John R. McLaughlin, Darshana Daftary, Jo Knight, Roger C. Green, Miralem Mrkonjic, H. B. Younghusband, Daniel D. Buchanan, Bharati Bapat, Joanne P. Young, S. Gallinger, Aaron Pollett, James B. Rawson, Elizabeth Dicks, and Patrick S. Parfrey
Wnt genes encode a large family of secreted glycoproteins with widespread roles in development and carcinogenesis. These proteins have classically been divided into canonical or non-canonical family members based on their ability to activate these distinct arms of the Wnt signalling network. While canonical Wnt ligands promote cell growth and proliferation by controlling cytoplasmic degradation and subsequently nuclear accumulation of β-catenin. Non-canonical Wnt ligands govern cell motility and polarity through the Wnt/calcium and/or planar cell polarity pathways, which act through a variety of intracellular mediators including calmodulin-dependent protein kinase II, protein kinase C, and c-Jun N-terminal kinase. Aberrant hyperactivation of the canonical Wnt pathway is a critical tumour-initiating event in the majority of colorectal cancers (CRCs); however, the status of non-canonical Wnt activity in cancer and its roles in carcinogenesis are poorly understood. These functions have mainly been examined through Wnt5a, the quintessential non-canonical Wnt ligand. Wnt5a is ubiquitously expressed in normal tissues (Ying et al, 2008), but is often dysregulated in tumours (Wang et al, 2007, 2010) and has been controversially implicated in both tumour suppression and oncogenesis in addition to being recognised asa marker of both favourable and poor outcome in primary cancer. Studies supporting the former have demonstrated that Wnt5a inhibits invasion and proliferation in thyroid cancer (Kremenevskaja et al, 2005), low expression or loss of expression is prognostically unfavourable in breast cancer (Jonsson et al, 2002; Leris et al, 2005), and hemizygous mice develop lymphomas (Liang et al, 2003). On the other hand, oncogenic roles have been identified in prostate cancer, where Wnt5a promotes cell motility (Wang et al, 2010; Yamamoto et al, 2010), melanoma, where expression associates with tumour invasion (Weeraratna et al, 2002), and hepatocellular carcinoma, where expression is associated with poorly differentiated and invasive cell lines (Yuzugullu et al, 2009). In CRC, Wnt5a expression has been associated with favourable outcome in early stage tumours (Dejmek et al, 2005), while loss of Wnt5a expression is a hallmark of CRC-derived liver metastases (Ki et al, 2007). Collectively, these seemingly conflicting findings underscore the poorly understood functional and prognostic roles of Wnt5a in cancer. Recent studies in leukaemia (Martin et al, 2010) and CRC (Ying et al, 2008; Ahn et al, 2011) have shown that a major mechanism for Wnt5a downregulation is promoter hypermethylation. Aberrant promoter hypermethylation is a hallmark of CRC that has a pivotal role in defining tumour subtypes; somatic methylation of the MLH1 promoter causes the majority of sporadic CRC tumours with microsatellite instability (MSI), and widespread CpG island methylation defines the CpG island methylator phenotype (CIMP). Importantly, these methylation-dependent subtypes stratify disease outcome; MSI tumours are clinically favourable, but respond poorly to 5-fluorouracil-based chemotherapy (Ribic et al, 2003; Carethers et al, 2004), whereas CIMP tumours have complex associations with patient outcome that may depend on MSI and/or BRAF V600E status (Kim et al, 2009; Ogino et al, 2009; Dahlin et al, 2010). Despite the importance of these epigenetic modifications in defining these CRC subtypes, the specific methylation events that contribute to subtype-specific outcome has been poorly characterised. Our previous study suggested that microsatellite stable tumours may exhibit preferential gain of non-canonical Wnt signalling through methylation of Wnt antagonists (Rawson et al, 2011). Given the importance of Wnt5a in mediating non-canonical Wnt activity and its emerging role in carcinogenesis and prognosis, we investigated the promoter methylation status of this gene in a large cohort of MSI-stratified CRCs from two distinct Canadian populations. We examined associations to patient clinicopathological features focusing on tumour subtype and patient survival in hopes that these relationships would provide further insight into subtype-specific epigenetic mediation of non-canonical Wnt signalling and would help define the prognostic role of Wnt5a methylation in CRC.