In avascular wound repair, calcium signaling events are the predominant mechanism cells use to transduce information about stressors in the environment into an effective and coordinated migratory response. Live cell imaging and computational analysis of corneal epithelial wound healing revealed that signal initiation and propagation at the wound edge are highly ordered, with groups of cells engaging in cyclical patterns of initiation and propagation. The cells in these groups exhibit a diverse range of signaling behavior, and dominant "conductor cells" drive activity in groups of lower-signaling neighbors. Ex vivo model systems reveal that conductor cells are present in wing cell layers of the corneal epithelium and that signaling propagates both within and between wing and basal layers. There are significant aberrations in conductor phenotype and interlayer propagation in type II diabetic murine models, indicating that signal hierarchy breakdown is an early indicator of disease. In vitro models reveal that signaling profile diversity and conductor cell phenotype is eliminated with P2X7 inhibition and is altered in Pannexin-1 or P2Y2 but not Connexin-43 inhibition. Conductor cells express significantly less P2X7 than their lower-signaling neighbors and exhibit significantly less migratory behavior after injury. Together, our results show that the postinjury calcium signaling cascade exhibits significantly more ordered and hierarchical behavior than previously thought, that proteins previously shown to be essential for regulating motility are also essential for determining signaling phenotype, and that loss of signal hierarchy integrity is an early indicator of disease state. NEW & NOTEWORTHY Calcium signaling in corneal epithelial cells after injury is highly ordered, with groups of cells engaged in cyclical patterns of event initiation and propagation driven by high-signaling cells. Signaling behavior is determined by P2X7, Pannexin-1, and P2Y2 and influences migratory behavior. Signal hierarchy is observed in healthy ex vivo models after injury and becomes aberrant in diabetes. This represents a paradigm shift, as signaling was thought to be random and determined by factors in the environment.