1. Conflicting interpretations of Rome, Open City in 1945 Italy.
- Author
-
Cragin, Thomas
- Subjects
- *
ITALIAN films , *POST-World War II Period , *COMMUNISM , *TWENTIETH century , *HISTORY of communism ,HISTORY & criticism ,ITALIAN politics & government, 1945-1976 ,FASCISM in Italy ,HISTORY of fascism - Abstract
The article shows that the major Italian- and English-language interpretations ofRome, Open Cityshare a set of common assumptions about the meanings of the film for its 1945 viewers: that the film offered a coherent meaning that it still holds out to viewers today, that it owed its original success to its accuracy, that is, to its compatibility with most Italians’ memories of the war, and that its meaning and content were a function of its makers’ intentions. The article demonstrates that political and social conditions in postwar Italy rendered political newspapers’ reviews of the film an unusually good guide to understanding ideologically influenced audience perceptions. These reviews reveal three entirely different and contradictory interpretations of the film, each a product of a different, politically defined interpretive community: Christian Democrats and Liberals, Socialists and Actionists, and Communists. Rightist and extreme leftist reviews described and praised seemingly very different films. Especially significant is the Socialist and Actionist rejection ofRome, Open Cityas dangerously misleading. Overall, the article’s analysis of critical reception discourses highlights their value to the development of a more complex and meaningful understanding of diverse spectatorships of Italian cinema in the immediate postwar period. [ABSTRACT FROM PUBLISHER]
- Published
- 2017
- Full Text
- View/download PDF