Search

Monoclonal rat anti-idiotypic antibody (Ab2) BR3E4 mimicking the colorectal carcinoma (CRC)-associated epitope CO17-1A induced antigen-specific humoral and cellular immune responses in mice and rabbits. Ab2 BR3E4 was administered in a phase I trial to CRC patients either as intact IgG or as F(ab′) 2 coupled to keyhole limpet hemocyanin (KLH). There was a trend for the F(ab′) 2 -KLH-immunized patients to show higher immune response rates (18/21 and 5/15 patients with anti-anti-idiotypic antibodies and T cells, respectively) than the IgG-immunized patients (15/23 and 3/15 patients positive). Clinical responses were rare in these patients with liver metastases.

The colorectal carcinoma (CRC)-associated CO17-1A/GA733 antigen (Ag) has been the target of a phase II/III randomized trial of passive immunotherapy with monoclonal antibody CO17-1A (Ab1), and phase I active immunotherapy trials with polyclonal anti-idiotypic antibodies (Ab2) mimicking the CO17-1A or GA733 epitope of the Ag. However, monoclonal rat Ab2 BR3E4 directed against Ab1 CO17-1A was superior to polyclonal Ab2 in inducing antigen-specific humoral and cellular immune responses in mice and rabbits. Various forms of Ab2 BR3E4, i.e., BR3E4-F(ab')2 precipitated with aluminum-hydroxide (alum), BR3E4-F(ab')2 coupled to KLH and precipitated or non-precipitated with alum, and BR3E4-IgG in alum or incomplete Freund's adjuvant were compared for their capacity to induce in rabbits anti-anti-idiotypic antibodies (Ab3) that specifically bind to the CO17-1A Ag. BR3E4-F(ab')2 coupled to KLH and precipitated with alum was shown to induce the highest Ab3 titers, followed by Ab2 BR3E4-IgG in alum. Therefore Ab2 BR3E4 as intact IgG (IgG group) or as F(ab')2 coupled to KLH (KLH group), was administered in a phase I trial to 45 patients with CRC, stage Dukes'D (UICC stage IV), with the goal to modulate patients' immune responses to their tumors. Fifteen of 23 patients in the IgG group developed Ab3 binding specifically to Ab2, and in four of these patients the Ab3 also specifically bound to Ag-positive CRC cells. Lymphoproliferative responses to Ab2 and/or GA733-2E Ag stimulation were observed in three of these patients. Eighteen of the 22 KLH group patients tested developed Ab3 and the Ab3 bound specifically to CRC cells in eight patients. Five of the 15 KLH group patients tested developed lymphoproliferative responses to Ab2 and/or GA733-2E Ag. Thus, there was a trend for the KLH group demonstrating higher immune response rates than the IgG group. Clinical responses were rare in these patients with liver metastases.

Mutated epidermal growth factor receptor (EGF-RvIII, ΔEGF-R, and de2–7 EGF-R) is the result of an 801-bp deletion within the extracellular domain of wild-type EGF-R and is expressed by breast carcinomas, but not by normal breast tissues. EGF-RvIII is expressed both on the surface and in the cytoplasm of tumor cells. Thus, EGF-RvIII is a potential tumor-specific target for both Abs and T cells. However, it is not known whether breast cancer patients can raise immune responses to EGF-RvIII expressed by their tumors. The demonstration of EGF-RvIII-specific immune responses in patients would suggest that immunization of patients with EGF-RvIII vaccines is feasible, because these vaccines may boost a pre-existing immune response. We have evaluated humoral and cellular immune responses to EGF-RvIII in 16 breast cancer patients and three healthy donors. Seven of 16 patients developed EGF-RvIII-specific Abs that bound to isolated EGF-RvIII protein or the protein expressed by EGF-RvIII-transfected mouse fibroblasts. The Abs that bound to EGF-RvIII did not bind to wild-type EGF-R, and anti-EGF-RvIII Abs were not found in the sera of healthy donors. Three patients had EGF-RvIII peptide-specific lymphoproliferative responses, and two of these patients also had humoral immune responses. Humoral and cellular immune responses correlated with EGF-RvIII expression by patients’ tumors in most cases. These studies demonstrate that breast cancer patients specifically recognize EGF-RvIII with an overall immune response rate of 50%, suggesting that patients may benefit from vaccination against EGF-RvIII, boosting pre-existing immune responses.

Attempts to vaccinate against tumors can be hindered by the induction of immunological tolerance to the target Ag as a result of Ag expression on normal tissues. In this study, we find that transgenic mice expressing the melanoma-associated Ag CD63/ME491/neuroglandular/NKI/C-3 on their normal tissues do, in fact, exhibit immunological tolerance to the Ag, recapitulating the conditions in cancer patients. In these mice, growth of murine melanoma cells expressing the Ag after gene transfer was inhibited by immunization with Ag-expressing recombinant vaccinia virus combined with IL-2, but not by immunization with the protein alone, anti-idiotypic Abs, or irradiated tumor cells. The effect of the recombinant virus was demonstrated both for nonestablished and established tumors. Infiltration with both CD4+ and CD8+ T lymphocytes was significantly more extensive in tumors from experimental mice than in tumors from control mice. MHC class I-positive, but not class I-negative, tumors were inhibited by the vaccine, suggesting that MHC class I-restricted T lymphocytes play a role in the antitumor effects. Abs did not appear to be involved in the vaccine effects. CD63 was immunogenic in 2 of 13 melanoma patients, pointing to the potential of this Ag, combined with IL-2, as a vaccine for melanoma patients.

Cancer patients often develop CTLs that lyse autologous tumor cells in culture. However, tumors can progress in vivo despite the presence of CTLs. Various mechanisms have been reported to down-modulate CTL functions. In this study, the role of CD4+/CD25+ regulatory T cells in CTL induction and proliferation of established CTLs was investigated in a patient with CRC. CD4+ cytotoxic and regulatory T-cell lines were derived from the peripheral blood mononuclear cells of the same patient in mixed-lymphocyte tumor culture. The cytotoxic T-cell line and a clonal derivative specifically lysed the autologous tumor cells but not the B lymphocytes. Only HLA-A1-matched allogeneic CRC cells were lysed by the CTL clone. The clone produced IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha. The regulatory CD4+/CD25+ T-cell line was tumor cell-dependent in its growth but did not lyse autologous tumor cells. This T-cell line suppressed pokeweed mitogen responses of allogeneic lymphocytes, proliferative activity of the established, autologous CTLs, and induction of CTLs in autologous, freshly isolated peripheral blood mononuclear cells. The immunosuppressive effect of the CD4+/CD25+ regulatory T cells was mediated by transforming growth factor-beta and did not require cell-to-cell contact. Thus, although CRC patients can develop specific CTLs against their tumors, the development of regulatory T cells may allow the escape of tumor cells from immune surveillance by the CTLs in vivo.