This paper explores the dynamics of (dis)trust among experts, journalists, and audiences through the case study of an inaccurate exit poll aired on a leading Israeli television channel. It combines empirical data from the Israeli April 2019 elections with a conceptual view of exit polls as both sources of information and national rituals to address public discourse on the polls and its underlying suspicions. A multi-method approach yielded a corpus consisting of focus groups with citizens, in-depth semi-structured interviews with journalists, pollsters and experts, and qualitative textual analysis of news reports. Using inductive-qualitative analysis, we identified three types of public narratives, each casting blame for the erroneous exit poll projection on a different type of actor. The statistical and biased-media narratives tally with declining trust in the news media and assume misbehavior by pollsters and news creators respectively. The deception narrative, on the other hand, suggests that right-wing voters systematically sabotaged the exit poll projections. By extending trust beyond journalistic information, this narrative foregrounds the cultural meaning of election night rituals. Taken together, the narratives found in this study delineate (dis)trust as an interplay of active participants in the creation, reception, and interpretation of news. Our findings thus touch upon key attitudes towards both media and democracy and have implications for further studies on collective rituals and information evaluations in an era of eroding trust., The author(s) disclosed receipt of the following financial support for the research, authorship, and/ or publication of this article: This study is funded by ERC Starting Grant 802990 (PROFECI). Author Biographies Tali Aharoni is a PhD student at the Department of Communication and Journalism at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. Her research interests include journalistic production, news audiences, social media, trust, and the various intersections of media and psychology. Keren Tenenboim-Weinblatt is an Associate Professor at the Department of Communication and Journalism at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. Her research is in the fields of journalism and political communication, with a particular interest in the temporal dimensions of journalism and the role played by the news media in constructing and negotiating collective pasts and futures. She is leading the ERC-funded project "Mediating the Future: The Social Dynamics of Public Projections" (PROFECI). Christian Baden is an Associate Professor in the Department of Communication and Journalism at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem. His research focuses on the collaborative construction of meaning in controversial public debates, combining political communication and journalism research with the study of discourse, framing and sense-making. Maximilian Overbeck is a post-doctoral researcher at the Hebrew University of Jerusalem at the Department of Communication and Journalism. He does research at the intersection of International Relations, Communication Studies, and Sociology, analyzing complex theoretical concepts through the combination of qualitative and quantitative-computational research methods. In his research, he focuses on the political role of religious beliefs and identities within Western democracies and public spheres.