1. Emergency Medicine Milestones Final Ratings Are Often Subpar.
- Author
-
Gorgas DL, Joldersma KB, Ankel FK, Carter WA, Barton MA, and Reisdorff EJ
- Subjects
- Humans, Cross-Sectional Studies, Retrospective Studies, Education, Medical, Graduate standards, Emergency Medicine education, Clinical Competence standards, Internship and Residency standards, Educational Measurement
- Abstract
Background: The emergency medicine (EM) milestones are objective behaviors that are categorized into thematic domains called "subcompetencies" (eg, emergency stabilization). The scale for rating milestones is predicated on the assumption that a rating (level) of 1.0 corresponds to an incoming EM-1 resident and a rating of 4.0 is the "target rating" (albeit not an expectation) for a graduating resident. Our aim in this study was to determine the frequency with which graduating residents received the target milestone ratings., Methods: This retrospective, cross-sectional study was a secondary analysis of a dataset used in a prior study but was not reported previously. We analyzed milestone subcompetency ratings from April 25-June 24, 2022 for categorical EM residents in their final year of training. Ratings were dichotomized as meeting the expected level at the time of program completion (ratings of ≥3.5) and not meeting the expected level at the time of program completion (ratings of ≤3.0). We calculated the number of residents who did not achieve target ratings for each of the subcompetencies., Results: In Spring 2022, of the 2,637 residents in the spring of their last year of training, 1,613 (61.2%) achieved a rating of ≥3.5 on every subcompetency and 1,024 (38.8%) failed to achieve that rating on at least one subcompetency. There were 250 residents (9.5%) who failed to achieve half of their expected subcompetency ratings and 105 (4.0%) who failed to achieve the expected rating (ie, rating was ≤3.0) on every subcompetency., Conclusion: When using an EM milestone rating threshold of 3.5, only 61.2% of physicians achieved the target ratings for program graduation; 4.0% of physicians failed to achieve target ratings for any milestone subcompetency; and 9.5% of physicians failed to achieve the target ratings for graduating residents in half of the subcompetencies., Competing Interests: Conflicts of Interest: By the WestJEM article submission agreement, all authors are required to disclose all affiliations, funding sources and financial or management relationships that could be perceived as potential sources of bias. Drs. Gorgas, Ankel, and Carter are members of the American Board of Emergency Medicine (ABEM), Board of Directors. Drs. Joldersma, Barton, and Reisdorff are employees of ABEM. ABEM receives no revenue from Emergency Medicine Milestones reporting. There are no other conflicts of interest or sources of funding to declare.
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF