1. A Southwest Oncology Group study on the use of a human tumor cloning assay for predicting response in patients with ovarian cancer
- Author
-
Von Hoff, Daniel D., Kronmal, Richard, Salmon, Sydney E., Turner, Judy, Green, J.B., Bonorris, Jim S., Moorhead, Edgar L., Hynes, Henry E., Pugh, Reginald E., Belt, Robert J., and Alberts, David S.
- Subjects
Chemotherapy -- Evaluation ,Ovarian cancer ,Tissue culture ,Health - Abstract
Despite gains in chemotherapy for cancer, some fraction of patients will relapse or fail to respond to treatment. It would, of course, be useful to predict in advance which chemotherapeutic regimens would be unlikely to work and which would have the greatest chance of success. In the case of advanced ovarian cancer, only from 10 to 40 percent of patients may be expected to achieve a complete response, and the outlook for those who fail to respond or who relapse is grim. One method of potential usefulness in the prediction of response to chemotherapy is in vitro testing. This method involves culturing cells from a patient's tumor and then adding chemotherapeutic agents to these cells in the laboratory. It is far from certain, however, that chemotherapeutic agents which work in laboratory dishes will work in the patient as well. In order to evaluate the usefulness of tissue culture in the prediction of chemotherapeutic response, tumor cell cultures from 211 patients with epithelial ovarian cancer were cultured. In 168 patients, the cancers have proved refractory to prior chemotherapy, while in 43 patients no prior chemotherapy had been attempted. Of the 168 patients with prior chemotherapy, sensitivity of the cells to agents in tissue culture could be demonstrated in 23. These patients were treated with the same agents. For 101 patients, either cell cultures could not be successfully established or no sensitivity in culture could be demonstrated. These patients were treated with a chemotherapeutic agent of the physician's choice. The remaining patients were not treated due to either deterioration or death. Among the patients treated with the agents demonstrated to work in tissue culture, the response rate was 28 percent, in contrast to 11 percent for the remainder. However, this response rate did not translate into an improvement in survival, which was a median of 6.7 and 7.0 months for the two groups, respectively. For the patients who had never been treated, only seven cultures could be established, but among these the correlation between in vitro sensitivity and response to treatment was perfect. The results show that the technique shows some promise, but that it is at present severely limited by the difficulty in establishing successful cultures for the majority of patients. (Consumer Summary produced by Reliance Medical Information, Inc.)
- Published
- 1991