The authors’ study provides valuable insight into the stress-strain behavior of fine-grained soils silts and clays under monotonic and cyclic undrained loading. The distinct behavioral features of sands versus clays under the aforementioned types of loading are first identified with regard to the shape of the hysteresis loops, the value of excess pore-water pressure ratio, and the magnitude of developed strains. Then, a classification of fine-grained soils into two classes of materials is proposed, namely, “sand-like” materials that are susceptible to liquefaction in the classical meaning of the term , and “clay-like” materials that are susceptible to cyclic softening. In addition, the authors emphasize the critical importance of using the appropriate procedure for evaluating the cyclic strength for each class of material. Following the establishment of the above framework, the authors review a database of test results compiled from the literature and found that the plasticity index, PI, of fines is the single most important parameter for distinguishing between the two types of behavior. They propose the use of a limit value of PI 7 as follows: 1. for PI 7, the material is susceptible to liquefaction i.e., exhibits “sand-like” behavior and its liquefaction resistance should be evaluated using the available procedures for sands; 2. for PI 7, the soil behaves as a ‘clay-like’ material and its behavior should be analyzed using the procedures available for evaluating the cyclic strength of cohesive soils. A transition zone of plasticity index from 3 to 8 is proposed by the authors, who also suggest discontinuing the use of the Chinese criteria of liquefaction susceptibility. Finally, the authors discuss the applicability of the liquefaction criterion proposed in the paper to soils containing less than 50% fines coarse-grained materials . They argue that as long as the amount of fines is greater than a threshold value, FCthr which is the limit above which the fine grains constitute the loading-carrying matrix of soil , their criterion could be extended to fines content FC 50%. The discussers have recently presented results of cyclic triaxial tests on saturated mixtures of sand with different amounts of nonplastic silt Xenaki and Athanasopoulos 2003 . The tests were conducted to investigate the effect of fines content on the liquefaction resistance of sand-silt mixtures. In view of the authors’ study and other recently published data, the discussers would like to present some related data not included in their previous publication and compare them to the findings reported in the paper.