Search

The use of autologous stem/progenitor cells represents a promising approach to the repair of craniofacial bone defects. The calvarium is recognized as a viable source of stem/progenitor cells that can be transplanted in vitro to form bone. However, it is unclear if bone formed in cell culture is similar in quality to that found in native bone. In this study, the quality of bone mineral formed in osteogenic cell cultures were compared against calvarial bone from postnatal mice. Given the spectroscopic resemblance that exists between cell and collagen spectra, the feasibility of extracting information on cell activity and bone matrix quality were also examined. Stem/progenitor cells isolated from fetal mouse calvaria were cultured onto fused-quartz slides under osteogenic differentiation conditions for 28 days. At specific time intervals, slides were removed and analyzed by Raman microscopy and mineral staining techniques. We show that bone formed in culture at Day 28 resembled calvarial bone from 1-day-old postnatal mice with comparable mineralization, mineral crystallinity, and collagen crosslinks ratios. In contrast, bone formed at Day 28 contained a lower degree of ordered collagen fibrils compared with 1-day-old postnatal bone. Taken together, bone formed in osteogenic cell culture exhibited progressive matrix maturation and mineralization but could not fully replicate the high degree of collagen fibril order found in native bone.

Understanding ethical boundaries in student affairs work can be challenging and difficult to navigate for student affairs professionals. The purpose of this article is to examine the complexities of dual relationships and the ethical issues that may arise. As a result, the authors offer tools to (a) identify various perspectives in resolving ethical problems and (b) examine the issues using a theoretical model. The article includes a case study embedded throughout the article, a brief overview of ethics in the profession, and tools for ethical analysis that will assist supervising practitioners, graduate faculty, and graduate students under their supervision.

The use of stem/progenitor cells represents a promising approach to treat craniofacial bone defects, but successful treatments will rely on the availability of cells that can be expanded in vitroand which will differentiate appropriately in vivo. The calvaria may represent a source of autologous cells for such purposes. We demonstrate expression of stem cell antigen-1 (Sca-1) in mouse calvaria. We isolated Sca-1+ and Sca-1– cells at high purity and tested the ability of these cells to differentiate into adipose and bone. We show that the Sca-1+ cell fraction has adipogenic differentiation potential and that the cell Sca-1– fraction has osteogenic differentiation potential. The Sca-1+ cell fraction partially retains its adipogenic differentiation potential and the Sca-1– cell fraction partially retains its osteogenic differentiation potential after in vitroexpansion. These data suggest that the calvaria may be used as a source of stem/progenitor cells that can be expanded in vitroand transplanted in vivofor craniofacial tissue regeneration.

The flat bones of the skull (calvaria) develop by balanced cell proliferation and differentiation in the calvarial sutures and the bone tips. As the brain grows and the calvaria expand, cells within the sutures must remain undifferentiated to maintain suture patency, but osteoprogenitors also need to be recruited into the osteogenic fronts. The exact identity of calvarial osteoprogenitors is currently not known. We used immunomagnetic cell sorting to isolate Sca-1+ and Sca-1(-) cells from fetal mouse calvaria and determined their differentiation potential in in vitro differentiation asssays and in vivo subcutaneous transplantations. Cells within the Sca-1+ cell fraction have a higher adipogenic potential, whereas cells within the Sca-1(-) cell fraction have a higher osteogenic and chondrogenic potential. The Sca-1(-) fraction retains its chondrogenic potential after in vitro expansion but not its osteogenic potential. The Sca-1+ fraction does not retain its adipogenic potential after in vitro expansion. Subcutaneous transplantation resulted in islands of bone and cartilage in implants that had been seeded with Sca-1(-) cells. In conclusion, immunomagnetic cell sorting with Sca-1 antibodies can be used to separate a Sca-1+ cell fraction with adipogenic potential from a Sca-1(-) cell fraction with osteogenic and chondrogenic potential. Isolation of pure populations of calvarial adipoprogenitors, osteoprogenitors, and chondroprogenitors will be beneficial for cellular studies of calvarial development, adipogenesis, osteogenesis, and chondrogenesis. Calvaria-derived osteogenic cell populations may be useful in craniofacial tissue regeneration and repair.

To understand early mineralization events, we studied living murine calvarial tissue by Raman spectroscopy using fibroblast growth factor 2 (FGF2)-soaked porous beads. We detected increased levels of a transient phase resembling octacalcium phosphate in sutures undergoing premature suture closure. Introduction: Several calcium phosphates have been postulated as the earliest inorganic precursors to bone mineral. They are unstable and have not been previously detected in tissue specimens. Whether the same intermediates are formed in sutures undergoing premature closure is also unknown. Methods: Six coronal suture tissue specimens from fetal day 18.5 B6CBA F1/J wild-type mice were studied. Three sutures specimens were treated with FGF2-soaked heparin acrylic beads to induce accelerated mineralization and premature suture closure. Three control specimens were treated with empty heparin acrylic beads. All sutures were maintained as organ cultures to permit repeated spectral analyses at 12–24 h intervals over a 72-h period. Results: During the first 24 h, the spectra contained bands of octacalcium phosphate (OCP) or an OCP-like mineral. The main phosphorus–oxygen stretch was at 955 cm−1, instead of the 957–959 cm−1 seen in bone mineral, and there was an additional band at 1010–1014 cm−1, as expected for OCP. A broad band was found at 945 cm−1, characteristic of a highly disordered or amorphous calcium phosphate. An increased amount of mineral was observed in FGF2-treated sutures, but no qualitative differences in Raman spectra were observed between experimental and control specimens. Conclusions: Inorganic mineral deposition proceeds through transient intermediates, including an OCP-like phase. Although this transient phase has been observed in purely inorganic model systems, this study is the first to report OCP or an OCP-like intermediate in living tissue. Raman microspectroscopy allows observation of this transient mineral and may allow observation of other precursors as well.

Craniosynostosis, premature fusion of the skull bones at the sutures, is the second most common human birth defect in the skull. Raman microspectroscopy was used to examine the composition, relative amounts, and locations of the mineral and matrix produced in mouse skulls undergoing force-induced craniosynostosis. Raman imaging revealed decreased relative mineral content in skulls undergoing craniosynostosis compared with unloaded specimens. Introduction: Raman microspectroscopy, a nondestructive vibrational spectroscopic technique, was used to examine the composition, relative amounts, and locations of the mineral and matrix produced in mouse skulls undergoing force-induced craniosynostosis. Craniosynostosis, premature fusion of the skull bones at the sutures, is the second most common birth defect in the face and skull. The calvaria, or flat bones that comprise the top of the skull, are most often affected, and craniosynostosis is a feature of over 100 human syndromes and conditions. Materials and Methods: Raman images of the suture, the tips immediately adjacent to the suture (osteogenic fronts), and mature parietal bones of loaded and unloaded calvaria were acquired. Images were acquired at 2.6 × 2.6 μm spatial resolution and ranged in a field of view from 180 × 210 μm to 180 × 325 μm. Results and Conclusions: This study found that osteogenic fronts subjected to uniaxial compression had decreased relative mineral content compared with unloaded osteogenic fronts, presumably because of new and incomplete mineral deposition. Increased matrix production in osteogenic fronts undergoing craniosynostosis was observed. Understanding how force affects the composition, relative amounts, and location of the mineral and matrix provides insight into musculoskeletal disease in general and craniosynostosis in particular. This is the first report in which Raman microspectroscopy was used to study musculoskeletal disease. These data show how Raman microspectroscopy can be used to study subtle changes that occur in disease.

Band-target entropy minimization (BTEM) has been applied to extraction of component spectra from hyperspectral Raman images. In this method singular value decomposition is used to calculate the eigenvectors of the spectroscopic image data set. Bands in non-noise eigenvectors that would normally be used for recovery of spectra are examined for localized spectral features. For a targeted (identified) band, information entropy minimization or a closely related algorithm is used to recover the spectrum containing this feature from the non-noise eigenvectors, plus the next 5-30 eigenvectors, in which noise predominates. Tests for which eigenvectors to include are described. The method is demonstrated on one synthesized Raman image data set and two bone tissue specimens. By inclusion of small amounts of signal that would be unused in other methods, BTEM enables the extraction of a larger number of component spectra than are otherwise obtainable. An improvement in signal/noise ratio of the recovered spectra is also obtained.

We report the use of Raman microscopy to image mouse calvaria stained with hematoxylin, eosin and toluidine blue. Raman imaging of stained specimens allows for direct correlation of histological and spectral information. A line-focus 785 nm laser imaging system with specialized near-infrared (NIR) microscope objectives and CCD detector were used to collect approximately 100 x 450 micro m Raman images. Principal components analysis, a multivariate analysis technique, was used to determine whether the histological stains cause spectral interference (band shifts or intensity changes) or result in thermal damage to the examined tissue. Image analysis revealed factors for tissue components and the embedding medium, glycol methacrylate, only. Thus, Raman imaging proved to be compatible with histological stains such as hematoxylin, eosin and toluidine blue.

Distraction osteogenesis is an established treatment strategy in the reconstruction of the craniofacial skeleton. The underlying mechanisms that drive bone formation during this process are largely unknown, but a regulatory role for mechanical force is believed to be critical. The integrin-mediated signal transduction cascade is a primary pathway by which signal transduction of mechanical stimuli (i.e., mechanotransduction) occurs. Focal adhesion kinase (FAK) is a significant regulator in this pathway. The authors hypothesize that mechanical forces created during distraction osteogenesis are responsible for the osteogenic response that takes place, and that these changes arise through integrin-dependent mechanotransduction. Using a rat model of distraction osteogenesis, the authors examined the expression of FAK in critical size defects (n = 15), subcritical size defects (n = 15), and mandibles undergoing distraction osteogenesis (n = 15). Their findings demonstrated FAK immunolocalization in mandibles undergoing distraction osteogenesis, but not in the critical size defects or in subcritical size defects, despite varying degrees of bone formation in the latter two groups. Furthermore, bone sialoprotein mRNA in situ hybridization patterns were found to mirror FAK immunolocalization patterns in mandibles undergoing distraction osteogenesis, demonstrating an association of FAK expression with the osteogenic process specific to distraction osteogenesis. These findings suggest that the bone formation in distraction osteogenesis is regulated by mechanical force by means of integrin-dependent mechanotransduction pathways.

The coordinate growth of the brain and skull is achieved through a series of interactions between the developing brain, the growing bones of the skull, and the fibrous joints, or sutures, that unite the bones. These interactions couple the expansion of the brain to the growth of the bony plates at the sutures. Craniosynostosis, the premature fusion of the bones of the skull, is a common birth defect (1 in 3000 live births) that disrupts coordinate growth and often results in profoundly abnormal skull shape. Individuals affected with Boston-type craniosynostosis, an autosomal dominant disorder, bear a mutated copy of MSX2, a homeobox gene thought to function in tissue interactions. Here we show that expression of the mouse counterpart of this mutant gene in the developing skulls of transgenic mice causes craniosynostosis and ectopic cranial bone. These mice provide a transgenic model of craniosynostosis as well as a point of entry into the molecular mechanisms that coordinate the growth of the brain and skull.

The normal src protein (pp60c-src) is localized principally in the nerve growth cone of developing neurons and declines to low levels with synaptic maturation. To determine whether pp60c-src is reexpressed in regenerating axons, its expression was studied by immunoblotting and immunocytochemical analyses in adult chicken sciatic nerve following nerve crush injury. pp60c-src expression was found to increase during nerve repair with a temporal and spatial pattern consistent with a localization in regenerating axons. At the crush site, pp60c-src increased to maximal levels 7 days postinjury, increasing fivefold relative to 0 day nerve. In the nerve segment distal to the injury, the maximal increase in pp60c-src was sevenfold and occurred between 11 and 21 days postinjury. Immunoperoxidase staining revealed pp60c-src in regenerating axons and certain nonneuronal cells at the site of nerve repair. pp60c-src was induced in both motor and sensory neurons, as shown by increased pp60c-src immunoreactivity in their cell bodies located in the spinal cord and dorsal root ganglion. Phosphotyrosine-modified proteins that were potential targets of pp60c-src increased following nerve crush, and were localized to outgrowing neurites as well as to nonneuronal cells. These results suggest that pp60c-src is a common component of cellular mechanisms regulating growth cone migration in both regenerating and developing axons.

A panoramic radiograph obtained during orthodontic treatment revealed an intracoronal radiolucency within an unerupted permanent second molar. This unusual entity was successfully treated by surgical and endodontic intervention, followed by restorative and orthodontic treatment. These treatments enabled the tooth to maintain pulpal vitality, erupt, complete root formation, and function. This report will review the proposed etiologies for this condition, discuss the need for surgical intervention, and present the details of the case.

(1990). Ethical Education in a College Environment. NASPA Journal: Vol. 27, No. 3, pp. 192-198.

Raman spectral imaging provides the means to study spatially localized response to controlled external perturbations to tissue specimens with light microscopy resolution. We discuss use of heparin-acrylic microbeads soaked with the protein fibroblast growth factor-2 (FGF2). Microbeads containing FGF2 are placed in murine calvarial tissue and stimulate abnormally rapid mineralization. The tissue response simulated the effects of craniosynostosis, a birth defect occurring in 1 in 2400 live births. We describe Raman imaging measurements of the spatial distribution of apatitic mineral and matrix (predominantly type I collagen) from normal murine calvarial tissue and murine calvarial tissue modeling craniosynostosis. We also discuss spectroscopic evaluation of the state of the mineral induced by the FGF2 beads.

Craniosynostosis, the premature fusion of the skull bones at the sutures, is the second most common human birth defect that affects the face and skull. The top most flat bones that comprise the skull, or calvaria, are most often affected. We previously showed that treatment of mouse calvaria with FGF2-soaked beads leads to craniosynostosis. In this study we treated mouse calvaria with FGF2-soaked beads and then used Raman imaging to demonstrate the spatial distribution of apatitic mineral and matrix in the sutures. There was no difference between FGF2 treated and control calvaria in the type of mineral produced (a lightly carbonated apatite), however we did observe increased mineral deposition in FGF2 treated calvaria. Raman imaging has great promise to detect the earliest mineral and matrix changes that occur in craniosynostosis.

Fracture repair has previously been shown to be sensitive to mechanical environment, yet the specific relationship between strain character, magnitude and frequency, as well as other mechanical parameters, and tissue formation is not well understood. This study aimed to correlate strain distribution within the healing fracture gap with patterns of tissue formation using a rat model of a healing osteotomy subject to mechanical stimulation in bending. Finite element models based on realistic tissue distributions were used to estimate both the magnitude and spatial distribution of strains within the fracture gap. The spatial distribution of regenerating tissue was determined by microcomputed tomography and histology, and was confirmed using reverse transcription-polymerase chain reaction (RT-PCR). Results suggest that tensile strains suppress chondrogenesis during the mechanical stimulation period. After stimulation ends, however, tensile strains increased chondrogenesis followed by rapid bone formation. In contrast, in compressive environments, bone is formed primarily via intramembranous ossification. Taken together, these results suggest that intermittent tensile strains during fracture repair stimulate endochondral ossification and promote eventual bone healing compared to intermittent compressive strains and unstimulated fractures. Further understanding of these relationships may allow proposal of optimal therapeutic strategies for improvement of the fracture repair process.

Craniosynostosis, the premature fusion of the skull bones at the sutures, represents a disruption to the coordinated growth and development of the expanding brain and calvarial vault and is the second most common birth defect that affects the craniofacial complex. Mutations in the human homeobox-containing gene, Msx2, have been shown to cause Boston type craniosynostosis, and we have shown that overexpression of Msx2 leads to craniosynostosis in mice. Activating mutations in fibroblast growth factor (FGF) receptors are thought to cause craniosynostosis in Crouzon, Apert, Jackson-Weiss, Beare-Stevenson, and Muenke syndromes. To mimic activated signaling by mutated FGF receptors, we used heparin acrylic beads to deliver FGF ligands to mouse calvaria and demonstrated increased Msx2, Runx2, Bsp, and Osteocalcin gene expression, decreased cell proliferation, and suture obliteration and fusion. FGF2 elicited the greatest increase in Msx2 expression, and FGF1 was most likely to cause suture obliteration and fusion. Of the three sutures studied, the coronal suture exhibited the greatest increase in Msx2 expression and was the most likely to undergo obliteration and fusion. These results are intriguing because the coronal suture is the most commonly affected suture in syndromic craniosynostosis. These results suggest that Msx2 is a downstream target of FGF receptor signaling and that increased FGF signaling leads to osteogenic differentiation by sutural mesenchyme in mouse calvaria. These results are consistent with the hypotheses that increased Msx2 expression and activated signaling by mutated FGF receptors lead to craniosynostosis.

Despite the increasing use of distraction osteogenesis (DO) of the mandible, the molecular mechanisms regulating new bone formation during DO remain poorly understood. The purposes of this study were (1) to establish a unique rodent model of DO capable of outlining parameters for new bone formation at the distraction site and (2) to determine a critical-size defect to differentiate osteogenesis resulting from distraction from conventional fracture healing at the osteotomy site. Adult Sprague-Dawley rats were fitted successfully with this newly developed distraction device. Analyses demonstrated that the device could distract the rat mandible reliably to 5.1 mm with complete union. Acute intersegmental gaps of 2 mm resulted in complete bony union in a manner consistent with fracture healing, whereas 3-mm acute gaps resulted in varying degrees of bony union. Acute intersegmental gaps of 5.1 mm invariably resulted in fibrous nonunion. In summary, the authors have developed a rodent model of DO of the mandible. Their distraction protocols resulted successfully in advancement to 5.1 mm with bony consolidation. Notable fracture healing occurred at immediate intersegmental spaces as large as 3 mm. A gap of 5.1 mm was sufficient to act as a critical-size defect, resulting consistently in fibrous nonunion. These findings validate the effectiveness of this distraction device and establish the critical-size defect of a rat mandible at more than 3 mm. This novel model of DO provides an effective method of examining fundamental mechanisms responsible for new bone formation in the craniofacial skeleton.

Raman microspectroscopy is a nondestructive vibrational spectroscopic technique that permits the study of organic and mineral species at micron resolution, offers the ability to work with hydrated and dehydrated specimens in vivo or in vitro, and requires minimal specimen preparation. We used Raman microspectroscopy to determine the composition of the mineral environments present in mouse calvaria, the flat bones that comprise the top of the skull. We have acquired Raman transects (lines of point spectra) from mouse calvaria during a developmental time course ranging from embryonic day 13.5 (E13.5; 6 days before birth) to 6 months of age. Exploratory factor analysis (FA) reveals the presence of a variety of apatitic mineral environments throughout the tissue series. The earliest mineral is observed in the fetal day 15.5 (F15.5) mice and is identified as a carbonated apatite. The presence of a heterogeneous mineralized tissue in the postnatal specimens suggests that ionic incorporation and crystal perfection in the lattice yary as the mouse develops. This variation is indicative of the presence of both recently deposited mineral and more matured remodeled mineral. Band area ratios reveal that the mineral/matrix ratio initially increases, reaches a plateau, and then increases again. The carbonate/phosphate band area ratio remains constant from F18.5 to postnatal day 3 (PN3) and then increases with age. Insights into the chemical species, the degree of mineralization, and the multiple mineral environments that are present in normal calvarial tissue will enable us to better understand both normal and abnormal mineralization processes.

Bone tissue consists of a carbonated apatite-like mineral supported on a hydrated, collagen-rich protein matrix. Despite extensive studies into the macroscopic characteristics of bone, much about the early stages of bone formation remains unknown. Raman microspectroscopy and imaging are increasingly important tools for the study of mineralized tissue, due to advancements in both spectral acquisition and analysis protocols. With this technique, mapping of both organic and inorganic components of bone, in addition to determining their distributions with high spatial resolution across a specimen, can be realized. We have employed Raman microscopy to investigate the early stages of mineralization in four different mouse calvarial systems: typical and atypical osteoblastic (bone forming) cell cultures and healthy and diseased bone tissue. These systems are commonly utilized as models for mineralization. The mineral deposited by osteoblast cultures grown atypically gives a Raman signal completely different to that observed in osteoblast cultures grown in the conventional manner. Similarly, Raman images of healthy and diseased bone tissue show differences in the relationship of the mineral and matrix environments. In this report, we compare the several differences between these four mineral environments, and discuss the chemistry of mineral maturation observed.

The composition of the bone tissue initially formed during the early mineralization of calvarial bone is poorly understood. Calvarial de novo mineral deposition occurs rapidly; however, whether the mineral is first deposited as an amorphous calcium phosphate or some other calcium phosphate lattice is unclear. Raman microscopy offers the ability to distinguish differences in the mineral lattice through the positions and shifts in the bands of the bone tissue mineral constituents, particularly in the phosphate v1 stretch vibration (950 - 963 cm-1). The ratios of the mineral and organic matrix constituents throughout the sampled region can also elucidate the type of bone tissue deposited. The ability to examine intact specimens at high spatial resolution, without interference from water, is an important feature of Raman microscopy. Using postnatal murine calvaria, we show that the earliest mineral detected is a carbonated hydroxyapatite with other phosphate environments present at lower levels as well. We discuss the mineral composition changes with respect to the age of the mouse over the time period of 2 weeks using a sequence of calvarial sections: postnatal days 3, 7 and 14. We use two different data analysis techniques, factor analysis and center of gravity calculations, to elucidate these discrete changes.© (2001) COPYRIGHT SPIE--The International Society for Optical Engineering. Downloading of the abstract is permitted for personal use only.

In this review, we provide a survey of the experimental approaches used to generate genetically engineered mice. Two specific examples are presented that demonstrate the applicability of these approaches to craniofacial development. In the first, a promoter analysis of the Msx2 gene is presented which illustrates the cis regulatory interactions that define cell-specific gene expression. In the second, a mouse model of the human disease craniosynostosis, Boston type, has been created by misregulation of the Msx2 gene product. Finally, we present a formulary of spontaneously occurring and genetically engineered mice that exhibit defects in developmental processes affecting the craniofacial complex. The purpose of this review is to provide insight into the experimental approaches that are used to create genetically engineered mice and to impress upon the reader that genetically engineered mice are well-suited to address fundamental questions pertaining to the development, maintenance, and regeneration of tissues and organs.

The nonreceptor tyrosine protein kinases pp60c-src, p59fyn, and pp62c-yes are localized in growth cones of developing neurons, but their function is undefined. To determine whether these tyrosine kinases were capable of regulating substrate-dependent axon growth, cultures of cerebellar neurons from wild-type, src-, fyn-, and yes- mice were analyzed for neurite outgrowth on the neural cell adhesion molecule L1 or the extracellular matrix protein laminin. The rate of neurite extension on L1 was reduced in src-, but not in fyn- or yes- neurons. Neurite extension on laminin was unaltered in src-, fyn-, or yes- neurons, indicating that pp60c-src, p59fyn, or pp62c-yes is not likely to participate in integrin-dependent axon growth. These results demonstrate that pp60c-src is a component of the intracellular signaling pathway in L1-mediated axonal growth and suggest that Src-related nonreceptor tyrosine kinases may have distinct, nonredundant functions in the nervous system.

Craniosynostosis is a severe craniofacial disease where one or more sutures, the fibrous tissue that lies between the cranial bones, fuses prematurely. Some craniosynostosis syndromes are known to be caused by mutations in fibroblast growth factor (FGF) receptors. Mutated FGF receptors are thought to cause constitutive signaling. In this study, heparin acrylic beads released fibroblast growth factor 2 (FGF2) to mimic constitutive signaling by mutated receptors, delivering FGF2 in addition to already existing normal tissue amounts. Fetal day 18.5 mouse sutures were treated with FGF2-soaked beads and cultured in serum free media for 48 h. We have shown previously that this treatment leads to fusion and increased Msx2 expression, but here we use near-infrared Raman imaging to simultaneously examine the mineral components and matrix components of cranial tissue while providing light microscopic spatial information. FGF2-treated mouse sutures show increased v1 phosphate and v1 carbonate bandwidths, indicating a slightly chemically modified mineral being rapidly deposited. In addition, FGF2-treated mouse sutures show a marked increase in mineral-to-matrix ratios compared to control mouse sutures, typical of increased mineralization.

Raman microspectroscopy and imaging can be used to probe the chemical properties of newly mineralized bone tissue. In this study, our early mineralization models are neonatal murine cranial suture tissue and prostate cancer cell cultures. The murine cranial tissue was harvested from animals three weeks postnatal. On this time scale, remodeling does not corrupt the temporal record inherent in the spatial distribution of mineral species. When analyzing transects, line images, of the cranial tissue, multivariate data processing is required to generate chemical state plots from the hundreds of Raman spectra acquired during a single transect experiment. In most cranial tissue specimens more than one phosphate mineral environment is observed, allowing inferences on the relation between chemical structure and physiologically important properties. The prostate cancer cell cultures were cultured for up to nine days. Point microspectroscopy reveals the ratios of mineral species present and the amount of protein species in the cell cultures changes dramatically over the course of 9 days. Very low carbonation, typical of early-mineralized tissue, is observed in both of these models.