Charles F. Delwiche, Karin Ljung, Eva Sundberg, Mattias Thelander, Markus Geisler, Endymion D. Cooper, Elena Feraru, Jiří Friml, Katarina Landberg, Tom Viaene, Eva Medvecká, Eric R. A. Pederson, and Mansour Karimi
Plant Biology, Department of Biology, University of Fribourg,1700 Fribourg, SwitzerlandSummaryThe emergence and radiation of multicellular land plantswas driven by crucial innovations to their body plans [1].The directional transport of the phytohormone auxin repre-sents a key, plant-specific mechanism for polarization andpatterning in complex seed plants [2–5]. Here, we showthat already in the early diverging land plant lineage, asexemplifiedbythemossPhyscomitrellapatens,auxintrans-port by PIN transporters is operational and diversified intoER-localized and plasma membrane-localized PIN proteins.Gain-of-function and loss-of-function analyses revealedthat PIN-dependent intercellular auxin transport in Phys-comitrella mediates crucial developmental transitions intip-growing filaments and waves of polarization and differ-entiation in leaf-like structures. Plasma membrane PIN pro-teinslocalizeinapolarmannertothetipsofmossfilaments,revealing an unexpected relation between polarizationmechanisms in moss tip-growing cells and multicellulartissues of seed plants. Our results trace the origins of polar-ization and auxin-mediated patterning mechanisms andhighlight the crucial role of polarized auxin transport duringthe evolution of multicellular land plants.Results and DiscussionDuring plant diversification, a spectacular evolutionary transi-tion from anatomically simple green algae to developmentallycomplex multicellular land plants took place, presumably inorder to adapt to new and challenging environments [1].The phytohormone auxin is the most versatile plant-specificsignal that governs many crucial aspects of the seed plantbody organization [2]. A unique property of auxin amongplant signaling molecules is its directional (polar) transportthrough tissues, which is essential for most auxin-regulateddevelopmental processes, such as the establishment ofthe polarity axis during embryogenesis, de novo formationof organs, and vascular tissue formation [3–5]. Auxin trans-port depends largely on specific auxin transporters, namelythe PIN-FORMED (PIN) proteins [6]. Their typically asymmet-rical (polar) localization at the plasma membrane (PM)determines the direction of auxin flow between cells [7],which in turn provides directional and positional informationfor the development of multicellular tissues by linkinginformation at the level of individual cells to a coordinateddevelopmental output [8]. On account of its universalroles in polarization and patterning processes in seedplants, it is believed that this PIN-mediated auxin transportplayed a key role in important developmental innovationsduring the diversification of land plants [9, 10]. However,in planta data on the evolution of auxin transport andpolarization machineries in early diverging land plants aremissing.In order to reconstruct the role of PIN proteins during landplant evolution, we used the moss model species Physcomi-trella patens, which is a representative of one of the earliestdiverging lineages of land plants [11]. Similar to that of theangiosperm Arabidopsis, the P. patens genome encodes twodifferent types of PIN proteins, characterized by either a shortor a long hydrophylic loop between the transmembrane re-gions (Figure 1A), the latter designated as the canonical PINprotein [12, 13]. We assessed the auxin transport capabilitiesof these different PIN proteins by several means. We per-formed auxin transport assays using radioactively labeledsubstrates in mesophyll protoplasts from transfected Nico-tiana benthamiana leaves [14] and found that P. patens PINswith a long and short loop enhanced the export of indole-3-acetic acid (IAA), but not the chemically related benzoic acid(Figure S1F available online). Using root hair growth as an es-tablished measure of auxin export capacities, we showed thatoverexpression (OE) of long moss PINs in Arabidopsis, similarto OE of a typical PM-localized long PIN from Arabidopsis(AtPIN1), inhibits root hair growth, suggesting action in stimu-latingauxinefflux.Incontrast,OEoftheshortmossPINdidnotaffect root hair growth, similar to OE of the ER-localized, shortAtPIN5 from Arabidopsis [15](Figures 1B and S1G). Finally,P. patens filaments export auxin [16, 17] that can be detectedin the cultivation medium (Figure 1C). Using this in vivo assay,we observed that OE of moss and Arabidopsis PINs stronglyenhancedauxinexportintothemedium.Also,adoublemutantlinein long mossPINs(pinapinb)slightly reduced auxinexportinto the medium (Figures 1C, S1A–S1E, and S1H). Theseresults suggest that already in one of the early divergingland plant lineages, similar to seed plants, the PIN proteinsdiversified into long PINs with auxin export function andshort PINs with presumable roles in auxin homeostasis andmetabolism.