1. Basic Bronchoscopy Competence Achieved by a Nationwide One-day Simulation-based Training.
- Author
-
Gerretsen ECF, Groenier M, Annema JT, van der Heijden EHFM, van Mook WNKA, Aldenkamp AF, Citgez E, Crombag LMMJ, Hagmolen Of Ten Have W, Hiddinga BI, Hoppe BPC, Ninaber MK, van de Pol MA, Robberts B, Rutten M, Sprooten R, Wagenaar M, and Smeenk FWJM
- Subjects
- Humans, Netherlands, Male, Female, Adult, Bronchoscopy education, Bronchoscopy methods, Clinical Competence, Simulation Training methods, Pulmonary Medicine education, Internship and Residency methods
- Abstract
Background: In 2020, a mandatory, nationwide 1-day bronchoscopy simulation-based training (SBT) course was implemented for novice pulmonology residents in the Netherlands. This pretest-posttest study was the first to evaluate the effectiveness of such a nationwide course in improving residents' simulated basic bronchoscopy skills., Methods: After passing a theoretical test, residents followed a 1-day SBT course, available in 7 centers, where they practiced their bronchoscopy skills step-by-step on a virtual reality simulator under pulmonologist supervision. Residents practiced scope handling efficiency (task 1) and navigational skills combined with lung anatomy knowledge (task 2). Task 1 outcome measures were navigational skill simulator metrics: percentage of time at mid-lumen, percentage of time with scope-wall contact, procedure time (PT), number of wall contacts and number of wall contacts per minute of PT. Task 2 outcome measures were PT, observational assessment scores of a validated tool with a 5-point scale (1 representing the worst and 5 the best competence) and blinded dexterity assessments., Results: The study included 100 residents. All outcome measures of task 1 improved significantly (P<0.001), except for the number of wall contacts per minute of PT (4.3 [IQR 3.0 to 6.2] pre vs. 3.5 [IQR 2.6 to 5.3] post, P=0.07). For task 2, PT was reduced by 54% (10.3±2.7 minutes pre vs. 4.7±0.9 minutes post, P<0.001) with an improvement in overall-competence scores (2.0 [IQR 1.0 to 2.0] pre vs. 4.0 [IQR 4.0 to 5.0] post, P<0.001) and all dexterity parameters (P<0.001)., Conclusion: Nationwide implementation of a SBT course led to rapid improvement of residents' basic bronchoscopy skills while halving PT., Competing Interests: Disclosure: The PhD project of E.G. was funded by the Catharina Hospital research fund & the board of directors of the Maastricht University Medical Center+. M.G. is Board member of the Dutch Society of Simulation in Healthcare. Educational EBUS courses that are taught by J.T.A. at the Amsterdam University Medical Centers have been supported by Simbionix (Surgical Science) by the inkind support of providing a simulator, no financial support was provided. Erik van der Heijden has received unrestricted research grants paid to his institution from Astra Zeneca Oncology, Pentax Medical, Philips Image Guided Therapies, Johnson & Johnson, Intuitive, IHI-EU public fund (for the “IMAGIO” project), and KWF–National Cancer Fund (for a KWF implementation research project). He has also received consulting fees paid to his institution from Johnson & Johnson, Intuitive, and NLC. In addition, E.v.H. has received speaker’s fees paid to his institution from Janssen-Cilag and Siemens, and sponsorship for symposiums he organized from Pentax, Ethicon, Astra Zeneca, Intuitive, and Philips Image Guided Therapy. Travel fees have been paid to E.v.H.’s institution by Siemens. He holds issued, pending, and planned patents in the field of advanced and navigation bronchoscopy. He has received single-use instruments for a scientific research protocol from Philips Medical and equipment loans for scientific research from Intuitive Surgical and Pentax Medical. E.v.H. is also an unpaid member of the Executive Board of EABIP. Fifty percent of B.R.’s traveling and hotel costs to the ERS Congress 2022 were paid by Chiesi. For the other authors, there are no conflict of interest or other disclosures., (Copyright © 2024 The Author(s). Published by Wolters Kluwer Health, Inc.)
- Published
- 2024
- Full Text
- View/download PDF