1. Effectiveness and comparative effectiveness of evidence-based psychotherapies for posttraumatic stress disorder in clinical practice.
- Author
-
Maguen, Shira, Madden, Erin, Holder, Nicholas, Li, Yongmei, Seal, Karen H, Neylan, Thomas C, Lujan, Callan, Patterson, Olga V, DuVall, Scott L, and Shiner, Brian
- Subjects
Humans ,Treatment Outcome ,Retrospective Studies ,Stress Disorders ,Post-Traumatic ,Psychotherapy ,Veterans ,Electronic Health Records ,Comparative Effectiveness ,Effectiveness ,Evidence-based psychotherapy ,Posttraumatic Stress Disorder ,Veteran ,cognitive processing therapy ,prolonged exposure therapy ,Clinical Research ,Behavioral and Social Science ,Anxiety Disorders ,Clinical Trials and Supportive Activities ,Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) ,Mental Health ,Comparative Effectiveness Research ,Health Services ,Brain Disorders ,Mental health ,Good Health and Well Being ,Neurosciences ,Public Health and Health Services ,Psychology ,Psychiatry - Abstract
BackgroundWhile evidence-based psychotherapy (EBP) for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) is a first-line treatment, its real-world effectiveness is unknown. We compared cognitive processing therapy (CPT) and prolonged exposure (PE) each to an individual psychotherapy comparator group, and CPT to PE in a large national healthcare system.MethodsWe utilized effectiveness and comparative effectiveness emulated trials using retrospective cohort data from electronic medical records. Participants were veterans with PTSD initiating mental healthcare (N = 265 566). The primary outcome was PTSD symptoms measured by the PTSD Checklist (PCL) at baseline and 24-week follow-up. Emulated trials were comprised of 'person-trials,' representing 112 discrete 24-week periods of care (10/07-6/17) for each patient. Treatment group comparisons were made with generalized linear models, utilizing propensity score matching and inverse probability weights to account for confounding, selection, and non-adherence bias.ResultsThere were 636 CPT person-trials matched to 636 non-EBP person-trials. Completing ⩾8 CPT sessions was associated with a 6.4-point greater improvement on the PCL (95% CI 3.1-10.0). There were 272 PE person-trials matched to 272 non-EBP person-trials. Completing ⩾8 PE sessions was associated with a 9.7-point greater improvement on the PCL (95% CI 5.4-13.8). There were 232 PE person-trials matched to 232 CPT person-trials. Those completing ⩾8 PE sessions had slightly greater, but not statistically significant, improvement on the PCL (8.3-points; 95% CI 5.9-10.6) than those completing ⩾8 CPT sessions (7.0-points; 95% CI 5.5-8.5).ConclusionsPTSD symptom improvement was similar and modest for both EBPs. Although EBPs are helpful, research to further improve PTSD care is critical.
- Published
- 2023