1. Perceived Barriers to the De-implementation of Routine Preoperative History & Physicals Preceding Low-Risk Ambulatory Procedures: A Qualitative Study of Surgeon Perspectives
- Author
-
Porag Das, Jacquelyn Miller, Alexandra I. Mansour, Alison S. Baskin, Anthony Cuttitta, Anthony E. Rios, Abed Rahman Kawakibi, Lesly A. Dossett, and Hannah Lahti
- Subjects
Risk ,Surgeons ,medicine.medical_specialty ,business.industry ,Surgical care ,General surgery ,De implementation ,Medicare ,United States ,Health care waste ,Ambulatory ,Humans ,Medicine ,Surgery ,Risks and benefits ,business ,Physical Examination ,Medicaid ,Qualitative Research ,Aged ,Qualitative research - Abstract
Background For patients undergoing surgery at an Ambulatory Surgical Center, recent changes to Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services policy allow for the omission of a 30-day preoperative History and Physical (H&P). Preoperative H&Ps for low-risk surgery may contribute to health care waste and lead to unnecessary preoperative testing and treatment cascades. Methods In this qualitative study, we conducted 30 semi-structured interviews with surgeons who frequently perform low-risk surgeries. We aimed to evaluate surgeon perspectives on the continued use of the 30-day preoperative H&P and specifically the potential risks and benefits associated with the elimination of a preoperative H&P requirement from institutional practice. We used an interpretive description approach to generate a thematic description. Results Most participants felt that the 30-day preoperative H&P was low value and frequently described it as “unnecessary,” “redundant,” or “just checking a box.” Many viewed the 30-day requirement as arbitrary and felt that new H&P findings were rare and unlikely to influence surgical care. The participants who favored the preoperative H&P felt it was a safeguard to ensure “nothing was missed” and were less likely to be burdened by the requirement than participants who felt it was low value. Conclusions Surgeons performing low-risk procedures question the utility and value of conducting a preoperative H&P within 30 days of surgery. De-implementation of the 30-day preoperative H&P for low-risk patients may increase convenience for patients and providers. Furthermore, it may improve value in surgery by increasing access to services for patients with greater need for preoperative assessment.
- Published
- 2022