1. A feminist critique of research on menopausal experience of Korean women.
- Author
-
Im E, Meleis AI, and Park YS
- Subjects
POWER (Social sciences) ,TRADITIONAL medicine ,TERMS & phrases ,MENOPAUSE ,HUMAN research subjects ,TRANSLATIONS ,ATTITUDES toward sex ,RESEARCH methodology ,COMMUNICATION ,PATIENT-professional relations ,FEMINIST criticism ,CULTURAL pluralism ,EVALUATION - Abstract
OBJECTIVE: To propose directions for future research on menopause, we analyzed and critiqued 158 studies on the menopausal experience of a group of Korean women. In this paper, we take a feminist stance that the menopausal experience of Asian women does not come from pure biology, but from their continuous interactions with their environment. DESIGN: Systemic review. SETTING: NA. POPULATION: Menopausal Korean women. INTERVENTIONS: An extensive literature search on menopause in Korean women was conducted using the MEDLINE and MELVYL data retrieval systems. Korean literature was searched through four major university libraries in South Korea. A total of 158 studies were reviewed, and the collected articles were analyzed and critiqued in terms of biases present in the research process. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S): Issues in conceptualization included biomedical oriented perspectives and underlying assumptions and language differences. Issues related to research methods included inadequate instruments, passive relationships between researchers and research participants, culturally inappropriate communication style, inadequate study designs, limited contextuality, and homogeneous research participants. Issues related to interpretation of results included misinterpretation of symptoms and communication of study findings. The analyses of research on the menopausal experience of Korean women indicate limitations of the research process from conceptualization to interpretation. RESULTS/CONCLUSIONS: The analyses of research on the menopausal experience of Korean women indicate limitations of the research process from conceptualization to interpretation. This suggests that interpretation, understanding, and generalization of the findings of the previous studies on menopausal experience of Asian women during menopausal transition should be undertaken with caution. [CINAHL abstract] [ABSTRACT FROM AUTHOR]
- Published
- 1999