Search

Objective: To test the hypothesis that many patients with alcoholic liver disease have coexisting hepatitis C virus (HCV) infection which promotes the development of cirrhosis., Design: Prospective, two-centre study comparing patients with alcoholic liver disease with HCV-positive blood donors identified by the Regional Blood Transfusion Service., Setting: Two teaching hospitals in Glasgow, UK., Patients: Sixty patients admitted to hospital with a diagnosis of alcoholic liver disease on the basis of clinical and histological tests. For comparison, a group of 50 anti-HCV-positive subjects identified from 305,012 blood donors during the same period (1991-1993) were questioned about their alcohol consumption and liver biopsy specimens are taken., Main Outcome Measures: The prevalence of HCV infection was determined by a second generation enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) for anti-HCV and by liver histology., Results: No patients with alcoholic liver disease were anti-HCV-positive. Of the blood donors with chronic HCV infection, 11 (22%) reported previous or continuing consumption of more than 80 g alcohol daily for at least 2 consecutive years but liver histology in all 50 cases showed features characteristic of chronic HCV. There was no difference in liver histology between donors with a history of high alcohol consumption [mean grade 2.6 (range, 1-5), stage 0.4 (range, 0-2)] and abstinent, anti-HCV-positive donors [grade 2.8 (0-5), stage 0.5 (range 0-1)]., Conclusions: The absence of anti-HCV in this population of patients with alcoholic liver disease shows that HCV is not a necessary or a common cofactor in the development of alcoholic liver disease in the west of Scotland.

Since blood donor screening for the hepatitis C virus (HCV) began in 1991 a large number of seropositive subjects have been detected and several reports have suggested a high prevelance of liver disease. The aim of this study was to evaluate the severity of liver disease in HCV-positive blood donors in terms of the clinical, biochemical and histological abnormalities and to investigate the relationships between these features and the mode of transmission, duration of infection and viral genotype. We evaluated 54 consecutive blood donors who were positive for HCV both on serological testing and polymerase chain reaction. Twenty-three (43%) had a history of intravenous drug abuse and 17 (31%) had received blood transfusions. In only two (4%) was no risk factor identified. The mean duration of infection in those with a clear history of HCV exposure was 12 years. Eighty-three percent were HCV genotypes 1 or 3. All had abnormal liver biopsies with chronic hepatitis and several patients had periportal or portal-portal fibrous septa, but there was none with architectural distortion or cirrhosis. There was no correlation between severity of liver disease and duration of HCV infection, mode of transmission or viral genotype. In the majority of HCV carriers detected at donor screening there is a chronic hepatitis with bridging necrosis in one third, but the degree of fibrosis is minimal and cirrhosis was not present in our patients. The long period of infection of many patients suggests that irreversible liver injury does not necessarily develop at an early stage despite persistent infection.