Search

Despite improvements in short-term renal allograft survival, long-term survival has not appreciably changed. Excepting death with a functioning graft, most late graft loss results from chronic allograft dysfunction. Immune and non-immune-mediated injuries contribute to graft dysfunction over time, ultimately leading to a non-specific and irreversible histological end-point of fibrosis, tubular atrophy, and glomerulosclerosis. Screening and early identification of pathology is crucial to allow timely intervention in order to prevent permanent nephron damage and graft loss. This chapter outlines assessment of renal dysfunction following transplantation, defines the causes of chronic allograft failure, and their pathophysiology, and evaluates current therapeutic strategies used to improve or stabilize chronic allograft dysfunction.

Noninherited maternal human leukocyte antigens may be less detrimental on allograft outcomes after kidney transplantation compared with noninherited paternal antigens, but this association in the era of modern immunosuppression remains unknown. Here we determine the association between parental donor kidneys, acute rejection, and graft failure in primary live-donor parental kidney transplant recipients using data from the Australia and New Zealand Dialysis and Transplant Registry between 1997 and 2012. Of the 1139 recipients followed for a median of 7.2 years (8588 person-years), 652 received kidneys from maternal donors. Compared with paternal donor kidneys, maternal donor kidneys were associated with a significantly increased risk of acute rejection (adjusted odds ratio 1.54; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.14–2.07) and significant overall graft loss. The latter was confined to recipients who have experienced acute rejection (adjusted hazard ratio 1.60; 95%CI, 1.05–2.43) but not in those who did not experience acute rejection. Thus, our study suggests that recipients of maternal donor kidneys have a greater risk of rejection and graft loss. Hence, clinicians and patients should be cognizant of this association when determining which of the 2 parental donors is most suitable for transplantation.

Background. For dialysis patients with a cancer history, a period of surveillance is generally recommended before listing for transplantation. However, the outcomes of patients with cancer recurrence and/or a second primary cancer after transplantation are unknown. Aim. To determine the prognosis of kidney transplant recipients who developed cancer after transplantation and whether this varied with cancer types (first cancer, recurrence, second primary cancer). Methods. Using data from the Australian and New Zealand Dialysis and Transplant Registry, we compared the cancer-specific and all-cause mortality among recipients with different cancer types using adjusted Cox proportional hazard models. Results. Of the 21,415 recipients transplanted between 1965 and 2012, 3%(651 of 21,415) had a previous cancer history. A total of 2840 (13%) recipients developed cancer after the first transplant, of whom 2760 (97.2%) developed a first cancer, 23 (0.8%) experienced cancer recurrence, and 57 (2%) developed a second primary cancer. There were no significant differences in the risks of cancer-specific and all-cause mortality between recipients who developed their first cancer after transplant, those with cancer recurrence (adjusted hazard ratios [aHRs], 0.79; 95% confidence interval [95% CI], 0.38-1.67; P = 0.54 and aHRs, 0.86; 95% CI, 0.45-1.66; P = 0.66, respectively) and recipients who developed a second primary cancer after transplantation (aHRs, 1.01; 95% CI, 0.63-1.62; P = 0.95 and aHRs, 1.16; 95% CI, 0.79-1.69; P = 0.45, respectively). Conclusion. Among patients with a previous history of malignancy, recurrent and second primary cancers are infrequent after renal transplantation. A history of previous malignancy does not have an additive effect on the cancer-specific and overall survival of kidney transplant recipients who develop cancer.

Background Screening for donor-specific anti-HLA antibodies (DSA) using bead-based multiplex assays to determine transplant suitability is standard practice in many countries. We compared the health benefits and costs of screening preformed DSA using bead-based assay as an add-on test to complement-dependent cytotoxicity (CDC) crossmatch with CDC crossmatch alone, and determined the optimal threshold to determine transplant suitability. Methods Three probabilistic Markov models were developed to compare bead-based assay with CDC and CDC alone. The model assumed a hypothetical cohort of 10,000 patients who received only a single kidney transplant and terminated when all patients were deceased. Results Assuming transplantation was permitted for recipients with no DSA or with a DSA mean fluorescence intensity (MFI) value of 500 or less, screening by bead-based assay and CDC saved 6.5 grafts and U.S. $1,192,303 per 100 transplants compared with CDC alone. If the thresholds were increased to an MFI of 2000 or less and 5000 or less, an extra 6.4 and 6.1 grafts would be saved, with cost savings of U.S. $867,203 and U.S. $830,664 per 100 transplants compared with CDC alone. The total number of kidney transplants performed would have increased by 8 and 9, respectively, but at the expense of an extra 0.1 and 0.4 graft lost per 100 transplants after 5 years. Conclusions Screening using bead-based assay is cost-saving and improves graft outcomes. The greatest benefits and cost-savings are achieved if transplantation occurs at a threshold of MFI of 500 or less or in those without preformed DSA. Increasing the threshold to an MFI of 2000 or less may provide an acceptable balance for improving transplant eligibility without compromising longer-term outcomes.

Background Reactivation of BK polyoma virus can result in destructive viral allograft nephropathy (BKVAN) with limited treatment options. Screening programs using surrogate markers of viral replication are important preventive strategies, guiding immunosuppression reduction. Methods We prospectively evaluated the diagnostic test performance of urinary decoy cells and urinary SV40T immunochemistry of exfoliated cells, to screen for BKVAN, (defined by reference histology with SV40 immunohistochemistry, n = 704 samples), compared with quantitative viremia, from 211 kidney and 141 kidney-pancreas transplant recipients. Results The disease prevalence of BKVAN was 2.6%. Decoy cells occurred in 95 of 704 (13.5%) samples, with a sensitivity of 66.7%, specificity of 88.6%, positive predictive value (PPV) of 11.7%, and negative predictive value of 98.5% to predict histologically proven BKVAN. Quantification of decoy cells improved the PPV to 32.1% (10 ≥ cells threshold). Immunohistochemical staining of urinary exfoliated cells for SV40T improved sensitivity to 85.7%, detecting atypical or degenerate infected cells (specificity of 92.3% and PPV of 33.3%), but was hampered by technical failures. Viremia occurred in 90 of 704 (12.8%) with sensitivity of 96.3%, specificity of 90.3%, PPV of 31.5%, and negative predictive value of 99.8%. The receiver-operator curve performance of quantitative viremia surpassed decoy cells (area under the curve of 0.95 and 0.79, respectively, P = 0.0018 for differences). Combining decoy cell and BK viremia in a diagnostic matrix improved prediction of BKVAN and diagnostic risk stratification, especially for high-level positive results. Conclusions Although quantified decoy cells are acceptable surrogate markers of BK viral replication with unexceptional test performances, quantitative viremia displayed superior test characteristics and is suggested as the screening test of choice.

Subclinical rejection (SCR) is diagnosed by protocol histology with a maximal prevalence occurring early after transplantation, falling to low levels by 1 year. Needle-core biopsy is safe, and the histology obtained fairly reflects subclinical immune activity. Several studies have consistently shown that SCR is associated with chronic tubulointerstitial damage, subsequent renal dysfunction and reduced graft survival. SCR is effectively treated by pulse corticosteroid therapy, although increased baseline immunosuppression may be necessary. A single randomized clinical trial of biopsy and corticosteroid therapy demonstrated significantly improved early structural and functional outcomes, and a (nonsignificant) 17% risk reduction in 4-year graft survival. Three possible approaches include: no protocol biopsies (usually accompanied by powerful immunosuppression); biopsies only in high-risk recipients (who may be difficult to reliably predict) or universal screening protocol biopsy (comprehensive but limited by cost and resource utilization). The appropriate screening methodology for a transplant unit is both a clinical and an economic decision; influenced by the SCR prevalence and potential gains of treatment, against costs and resource utilization. Further trials to quantify the cost-benefit balance in a typical, heterogeneous recipient population using modern immunosuppression are required.

In earlier registry analyses, cyclosporine at doses of3 mg/kg/d at 1 year post-renal transplantation has been associated with significant graft loss or reduction in renal function. Improvements in cyclosporine formulation with increased bioavailability, plus the use of more efficient comedications, may now confer better outcomes. To determine the effect of the 1-year cyclosporine microemulsion (CsA-ME) dose on renal allograft function at 5 years, we analyzed data collected from 2889 patients with documented graft survival to year 5 in a prospective, multinational, observational study-Neoral MOST.Glomerular filtration rate (GFR) at year 1 was 63 +/- 20 mL/min and 59 +/- 22 mL/min at year 5. The multivariate analysis including year 1 CsA-ME dose as factor and GFR at 1 year as covariate revealed the most significant factors affecting GFR at year 5 were 1-year GFR, donor age60 years, and CsA-ME dose at 1 year. Risk factors associated with reduction in 5-year GFR (65 mL/min) included donor or recipient age60 years, delayed graft function, cadaveric donor, previous graft, and acute rejection. CsA-ME dose3 mg/kg/d was found to protect GFR. Analysis of GFR at each year posttransplantation (Wilcoxon model) found 1-year CsA-ME (cutoff 3 mg/kg/d) had a significant effect at each time point.Compared to higher doses, CsA-ME3 mg/kg/d at year 1 posttransplantation is associated with increased preservation of renal allograft function at year 5.

Background Long-term success of renal transplantation depends upon the quality of the donor organ, avoidance of peritransplant and early posttransplant damage (rejection), and optimal maintenance of graft function after the first 6-12 months. Glomerular filtration rate (GFR) at 1 year is a standard way to evaluate short-term success, whereas calculated GFR at 5 years gives a better appreciation of long-term outcomes. The objective of this study was to assess the effect of various demographic and transplant-related parameters on renal function via GFR at 1 year and 5 years post transplantation, using univariate and multivariate data analysis. Methods Data on 1-year GFR were available from 10,397 patients, whereas 2,889 patients provided data on both 1-year and 5-year GFR. All patients were enrolled in the Neoral Multinational Observational Study in Transplantation (Neoral-MOST), an ongoing, prospective, observational study of adult renal transplant recipients. Results One-year GFR was the most relevant predictor for 5-year GFR. In a multifactorial analysis (ANCOVA) using 1-year GFR as a continuous variable, the effects of several highly relevant parameters from univariate analysis (such as acute rejection and delayed graft function) on 5-year GFR appeared to be fully mediated by their influence on 1-year GFR, whereas immunological risk factors like HLA match or previous transplantation had an ongoing effect on graft function beyond year 1. Conclusions The findings of this study corroborate and augment data from previous registry surveys, and confirm the importance of observational studies in investigating the role of peritransplant parameters on long-term graft outcome.

SUMMARY: Sirolimus (Rapamycin, Wyeth Pharmaceuticals Australia Pty Ltd, Baulkham Hills, NSW, Australia) (SRL) has received increasing attention as an immunosuppressant in renal and other solid organ transplantation. Sirolimus is the first marketed agent in a new class of drugs with a novel mechanism of action. Sirolimus binds, like tacrolimus, to a member of the FK binding protein (FKBP) family. The SRL/FKBP complex binds to the protein kinase mTOR. Binding to mTOR blocks activation of signal transduction pathways causing arrest of the cell cycle in the G1 phase. It is now known that mTOR is a central regulator of cell growth and proliferation. The immunosuppressive properties of SRL are due primarily to blockade of interleukin-2 (IL-2)-induced proliferation of T cells. There is still much to be learnt about how best to use the drug. The key advantage over the current choice of immunosuppressive agents is the ability to preserve renal function and pathology while producing excellent rejection-free, graft survival rates. Thus, SRL may find its pivotal role as a calcineurin inhibitors replacement in patients whose grafts are affected by chronic allograft nephropathy. A second major driver for use may prove to be the impact of SRL on cancer incidence and prognosis. Studies still need to be performed to evaluate the best timing for commencement of SRL and the optimal dosage to minimize side-effects.

SUMMARY: Biopsy of cadaver renal allografts may aid in the assessment of marginal allografts. However, the use of this approach is not clear. This study presents the outcome of institution of a protocol for back table biopsy of renal allografts during organ procurement. Methods: Data from Lifelink Organ Donation Network records and the ANZDATA registry were analysed. Results: The biopsy rate of renal allografts increased from 0.8% to 15.6% (P = 0.01). The discardment rate of potential renal allografts increased slightly with 1.9% being discarded based on the biopsy result and 3.8% being discarded for other reasons. Under the biopsy protocol, 28/40 (70%) of donors with renal allograft biopsies had

Objective: This analysis evaluates the cost-effectiveness of valaciclovir prophylaxis using clinically and economically important health outcomes including graft failure, life-years, and quality-adjusted life-years (QALYs). Methods: A Markov model was developed using a randomized, placebo-controlled trial of valaciclovir prophylaxis, together with a published epidemiological study and national renal transplant registry data. The model's population was stratified into two risk groups by donor/recipient cytomegalovirus (CMV) serostatus at transplantation: donor-positive/recipient-negative (D+R−) and recipient-positive (R+) patients. The model estimated costs and health outcomes over a 30-yr period from the perspective of Australian health care providers. Results: The total health care cost was $3619 lower for D+R− patients receiving valaciclovir prophylaxis compared with those not receiving prophylaxis. D+R− patients receiving valaciclovir gained an extra 0.33 yr of life and 0.27 QALYs. R+ patients receiving valaciclovir prophylaxis gained an extra 0.07 yr of life and 0.05 QALYs, with an incremental cost of $914. This equates to $17 127 per QALY gained, which is highly cost-effective compared with other drugs and health interventions. Conclusions: Valaciclovir for the prophylaxis of CMV disease in renal transplant recipients is a cost-effective intervention, significantly reducing the burden of CMV disease to patients and health care providers.

Noncompliance can be defined as covert nonadherence to prescribed medication used for the prophylaxis of allograft rejection and threatening impaired kidney histology or function. It is an increasingly significant long-term problem in transplantation as the failure rates from other causes have diminished. Formal approaches to diagnosis, prophylaxis, and treatment, together with a greater understanding of what should be regarded as a syndrome, are thus increasingly important components of reducing the chronic attrition of graft function and survival. It is possible to classify noncompliant behavior using four facets of the syndrome: timing, frequency, origin, and diagnostic certainty. There are a number of different ways of approaching diagnosis, such as observation of behavior through pill counting or electronic measurements of pill container opening; blood level measurement of relevant drugs; physical examination; and observation of the consequences. However, the only certainty of diagnosis comes from direct patient admission of nonadherence to the prescribed immunosuppression. It is possible to define the highest risk patients through assessment of a number of patient-, drug-, and physician-associated variables, and then to influence the outcome through education, compliance monitoring, and simplified regimens targeted to the highest risk patients. It is important for all transplant units to address the issues raised by noncompliance if the chronic loss of allografts is to be reduced.

Background: Interleukin 2 receptor antagonists (IL-2Ra) are increasingly used to treat renal transplant recipients. This study aims to systematically identify and summarize the effects of using IL-2Ra as induction immunosuppression, as an addition to standard therapy, or as an alternative to other antibody therapy. Methods: Databases, reference lists, and abstracts of conference proceedings were searched extensively to identify relevant randomized controlled trials in all languages. Data were synthesized using the random effects model. Results are expressed as relative risk (RR), with 95% confidence intervals (CI). Results: A total of 117 reports from 38 trials involving 4,893 participants were included. When IL-2Ra were compared with placebo (17 trials; 2,786 patients), graft loss was not significantly different at 1 year (14 trials: RR 0.84; CI 0.64–1.10) or 3 years (4 trials: RR 1.08; CI 0.71–1.64). Acute rejection was significantly reduced at 6 months (12 trials: RR 0.66; CI 0.59–0.74) and at 1 year (10 trials: RR 0.67; CI 0.60–0.75). At 1 year, cytomegalovirus infection (7 trials: RR 0.82; CI 0.65–1.03) and malignancy (9 trials: RR 0.67; CI 0.33–1.36) were not significantly different. When IL-2Ra were compared with other antibody therapy, no significant differences in treatment effects were demonstrated, but IL-2Ra had significantly fewer side effects. Conclusions: Given a 40% risk of rejection, seven patients would need treatment with IL-2Ra in addition to standard therapy, to prevent one patient from undergoing rejection, with no definite improvement in graft or patient survival. There is no apparent difference between basiliximab and daclizumab.

methods We evaluated the natural history of chronic allograft nephropathy in a prospective study of 120 recipients with type 1 diabetes, all but 1 of whom had received kidney–pancreas transplants. We obtained 961 kidney-transplant–biopsy specimens taken regularly from the time of transplantation to 10 years thereafter. results Two distinctive phases of injury were evident as chronic allograft nephropathy evolved. An initial phase of early tubulointerstitial damage from ischemic injury (P

INTRODUCTION The purpose of this study was to evaluate early cyclosporine (CsA) withdrawal from a sirolimus (SRL)-CsA-steroid (ST) regimen. METHODS Within 48 hr after transplantation, 525 primary (90%) or secondary (10%) renal allograft recipients with cadaveric (89%) or living (11%) donors received 2 mg of SRL (troughs >5 ng/mL; immunoassay), CsA, and ST. Those eligible (430) were randomly assigned (1:1) at 3 months +/- 2 weeks to remain on triple-drug therapy (SRL-CsA-ST group) or to have CsA withdrawn and SRL trough concentrations targeted to 20 to 30 ng/mL (SRL-ST group) until month 12, and 15 to 25 ng/mL thereafter. RESULTS At 24 months, there were no statistically significant differences in patient survival (94.0% vs. 95.3%), graft survival (91.2% vs. 93.5%), acute rejection after randomization (5.1% vs. 9.8%) or discontinuations (34% vs. 33%) for SRL-CsA-ST versus SRL-ST, respectively. Serum creatinine level was significantly better in patients who had CsA withdrawn (167 vs. 128 micromol/L, P

Autosomal dominant polycystic kidney disease (ADPKD) can affect several organs in addition to the kidney. There is paucity in the literature on the cardiac manifestations of this disease. This retrospective study aimed to assess whether ADPKD was associated with a larger coronary artery diameter and to evaluate for the presence of coronary artery aneurysm and ectasia. This study shows that subjects with ADPKD and end-stage renal failure have dilatation of coronary arteries independent of traditional coronary risk factors and medication use.

The available research in the area of roundabout intersections was surveyed with focus primarily on concerns about their installation. The Federal Highway Administration’s 2000 publication, Roundabouts: An Informational Guide, examines what should be done after the decision has been made to install a roundabout. This guide, while a good reference, does not provide specific decision-making criteria, the main focus of this proposed framework. The areas of focus are not to be considered exhaustive or complete but as suggested criteria, as the use of warrants seeks to imply. The areas covered in depth by these criteria are pedestrian volume, horizontal alignment, vertical alignment, and unbalanced flow volumes. In addition, safety and relevant local concerns should be focused on in the overall decision-making process.

Introduction Les criteres de jugement rapportes dans les essais cliniques sont souvent heterogenes et rarement centres sur le patient ce qui diminue la pertinence de leurs resultats. Notre but etait d’identifier les criteres de jugement les plus important en transplantation renale pour les patients, leurs aidants et les professionnels de sante. Materiels et methodes Lors d’une enquete Delphi a 3 tours, nous avons demande a des patients/aidants et professionnels de sante de noter sur une echelle de Likert a 9 points l’importance de criteres de jugement utilises en transplantation renale. Au cours des 2es et 3es tours, les participants re-notaient leurs propres scores apres avoir reevalue leur precedente notation, celle des autres participants et tous les commentaires rapportes precedemment. Nous avons calcule la mediane et la moyenne des scores ainsi que les proportions de scores entre 7 et 9 puis effectue une analyse thematique des commentaires. Resultats Au total, 1018 participants (461 [45 %] patients/aidants et 557 [55 %] professionnels de sante) venant de 79 pays ont complete le 1er tour et 779 (77 %) le 3e tour. Les 8 criteres de jugement ayant atteint un consensus entre les 2 groupes (moyenne ≥ 7,5, mediane ≥ 8 et proportion 7–9 > 85 %) etaient : perte du greffon, fonction du greffon, rejet chronique, rejet aigu, mortalite, infection, cancer (non cutane), et evenements cardiovasculaires. Le groupe patients/aidants a donne une plus grande importance a 6 criteres de jugement (difference de moyenne de 0,5 ou plus) par rapport au groupe professionnels de sante : cancer cutane, complications chirurgicales, cognition, pression arterielle, depression et capacite a travailler. Nous avons identifie 5 themes : capacite a controler et inevitabilite, pertinence personnelle, repercussion debilitantes, prise de conscience des risques et reponses aux lacunes dans les connaissances. Discussion Les criteres de jugement relatifs aux complications du greffon et aux complications cliniques severes etaient notes comme les plus importants pour les 2 groupes de participants. Conclusion L’obtention d’un consensus fonde sur l’opinion partage des patients/aidants et professionnels de sante permettra d’ameliorer la coherence et l’homogeneite des criteres de jugement evalues dans les essais en transplantation renale. Groupe(s) de travail SONG-Tx.

Research aims to improve health outcomes for patients. However, the setting of research priorities is usually performed by clinicians, academics, and funders, with little involvement of patients or caregivers and using processes that lack transparency. A national workshop was convened in Australia to generate and prioritize research questions in chronic kidney disease (CKD) among diverse stakeholder groups. Patients with CKD (n = 23), nephrologists/surgeons (n = 16), nurses (n = 8), caregivers (n = 7), and allied health professionals and researchers (n = 4) generated and voted on intervention questions across 4 treatment categories: CKD stages 1 to 5 (non–dialysis dependent), peritoneal dialysis, hemodialysis, and kidney transplantation. The 5 highest ranking questions (in descending order) were as follows: How effective are lifestyle programs for preventing deteriorating kidney function in early CKD? What strategies will improve family consent for deceased donor kidney donation, taking different cultural groups into account? What interventions can improve long-term post-transplant outcomes? What are effective interventions for post hemodialysis fatigue? How can we improve and individualize drug therapy to control post-transplant side effects? Priority questions were focused on prevention, lifestyle, quality of life, and long-term impact. These prioritized research questions can inform funding agencies, patient/consumer organizations, policy makers, and researchers in developing a CKD research agenda that is relevant to key stakeholders.

Living kidney donation offers superior outcomes over deceased organ donation, but incurs psychosocial and ethical challenges for recipients because of the risks imposed on their donor. We aimed to describe the beliefs, attitudes, and expectations of patients with chronic kidney disease toward receiving a living kidney donor transplant.We conducted a systematic review of qualitative studies of patients' attitudes toward living kidney donation using a comprehensive literature search of electronic databases to February 2013. The findings were analyzed using thematic synthesis.Thirty-nine studies (n ≥ 1791 participants) were included. We identified six themes: prioritizing own health (better graft survival, accepting risk, and desperate aversion to dialysis), guilt and responsibility (jeopardizing donor health, anticipating donor regret, and causing donor inconvenience), ambivalence and uncertainty (doubting transplant urgency, insufficient information, confronted by unfamiliarity, and prognostic uncertainty), seeking decisional validation (a familial obligation, alleviating family burden, reciprocal benefits for donors, respecting donor autonomy, external reassurance, and religious approval), needing social support (avoiding family conflict, unrelenting indebtedness, and emotional isolation), and cautious donor recruitment (self-advocacy, lacking self-confidence, avoiding donor coercion, emotional vulnerability, respecting cultural, and religious taboos).Enhanced education and psychosocial support may help clarify, validate, and address patients' concerns regarding donor outcomes, guilt, relationship tensions, and donor recruitment. This may encourage informed decision-making, increase access to living kidney donation, and improve psychosocial adjustment for transplant recipients.

Background Most people who receive a kidney transplant die from either cardiovascular disease or cancer before their transplant fails. The most common reason for someone with a kidney transplant to lose the function of their transplanted kidney necessitating return to dialysis is chronic kidney transplant scarring. Immunosuppressant drugs have side effects that increase risks of cardiovascular disease, cancer and chronic kidney transplant scarring. Belatacept may provide sufficient immunosuppression while avoiding unwanted side effects of other immunosuppressant drugs. However, high rates of post-transplant lymphoproliferative disease (PTLD) have been reported when belatacept is used in particular kidney transplant recipients at high dosage. Objectives 1) Compare the relative efficacy of belatacept versus any other primary immunosuppression regimen for preventing acute rejection, maintaining kidney transplant function, and preventing death. 2) Compare the incidence of several adverse events: PTLD; other malignancies; chronic transplant kidney scarring (IF/TA); infections; change in blood pressure, lipid and blood sugar control. 3) Assess any variation in effects by study, intervention and recipient characteristics, including: differences in pre-transplant Epstein Barr virus serostatus; belatacept dosage; and donor-category (living, standard criteria deceased, or extended criteria deceased). Search methods We searched the Cochrane Renal Group's Specialised Register to 1 September 2014 through contact with the Trials' Search Co-ordinator using search terms relevant to this review. Selection criteria Randomised controlled trials (RCT) that compared belatacept versus any other immunosuppression regimen in kidney transplant recipients were eligible for inclusion. Data collection and analysis Two authors independently extracted data for study quality and transplant outcomes and synthesized results using random effects meta-analysis, expressed as risk ratios (RR) and mean differences (MD), both with 95% confidence intervals (CI). Subgroup analyses and univariate meta-regression were used to investigate potential heterogeneity. Main results We included five studies that compared belatacept and calcineurin inhibitors (CNI) that reported data from a total of 1535 kidney transplant recipients. Of the five studies, three (478 participants) compared belatacept and cyclosporin and two (43 recipients) compared belatacept and tacrolimus. Co-interventions included basiliximab (4 studies, 1434 recipients); anti-thymocyte globulin (1 study, 89 recipients); alemtuzumab (1 study, 12 recipients); mycophenolate mofetil (MMF, 5 studies, 1509 recipients); sirolimus (1 study, 26 recipients) and prednisone (5 studies, 1535 recipients). Up to three years following transplant, belatacept and CNI-treated recipients were at similar risk of dying (4 studies, 1516 recipients: RR 0.75, 95% CI 0.39 to 1.44), losing their kidney transplant and returning to dialysis (4 studies, 1516 recipients: RR 0.91, 95% CI 0.61 to 1.38), and having an episode of acute rejection (4 studies, 1516 recipients: RR 1.56, 95% CI 0.85 to 2.86). Belatacept-treated kidney transplant recipients were 28% less likely to have chronic kidney scarring (3 studies, 1360 recipients: RR 0.72, 95% CI 0.55 to 0.94) and also had better graft function (measured glomerular filtration rate (GFR) (3 studies 1083 recipients): 10.89 mL/min/1.73 m², 95% CI 4.01 to 17.77; estimated GFR (4 studies, 1083 recipients): MD 9.96 mL/min/1.73 m², 95% CI 3.28 to 16.64) than CNI-treated recipients. Blood pressure was lower (systolic (2 studies, 658 recipients): MD -7.51 mm Hg, 95% CI -10.57 to -4.46; diastolic (2 studies, 658 recipients): MD -3.07 mm Hg, 95% CI -4.83 to -1.31, lipid profile was better (non-HDL (3 studies 1101 recipients): MD -12.25 mg/dL, 95% CI -17.93 to -6.57; triglycerides (3 studies 1101 recipients): MD -24.09 mg/dL, 95% CI -44.55 to -3.64), and incidence of new-onset diabetes after transplant was reduced by 39% (4 studies (1049 recipients): RR 0.61, 95% CI 0.40 to 0.93) among belatacept-treated versus CNI-treated recipients. Risk of PTLD was similar in belatacept and CNI-treated recipients (4 studies, 1516 recipients: RR 2.79, 95% CI 0.61 to 12.66) and was no different among recipients who received different belatacept dosages (high versus low dosage: ratio of risk ratios (RRR) 1.06, 95% CI 0.11 to 9.80, test of difference = 0.96) or among those who were Epstein Barr virus seronegative compared with those who were seropositive before their kidney transplant (seronegative versus seropositive; RRR 1.49, 95% CI 0.15 to 14.76, test for difference = 0.73). The belatacept dose used (high versus low), type of donor kidney the recipient received (extended versus standard criteria) and whether the kidney transplant recipient received tacrolimus or cyclosporin made no difference to kidney transplant survival, incidence of acute rejection or estimated GFR. Selective outcome reporting meant that data for some key subgroup comparisons were sparse and that estimates of the effect of treatment in these groups of recipients remain imprecise. Authors' conclusions There is no evidence of any difference in the effectiveness of belatacept and CNI in preventing acute rejection, graft loss and death, but treatment with belatacept is associated with less chronic kidney scarring and better kidney transplant function. Treatment with belatacept is also associated with better blood pressure and lipid profile and a lower incidence of diabetes versus treatment with a CNI. Important side effects (particularly PTLD) remain poorly reported and so the relative benefits and harms of using belatacept remain unclear. Whether short-term advantages of treatment with belatacept are maintained over the medium- to long-term or translate into better cardiovascular outcomes or longer kidney transplant survival with function remains unclear. Longer-term, fully reported and published studies comparing belatacept versus tacrolimus are needed to help clinicians decide which patients might benefit most from using belatacept.

Background and objectives The unmet demand for kidney transplantation has generated intense controversy about introducing incentives for living kidney donors to increase donation rates. Such debates may affect public perception and acceptance of living kidney donation. This study aims to describe the range and depth of public opinion on financial reimbursement, compensation, and incentives for living kidney donors. Design, setting, participants, & measurements Twelve focus groups were conducted with 113 participants recruited from the general public in three Australian states in February 2013. Thematic analysis was used to analyze the transcripts. Results Five themes were identified: creating ethical impasses (commodification of the body, quandary of kidney valuation, pushing moral boundaries), corrupting motivations (exposing the vulnerable, inevitable abuse, supplanting altruism), determining justifiable risk (compromising kidney quality, undue harm, accepting a confined risk, trusting protective mechanisms, right to autonomy), driving access (urgency of organ shortage, minimizing disadvantage, guaranteeing cost-efficiency, providing impetus, counteracting black markets), and honoring donor deservingness (fairness and reason, reassurance and rewards, merited recompense). Reimbursement and justifiable recompense are considered by the Australian public as a legitimate way of supporting donors and reducing disadvantage. Financial payment beyond reimbursement is regarded as morally reprehensible, with the potential for exploitative commercialism. Some contend that regulated compensation could be a defensible strategy to increased donation rates provided that mechanisms are in place to protect donors. Conclusions The perceived threat to community values of human dignity, goodwill, and fairness suggests that there could be strong public resistance to any form of financial inducements for living kidney donors. Policy priorities addressing the removal of disincentives may be more acceptable to the public.

Background Kidneys from expanded criteria deceased donors may elicit a strong inflammatory response, predisposing recipients to an increased risk of cancer after transplantation. We aimed to determine the association between donor types and cancer risk after kidney transplantation. Methods Using the Australian and New Zealand Dialysis and Transplant Registry, we assessed the association between different donor types (living donor, standard, and expanded criteria deceased donors) and the risk of cancer after kidney transplantation using adjusted Cox proportional hazard and competing risk models. Results Over a median follow-up period of 4.4 years in 7,040 patients (34,684 patient-years), 468 patients (6.6%) developed cancer. The overall risks for cancer were 1,080, 1,444, and 2,018 per 100,000 patient-years for recipients of living donor, standard, and expanded criteria deceased donor kidneys, respectively. Compared to recipients of living-donor kidneys, recipients of expanded criteria deceased donor kidneys were at an increased risk of cancer (adjusted hazard ratio [HR], 1.52; 95% confidence interval [95% CI], 1.15-2.02; P = 0.004), particularly for genitourinary cancer (adjusted HR, 1.79; 95% CI, 1.03-3.10; P = 0.038) and post-transplant lymphoproliferative disease (adjusted HR, 2.72; 95% CI, 1.38-5.37; P = 0.004). Conclusion Recipients of expanded criteria deceased donor kidneys are at substantially increased risk of cancer, especially cancers with a viral etiology. Allocation of expanded criteria deceased donor kidneys to potential recipients should balance the harms, such as the excess risk of cancer against the survival gains and quality-of-life benefits associated with transplantation.

The imperfections of early technologies for assessment of human leukocyte antigen (HLA) antibody specificity have been resolved by solid phase micro bead assays, but this has revealed new uncertainties. The relationship between presence of antibody specific for a donor HLA molecule to graft damage and outcomes has had to be re-evaluated. Studies of protocol biopsies have identified a correlation between donor specific antibody and electron microscopy (EM) changes at three months, which do not predict chronic antibody mediated rejection, but that are predicted by EM changes seen on 12-month protocol biopsies. These intriguing results point to the plasticity of the renal endothelium in the earlier post-transplant months, as well as to the reality that the immune system interaction with the endothelium changes with time.

Background With the rising prevalence of end-stage kidney disease worldwide, the proportion of the general community who might subsequently be called upon to consider living related kidney donation is also increasing. Knowledge about the attitudes and beliefs among the general public about living kidney donation is limited. We aimed to describe public perspectives on living kidney donation. Methods Participants were recruited from three states in Australia to participate in 12 focus groups (n=113). Transcripts were analyzed thematically. Results We identified six themes: expected benefits (saving and improving life, societal gain, donor satisfaction, reassurance and control), consciousness of donor risks (compromised health, lifestyle limitations, financial consequences, relationship tensions, devastation), social precariousness (fear of the unknown, exploitative connotation, recipient deservingness, protecting conscience, potential regret), upholding fairness (equal access to transplantation, reciprocity, prevent prejudice, donor safety net), decisional autonomy (body ownership, right to know, valid relationships), and assumed duty of care (facilitate informed decision-making, safeguard against coercion, ensure psychological safety, justifiable risk, objectivity, warranted disclosure). Conclusion The expected benefits for recipients bolster public support for living kidney donor transplantation; however, ethical dilemmas and concerns for the donor instilled ambivalence about living donation. Protecting equity and autonomy, and an implicit trust in health professionals to protect donors and recipients mitigated some of these uncertainties. Developing interventions, practices, and policies that address community skepticism and values may promote awareness and trust in living kidney donation.

Kidney transplant obstruction (KTO) following renal transplantation remains an important reversible cause of allograft dysfunction, requiring prompt diagnosis to prevent long-term graft damage. Although ultrasound can accurately diagnose renal transplant hydronephrosis, it cannot be used to assess its functional significance. We prospectively assessed the utility of technetium-99m mercaptoacetyltriglycine (Tc99m MAG3) diuretic renography for the diagnosis of allograft KTO, using standard visual and quantitative parameters, as well as calculated renal output efficiency (OE), which has been postulated to improve diagnostic yield. From a cohort of 45 renal transplant patients, two subgroups were formed. The first group of transplant recipients (n = 21) with stable function and no obstruction was used to derive normal values for Tc99m MAG3 scans. A second group of transplant recipients with acute renal dysfunction in whom KTO was clinically suspected was used to test the diagnostic utility of these derived values (n = 43 scans). KTO was diagnosed independently of the MAG3 scans by a fall in the serum creatinine in response to renal pelvis urinary drainage. OE in 12 renal allografts with KTO was significantly reduced compared with 31 Tc99m MAG3 scans without KTO (59.6 +/- 18.9 vs. 81.6 +/- 5.4%, p 5 min and a TTB of > 7 min both yielded a sensitvity of 92% and a specificity of 81%. In conclusion, MAG3 renography is a clinically useful investigation for the diagnosis of KTO.

Transplantation of renal allografts (RA) from older donors has become more common, despite conflicting data on outcome between reports from large series versus individual centres. Factors other than donor age per se may contribute to RA outcome. The outcome of RA procured from 114 older donors over 55 yr of age in NSW, between 1990 and 1997, was analysed. Corresponding donor factors, including demographics, medical history, inotrope use, major hypotension and findings at procurement, were also analysed. Of the potential RA, 8% were discarded and the remainder transplanted. Factors significantly associated with renal discard were pre-transplantation donation biopsy abnormality (p < 0.001) and a history of cardiovascular (CV) disease in the donor (p < 0.02). Donor aortorenal atherosclerosis (AS; p < 0.09) and a donor age of 65 yr or older (p < 0.08) were common in the discard group. The never function rate was 7.6% and was associated with a history of a discarded partner kidney (p < 0.05). The delayed graft function rate was 33% and was associated with a history of donor CV disease. At a median follow up of 5 yr, the death censored allograft failure rate was 24%. Allograft failure was associated with a history of donor hypertension (p < 0.05). Donor AS (p < 0.7) tended to have been more common in the allograft failure group. A number of cadaveric organ donor factors documented at procurement may be associated with inferior outcome of RA. These include biopsy abnormality, history of donor CV disease and history of donor hypertension. A donor age of 65 yr or older or significant visible aortorenal AS may also be factors. This retrospective review of kidneys procured from 114 older cadaveric organ donors identifies factors apart from donor age, which may have a negative impact on both allograft utilisation and outcome. Theses factors include renal biopsy abnormality, history of donor CV disease, discard of a partner kidney and donor hypertension. Visible AS in the donor aorta documented at renal procurement may also be a factor.

Background. Chronic renal allograft failure remains a major challenge to overcome. Factors such as donor quality, delayed graft function (DGF), acute rejection, and immunosuppression are known to affect long-term outcome, but their relationship to histological damage to graft outcome is unclear. Methods. Protocol kidney biopsies (n=112) obtained at 3 months after transplantation yielded 102 with adequate tissue. Histology was scored by the Banff schema, and compared with implantation biopsies (n=91), repeat 12-month histology (n=39), decline in serum creatinine and serial isotopic glomerular filtration rate, onset of chronic allograft nephropathy (CAN), and actuarial graft survival censored for death with a functioning graft. Results. At a median follow-up of 9.3 years, 20 patients had graft failure and 26 died with a functioning graft. Banff chronic nephropathy was present in 24% of 3-month biopsies, and was predicted by microvascular disease in the donor, cold ischemia, DGF, and acute vascular rejection (P

Introduction. Cataract is a major cause of visual disturbance after transplantation. Although corticosteroid therapy has been linked with posterior subcapsular cataract, its natural history in the cyclosporine era is not well understood. Methods. Baseline and regular postoperative slitlamp biomicroscopy and ophthalmic examinations (n5432) were performed in 108 eyes of simultaneous kidney/pancreas (SPK) recipients (n554) for up to 10 years after transplantation. Triple therapy immunosuppression of cyclosporine, azathioprine, and prednisolone was used. Results. Cataract was present in 40% of eyes at simultaneous kidney/pancreas associated with duration of diabetes, lower insulin dose, and the use of pretransplant hemodialysis (P

Introduction. Cardiovascular and cerebrovascular disease are major causes of morbidity and mortality after kidney transplantation. The aim of this longitudinal study was to examine the natural history of carotid plaque and to determine risk factors for the progression of vascular disease in uremic, type 1 diabetic patients who received a combined kidney and pancreas transplant. Methods. Carotid artery (n=765) and lower limb vascular duplex scanning (n=656) were prospectively undertaken in 82 recipients before transplantation, at 6 months, and then at annual intervals for up to 10 years. Plaque in the internal carotid artery (ICA), external carotid artery, and common carotid artery was classified by type, location, extent, and degree of functional obstruction, and evaluated using multivariate analysis. Results. Carotid plaque was present in 22.5% of patients at initial scanning, but increased to 56.6% by 7-10 years after transplantation, especially in the ICA and common carotid artery. Both the severity and extent of plaque increased, and plaque became more complex and heterogeneous with time after transplantation (P

Low-dose dopamine (LDD) is commonly used after kidney transplantation as a renoprotective agent, although the benefits of dopamine (DA) in this setting are controversial. LDD increases renal blood flow, decreases resistive index (RI) and causes diuresis in normal kidneys. We hypothesised that the vasculature of a denervated renal transplant may not respond to DA in the same way as healthy native kidneys. In a prospective, controlled study, renal blood flow velocity and vascular resistance were measured by Doppler ultrasound in recent kidney transplants (n = 20) over a range of DA doses (0-5 microg/kg/min). Main renal artery velocity was lower in kidneys with acute renal dysfunction than in those with normal function (0.60 +/- 0.31 vs. 0.81 +/- 0.24, respectively, p < 0.05). There was no demonstrable haemodynamic effect of LDD on either RI or main renal artery velocity as measured by Doppler ultrasound. Interestingly, the only significant correlation with mean RI was trough cyclosporin A level (r = 0.57, p < 0.001). Technical or timing factors cannot be used to explain the absence of DA effect, with equivalent doses capable of producing vasodilatation and reduced RI in studies of normal kidneys. In summary, these findings contrast the DA response of healthy native kidneys and may explain studies showing no clinical benefit of LDD in the early post-transplant period. These data suggest an insensitivity of recently implanted kidneys to the vasodilatory effects of LDD, that other factors such as cyclosporin A vasoconstriction may also be important, and question the rationale for routine LDD after kidney transplantation.

Background. The quality of a damaged kidney, the complexity of the surgery, and the events in the first weeks after transplantation, such as delayed graft function (DGF) and acute rejection, may influence its histological appearance and long-term survival. The aim of this study was to evaluate the importance of these factors in predicting renal allograft histology at 3 months. Methods. Prospective, protocol kidney biopsy specimens (n=112), obtained 3 months after transplantation, were scored for chronic damage by the Banff schema and evaluated by multivariate analysis against donor factors, implantation histology, prior recipient sensitization, ischemia, perioperative factors, and subsequent clinical events, such as DGF and acute rejection. Results. Adequate samples were obtained in 102 of 112 biopsies and classified as chronic Banff grade 0 (n=22), grade I (n=56), grade II (n=23), or grade III (n=1). Acute Banff scores were minimal. DGF occurred in 49% and was the strongest predictor of tubulointerstitial damage at 3 months. DGF correlated with acute tubular necrosis on the implantation biopsy specimen and with the number of acute rejection episodes; DGF also correlated with the Banff grades of chronic glomerulitis, chronic interstitial fibrosis, and tubular atrophy scores (P

Renal transplant patients lose their grafts most frequently from chronic allograft nephropathy and their lives from cardiac disease, malignancy, and infection. These are thus the challenges for renal transplant programs for this decade, just as acute rejection was the challenge of the last two decades. Most immunosuppressive protocols aim to minimize acute allograft rejection through heavy induction strategies and powerful but toxic maintenance therapies, counterbalanced by powerful and expensive infection prophylaxis. However, while the short-term results have improved steadily from the 1980s, and despite all the current efforts, the long-term success rates of renal transplants have not improved. Future aims include controlling both rejection and the long-term consequences of toxicity and infection risk. The biological facts that have determined our approach to the use of immunosuppressants have required us to try to balance the conflicting need for control of the allograft response and the inevitable toxicities of our drugs. The early period after transplantation requires maximum immunosuppressive efficacy with minimal ischemia reperfusion and good surgical-related wound healing. The latter period after transplantation requires less immunosuppressive efficacy and avoidance of chronic nephrotoxicity, cardiovascular, and malignancy risk factors. This usually leads to an induction strategy using a biological agent; a calcineurin inhibitor; an antiproliferative agent; and variable use of corticosteroids. In the long term, there are a variety of strategies for dose reduction or elimination of calcineurin inhibitors, incorporation of mammalian target of rapamycin inhibitors, and variable approaches to the risks of continued low-dose corticosteroids. The multiplicity of alternative strategies available testifies to the absence of evidence for a single dominant protocol and the urgent need to determine the relevant early indicators for measuring long-term success.

Background. Systemic viral disease after renal transplantation, especially after treatment with OKT3 or antithymocyte globulin, has usually been attributed to cytomegalovirus (CMV) infection. Identification of human herpesvirus 6 (HHV6) has raised the possibility that infection or reactivation of this virus may also occur in the same setting. Methods. We thus examined the incidence of CMV and HHV6 infection in a prospective blinded consecutive series of 30 renal and renal/pancreas transplant patients, 22 of whom received OKT3, antithymocyte globulin, or both. Results. Clinical diagnosis of a viral syndrome was made in 15 patients. Three patients with only HHV6 DNA in urine or serum had fever and abnormal liver function but not neutropenia. All five CMV-seronegative patients who received positive kidneys developed moderate to severe disease with fever and neutropenia but also had HHV6 DNA in urine or serum. Seven CMV-seropositive patients developed disease, mostly after OKT3/antithymocyte globulin, but six shed both CMV and HHV6 in urine or serum. The simultaneous detection of both HHV6 and CMV DNA in either urine or serum was the strongest predictor of disease (and also the severity of disease), with an odds ratio of 99.0 (95% confidence intervals 5.4-1814, P

Positive B cell crossmatch accompanied by high levels of pre-transplant human leukocyte antigen donor-specific antibodies are associated with adverse graft outcomes in kidney transplant recipients. Targeting plasma cells, the main antibody producing cells, with the proteasome inhibitor bortezomib may be a promising desensitization strategy. We report using a combination of bortezomib and plasmapheresis to desensitize a highly sensitized kidney transplant recipient for an ABO-incompatible living donor kidney transplant. The flow cytometric B cell crossmatch was positive on presentation. After treatment, the anti-A titres fell from 1:64 to 1:4, and a negative B flow cytometric crossmatch was achieved prior to transplantation. The combined approach of bortezomib to abrogate antibody production at the plasma cell level, followed by plasmapheresis and low-dose intravenous immunoglobulin to remove in-circulation alloantibodies, has proven to be effective in our case. Bortezomib may play a role in highly sensitized renal transplants.

A major barrier to meeting the needs for organ transplantation is family refusal to give consent. This study aimed to describe the perspectives of donor families on deceased donation. We conducted a systematic review and thematic synthesis of qualitative studies. Electronic databases were searched to September 2012. From 34 studies involving 1035 participants, we identified seven themes: comprehension of sudden death (accepting finality of life, ambiguity of brain death); finding meaning in donation (altruism, letting the donor live on, fulfilling a moral obligation, easing grief); fear and suspicion (financial motivations, unwanted responsibility for death, medical mistrust); decisional conflict (pressured decision making, family consensus, internal dissonance, religious beliefs); vulnerability (valuing sensitivity and rapport, overwhelmed and disempowered); respecting the donor (honoring the donor's wishes, preserving body integrity) and needing closure (acknowledgment, regret over refusal, unresolved decisional uncertainty, feeling dismissed). Bereaved families report uncertainty about death and the donation process, emotional and cognitive burden and decisional dissonance, but can derive emotional benefit from the "lifesaving" act of donation. Strategies are needed to help families understand death in the context of donation, address anxieties about organ procurement, foster trust in the donation process, resolve insecurities in decision making and gain a sense of closure Refereed/Peer-reviewed

Decision making is complex and difficult in clinical practice. Clinicians are often faced with a large range of possible alternative decision options, each with their own consequences and trade-offs. Health economics methods enable informed decision making on how best to allocate limited resources that could lead to most health gains. Economic evaluation in particular is highly relevant in transplantation medicine. Transplantation is an expensive intervention, but it improves the quality of life and survival of people with chronic diseases. The balance between health care resource use and the optimal health gains is useful not only to decision-makers, but also to consumers, clinicians, and researchers. This article is an overview of the concepts of economic evaluation in the setting of transplantation and highlights the applicability of these concepts in clinical transplantation. Refereed/Peer-reviewed