1. Best Practices: A Cross-Site Evaluation
- Author
-
DeJong, Judith A. and Hall, Philip S.
- Abstract
For well over a century, there have been boarding schools for American Indian children. The unique configuration that makes up each boarding school's environment attempts to meet the needs of as many students as possible, and tries to maximize positive outcomes. Recognizing that there is room for improvement, the Office of Indian Education Programs (OIEP) provided several years of funding to a group of schools in order to enhance their services to children. The selected boarding schools were provided Therapeutic Residential Model (TRM) funding to carry out their proposals. To determine each site's accomplishments as well as the efficacy of this approach, the OIEP concurrently implemented a cross-site evaluation. The evaluation was designed to: (1) provide a record and evaluation of the characteristics of each site's environment prior to funding; (2) document the course of planning and implementation of changes during TRM funding; (3) collect data on incoming students and outcome data agreed upon by all sites; (4) provide ongoing analysis of the data to the sites so that administrators could make program changes; and (5) use process and outcome data from these diverse sites to draw cross-site conclusions. In this article, the authors discuss the results of a cross-site evaluation which is patterned on chaos theory. Data were collected in the course of complex changes occurring in systems. Also, staff and student surveys provided the basis for data comparison among boarding schools. Furthermore, this article is divided into four sections including: (1) the identification of the factors that were common to sites that achieved high retention, and it describes the prevailing situation at those sites that were not successful at retaining students; (2) the examination of the process and outcome indicators that presumably impacted the retention rate at each TRM site; (3) the examination of each boarding school's ability to establish a data feedback loop to guide dynamic system change; and (4) is entitled Elephants in the Living Room, and deals with common issues across sites. The survey data indicated that students coming into the boarding school or peripheral dormitory sites had similar risk factors. (Contains 1 table and 24 figures.)
- Published
- 2006