Search

Background/aims: The aim of this study was to evaluate changes occurring in esophageal motility through a systematic manometric study performed before, during and after Heller-Dor operation (8) and to correlate the possible post-operative symptoms to the manometric and pH-recording patterns detected, in order to provide useful elements that may optimize surgical therapy for esophageal achalasia., Materials and Methods: Between January 1981 and January 1991, 27 patients affected by esophageal achalasia underwent Heller's operation with Dor's anti-reflux procedure. Assessment involved clinical, radiological and manometric investigations., Results: Intra-operative manometry was performed on 11 patients, in whom LES pressure reached values lower than 5 mmHg. Post-operative control, performed 2 years after operation on 25 patients, showed the complete absence of dysphagia in 22 (88%) and occasional dysphagia in 3 (12%). Post-operative manometry in all the patients showed a decreased LES resting pressure (from 32.6 to 7.2 mmHg, p < 0.001), LES residual pressure (from 16.4 to 5.0 mmHg, p < 0.001) and esophageal tone (from 4.8 to -3.5 mmHg, p < 0.001). Patients free of dysphagia presented LES basal and residual pressures lower than the other patients (6.2 and 4.6 vs 15.1 and 7.7 mmHg respectively, p < 0.01 and p < 0.05). 24-hour-esophageal pH-metry showed pathologic reflux in 3 patients with reflux symptoms and in 1 without symptoms. All had LES basal and residual pressures equivalent to non refluxing patients (5.7 and 5.0 vs 7.5 and respectively 4.9 mmHg, p = n.s. and p = n.s.). On the contrary, a difference was found in abdominal LES length between the two groups (0.5 vs 1.6 cm, p < 0.01). Patients with intra-operative manometry presented a lower incidence of residual dysphagia than patients without it (0% vs 21.5%), but a higher incidence of reflux (18.2% vs 7.3%)., Conclusion: Heller-Dor operation induces a definitive disappearance of dysphagia when it is complete in depth and length. Prevention of gastro-esophageal reflux requires the preservation of a sufficiently long portion of esophagus in the abdomen.

From 1962 to 1992 sixtythree patients with esophageal achalasia underwent primary surgical treatment. The intervention performed was a cardiomiotomy according to Heller in 20 patients (Group A), a cardiomiotomy according to Heller with anti-reflux procedure according to Lortat-Jacob in 12 patients (Group B), a cardiomiotomy according to Heller with fundoplicatio according to Dor in 31 patients (Group C). Preoperative study was performed by radiological evaluation in patients of Group A, while patients of Group B and Group C were submitted also to endoscopy and esophageal manometry. Postoperative evaluation in Group A was performed by clinical and endoscopical controls, while in Groups B and C by clinical and radiological studies 6 months after the intervention and by clinical and endoscopical studies every two years. During the early two years after operation a functional study (esophageal manometry and esophagogastric pH-monitoring) was performed. The follow-up was complete for 13 patients of Group A, 10 patients of Group B and 28 patients of Group C. Good results (complete absence or slight dysphagia) have been obtained in 70% of Group A, in 90% of Group B and 90% of Group C. Esophageal manometry found a decrease of both resting pressure and length in every patient in Groups B and C. Gastro-esophageal reflux symptoms were found in 15% of Group A, 20% of Group B and 11% of Group C. A various degree of esophagitis was found by endoscopy in 40% of Group A, 50% of Group B and 18% of Group C. Esophago-gastric pH-monitoring, performed in Group C patients, showed pathologic refluxes in 22% of the subjects. The clinical and functional study demonstrates that Heller's cardiomiotomy, in the way it is performed nowadays (complete miotomy over 7 cm of the esophagus and 3-4 cm of the stomach), allows the complete disappearance of dysphagia. On the other side the anti-reflux procedures till now performed (including the 180 degrees fundoplicatio according to Dor) are not effective enough to avoid post-operative gastro-esophageal reflux.