201. Testing Formal Accounts of Variation: A Sociolinguistic Analysis of Word Order in Negative Word + más Constructions
- Author
-
Sara L. Zahler and Manuel Díaz-Campos
- Subjects
060201 languages & linguistics ,Linguistics and Language ,05 social sciences ,Phrase structure rules ,Verb ,06 humanities and the arts ,Syntax ,050105 experimental psychology ,Linguistics ,Education ,Word lists by frequency ,Variation (linguistics) ,0602 languages and literature ,0501 psychology and cognitive sciences ,Priming (psychology) ,Sociolinguistics ,Word order ,Mathematics - Abstract
This study examines word order variation in negative word + mas constructions in Caracas Spanish, with mas pre-posed or post-posed in relation to the negative word. We empirically analyze the effect of formal syntactic and semantic constraints, the contribution of priming and frequency, as well as several social factors on variable positioning of mas in NW + mas constructions in Spanish. Data for this study comes from the Estudio sociolinguistico de Caracas (Bentivoglio and Sedano 1993). This corpus contains half-hour interviews, conducted between 1987 and 1988 with 160 speakers of Caracas Spanish. Regarding the role of syntactic and semantic formal constraints in the variation of NW + mas constructions, the findings reveal that only polarity and the position of the NW + mas construction relative to the verb significantly constrained variation between pre-posed and post-posed NW + mas constructions. Garcia Cornejo (2008) and Gutierrez-Rexach and Gonzalez-Rivera (2012, 2014) argued that pre-posed mas only occurs with purely negative uses of these constructions. While our results are consistent with this observation, we also found that this pattern is not categorical, since pre-posed mas is used in 34.3% of affirmative sentences. In order to address variation not explained by formal analyses, we explore the role of frequency to account for the variable position of mas + NW. Frequency appears to be a factor in this variation: the most frequent NW + mas construction, with nada, showed the highest rate of post-posing and lowest rate of pre-posing. Priming did not have a significant effect, although it trends in the expected direction: in contexts with a pre-posed prime, the rate of pre-posed mas was higher (58.3%). We argue that analogical levelling with other pre-posed mas constructions has led to an increased use of pre-posed NW + mas constructions in Caracas Spanish and that the most frequent construction, nada mas, is resisting this analogical change due to its higher frequency and consequential entrenchment.
- Published
- 2018
- Full Text
- View/download PDF