201. Understanding the Dissemination of Influential Parenting Research: A Rapid Review with Article-Level Metrics
- Author
-
Pool, Andrew C., Doolittle, Danielle, Laberee, Nora, Traurig, Shannon, Ginsburg, Kenneth R., Bier, Melinda C., and Funk, Christopher D.
- Abstract
This article presents a case study on parental discipline to describe a novel methodology for conducting rapid reviews using article-level metrics. A team of 3 researchers searched for studies that met predetermined thresholds of influence based on article-level metrics. These metrics included number of citations within the scientific literature and Altmetric scores, which measures a study's level of dissemination on blogs, news sites, and social media. Articles were reviewed for inclusion using traditional systematic review methods, with 52 articles meeting the criteria for influence, quality, and relevance. The studies captured in this review received significant attention from research consumers and suggest that fair discipline, enforced consistently, with explanation and discussion, is associated with favorable outcomes among adolescents. Similarities and differences in popular and scientific narratives were identified, such as the greater popularity of research on provocative topics (e.g., corporal punishment) among the general public. This rapid review methodology produced similar findings to systematic reviews and may provide an improved way for character education researchers and policymakers to understand translation and dissemination of parenting and adolescent health research, allowing them to address gaps in public knowledge more quickly and efficiently.
- Published
- 2022