia coli EPSP synthase (EPSPS). The validity of this technique was first verified by determining Kd's for the known binary complex with the substrate, shikimate 3-phosphate (S3P), as well as the herbicidal ternary complex with S3P and glyphosate (EPSPS.S3P.glyphosate). The observed Kd's agreed very well with those from previous independently determined kinetic and fluorescence binding measurements. Further applications unequivocally demonstrate for the first time a fairly tight interaction between phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP) and free enzyme (Kd = 390 microM) as well as a correspondingly weak affinity for glyphosate (Kd = 12 mM) alone with enzyme. The formation of the EPSPS.PEP binary complex was independently corroborated using equilibrium dialysis. These results strongly suggest that S3P synergizes glyphosate binding much more effectively than it does PEP binding. These observations add important new evidence to support the hypothesis that glyphosate acts as a transition-state analogue of PEP. However, the formation of a catalytically productive PEP binary complex is inconsistent with the previously reported compulsory binding order process required for catalysis and has led to new studies which completely revise the overall EPSPS kinetic mechanism. A previously postulated ternary complex between S3P and inorganic phosphate (EPSPS.S3P.Pi, Kd = 4 mM) was also detected for the first time. Quantitative binding enthalpies and entropies were also determined for each ligand complex from the microcalorimetry data. These values demonstrate a clear difference in thermodynamic parameters for recognition at the S3P site versus those observed for the PEP, Pi, and glyphosate sites.

Previous studies of Escherichia coli 5-enolpyruvoylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase (EPSPS, EC 2.5.1.19) have suggested that the kinetic reaction mechanism for this enzyme in the forward direction is equilibrium ordered with shikimate 3-phosphate (S3P) binding first followed by phosphoenolpyruvate (PEP). Recent results from this laboratory, however, measuring direct binding of PEP and PEP analogues to free EPSPS suggest more random character to the enzyme. Steady-state kinetic and spectroscopic studies presented here indicate that E. coli EPSPS does indeed follow a random kinetic mechanism. Initial velocity studies with S3P and PEP show competitive substrate inhibition by PEP added to a normal intersecting pattern. Substrate inhibition is proposed to occur by competitive binding of PEP at the S3P site [Ki(PEP) = 6-8 mM]. To test for a productive EPSPS.PEP binary complex, the reaction order of EPSPS was evaluated with shikimic acid and PEP as substrates. The mechanism for this reaction is equilibrium ordered with PEP binding first giving a Kia value for PEP in agreement with the independently measured Kd of 0.39 mM (shikimate Km = 25 mM). Results from this study also show that the 3-phosphate moiety of S3P offers 8.7 kcal/mol in binding energy versus a hydroxyl in this position. Over 60% of this binding energy is expressed in binding of substrate to enzyme rather than toward increasing kcat. Glyphosate inhibition of shikimate turnover was poor with approximately 8 x 10(4) loss in binding capacity compared to the normal reaction, consistent with the independently measured Kd of 12 mM for the EPSPS.glyphosate binary complex. The EPSPS.glyphosate complex induces shikimate binding, however, by a factor of 7 greater than EPSPS.PEP. Carboxyallenyl phosphate and (Z)-3-fluoro-PEP were found to be strong inhibitors of the enzyme that have surprising affinity for the S3P binding domain in addition to the PEP site as measured both kinetically and by direct observation with 31P NMR. The collective data indicate that the true kinetic mechanism for EPSPS in the forward direction is random with synergistic binding occurring between substrates and inhibitors. The synergism explains how the mechanism can be random with S3P and PEP, but yet equilibrium ordered with PEP binding first for shikimate turnover. Synergism also accounts for how glyphosate can be a strong inhibitor of the normal reaction, but poor versus shikimate turnover.

Direct observation of the tetrahedral intermediate in the EPSP synthase reaction pathway was provided by 13C NMR by examining the species bound to the enzyme active site under internal equilibrium conditions and using [2-13C]PEP as a spectroscopic probe. The tetrahedral center of the intermediate bound to the enzyme gave a unique signal appearing at 104 ppm. Separate signals were observed for free EPSP (152 ppm) and EPSP bound to the enzyme in a ternary complex with phosphate (161 ppm). These peak assignments account for our quantitation of the species bound to the enzyme and liberated upon quenching with either triethylamine or base. A comparison of quenching with acid, base, or triethylamine was conducted; the intermediate could be isolated by quenching with either triethylamine or 0.2 N KOH, allowing direct quantitation of the species bound to the enzyme. After long times of incubation during the NMR measurement, a signal at 107 ppm appeared. The compound giving rise to this resonance was isolated and identified as an EPSP ketal [Leo et al. (1990) J. Am. Chem. Soc. (in press)]. The rate of formation of the EPSP ketal was very slow, 3.3 X 10(-5) s-1, establishing that it is a side product of the normal enzymatic reaction, probably arising as a breakdown product of the tetrahedral intermediate. A slow formation of pyruvate was also observed and is attributable to the enzymatic hydrolysis of EPSP, with 5% of the enzyme sites occupied by EPSP and hydrolyzing EPSP at a rate of 4.7 X 10(-4) s-1. To look for additional signals that might arise from a covalent adduct which has been postulated to arise from reaction of enzyme with PEP, an NMR experiment was performed with an analogue of S3P lacking the 4- and 5-hydroxyl groups.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Reaction of 5-enolpyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase of Escherichia coli with the thiol reagent 5,5'-dithiobis-(2-nitrobenzoic acid) (DTNB) leads to a modification of only 2 of the 6 cysteines of the enzyme, with a significant loss of its enzymatic activity. Under denaturing conditions, however, all 6 cysteines of 5-enolpyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase react with DTNB, indicating the absence of disulfide bridges in the native protein. In the presence of shikimate 3-phosphate and glyphosate, only 1 of the 2 cysteines reacts with the reagent, with no loss of activity, suggesting that only 1 of these cysteines is at or near the active site of the enzyme. Cyanolysis of the DTNB-inactivated enzyme with KCN leads to elimination of 5-thio-2-nitrobenzoate, with formation of the thiocyano-enzyme. The thiocyano-enzyme is fully active; it exhibits a small increase in its I50 for glyphosate (6-fold) and apparent Km for phosphoenolpyruvate (4-fold) compared to the unmodified enzyme. Its apparent Km for shikimate 3-phosphate is, however, unaltered. These results clearly establish the nonessentiality of the active site-reactive cysteine of E. coli 5-enolpyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase for either catalysis or substrate binding. Perturbations in the kinetic constants for phosphoenolpyruvate and glyphosate suggest that the cysteine thiol is proximal to the binding site for these ligands. By N-[14C]ethylmaleimide labeling, tryptic mapping, and N-terminal sequencing, the 2 reactive cysteines have been identified as Cys408 and Cys288. The cysteine residue protected by glyphosate and shikimate 3-phosphate from its reaction with DTNB was found to be Cys408.

The binding of substrates and the herbicide N-(phosphonomethyl)glycine (glyphosate) to enolpyruvoylshikimate-3-phosphate (EPSP) synthase was evaluated by stopped-flow and equilibrium fluorescence measurements. Changes in protein fluorescence were observed upon the binding of EPSP and upon the formation of the enzyme-shikimate 3-phosphate-glyphosate ternary complex; no change was seen with either shikimate 3-phosphate (S3P) or glyphosate alone. By fluorescence titrations, the dissociation constants were determined for the formation of the enzyme binary complexes with S3P (Kd,S = 7 +/- 1.2 microM) and EPSP (Kd,EPSP = 1 +/- 0.01 microM). The dissociation constant for S3P was determined by competition with EPSP or by measurements in the presence of a low glyphosate concentration. At saturating concentrations of S3P, glyphosate bound to the enzyme--S3P binary complex with a dissociation constant of 0.16 +/- 0.02 microM. Glyphosate did not bind significantly to free enzyme, so the binding is ordered with S3P binding first: (formula; see text) where S refers to S3P, G refers to glyphosate, and E.S.G. represents the complex with altered fluorescence. The kinetics of binding were measured by stopped-flow fluorescence methods. The rate of glyphosate binding to the enzyme--S3P complex was k2 = (7.8 +/- 0.2) X 10(5) M-1 s-1, from which we calculated the dissociation rate k-2 = 0.12 +/- 0.02 s-1.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Direct evidence for an enzyme-bound intermediate in the EPSP synthase reaction pathway has been obtained by rapid chemical quench-flow studies. The transient-state kinetic analysis has led to the following complete scheme: (formula; see text) Values for all 12 rate constants were obtained. Substrate trapping experiments in the forward and reverse reactions established the kinetically preferred order of binding and release of substrates and products and showed that shikimate 3-phosphate (S3P) and 5-enolpyruvoylshikimate 3-phosphate (EPSP) dissociate at rates greater than turnover in each direction. Pre-steady-state bursts of product formation were observed in the reaction in each direction indicating a rate-limiting step following catalysis. Single turnover experiments with enzyme in excess over substrate demonstrated the formation of a transient intermediate in both the forward and reverse reactions. In these experiments, the enzymatic reaction was observed by employing a radiolabel in the enol moiety of either phosphoenol pyruvate (PEP) or EPSP. The separation and quantitation of reaction products were accomplished by HPLC monitoring radioactivity. The intermediate was observed as the transient production of radiolabeled pyruvate, formed due to the breakdown of the intermediate in the acid quench used to stop the reaction. The intermediate was observed within 5-10 ms after the substrates were mixed with enzyme and decayed in a reaction paralleling the formation of product in each direction. Thus, the kinetics demonstrate directly the kinetic competence of the presumed intermediate. No pyruvate was formed, on a time scale which is relevant to catalysis, after incubation of the enzyme with dideoxy-S3P and PEP or with EPSP in the absence of phosphate; and so, the intermediate does not accumulate under these conditions. The intermediate broke down to form PEP and EPSP in addition to pyruvate when the reaction was quenched with base rather than acid; therefore, the intermediate must contain the elements of each product. Other experiments were designed to measure directly the phosphate binding rate and further constrain the PEP binding rate. The overall solution equilibrium constant in the forward direction was determined to be 180 by quantitation of radiolabeled reactants and products in equilibrium after incubation with a low enzyme concentration. The internal, active site equilibrium constant was obtained by incubation of radiolabeled S3P with excess enzyme and high concentrations of phosphate and PEP to provide the ratio of [EPSP]/[S3P] = 2.3, which is largely a measure of K4.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)