1. An expanded evaluation of protein function prediction methods shows an improvement in accuracy
- Author
-
Yuxiang Jiang, Tal Ronnen Oron, Wyatt T. Clark, Asma R. Bankapur, Daniel D’Andrea, Rosalba Lepore, Christopher S. Funk, Indika Kahanda, Karin M. Verspoor, Asa Ben-Hur, Da Chen Emily Koo, Duncan Penfold-Brown, Dennis Shasha, Noah Youngs, Richard Bonneau, Alexandra Lin, Sayed M. E. Sahraeian, Pier Luigi Martelli, Giuseppe Profiti, Rita Casadio, Renzhi Cao, Zhaolong Zhong, Jianlin Cheng, Adrian Altenhoff, Nives Skunca, Christophe Dessimoz, Tunca Dogan, Kai Hakala, Suwisa Kaewphan, Farrokh Mehryary, Tapio Salakoski, Filip Ginter, Hai Fang, Ben Smithers, Matt Oates, Julian Gough, Petri Törönen, Patrik Koskinen, Liisa Holm, Ching-Tai Chen, Wen-Lian Hsu, Kevin Bryson, Domenico Cozzetto, Federico Minneci, David T. Jones, Samuel Chapman, Dukka BKC, Ishita K. Khan, Daisuke Kihara, Dan Ofer, Nadav Rappoport, Amos Stern, Elena Cibrian-Uhalte, Paul Denny, Rebecca E. Foulger, Reija Hieta, Duncan Legge, Ruth C. Lovering, Michele Magrane, Anna N. Melidoni, Prudence Mutowo-Meullenet, Klemens Pichler, Aleksandra Shypitsyna, Biao Li, Pooya Zakeri, Sarah ElShal, Léon-Charles Tranchevent, Sayoni Das, Natalie L. Dawson, David Lee, Jonathan G. Lees, Ian Sillitoe, Prajwal Bhat, Tamás Nepusz, Alfonso E. Romero, Rajkumar Sasidharan, Haixuan Yang, Alberto Paccanaro, Jesse Gillis, Adriana E. Sedeño-Cortés, Paul Pavlidis, Shou Feng, Juan M. Cejuela, Tatyana Goldberg, Tobias Hamp, Lothar Richter, Asaf Salamov, Toni Gabaldon, Marina Marcet-Houben, Fran Supek, Qingtian Gong, Wei Ning, Yuanpeng Zhou, Weidong Tian, Marco Falda, Paolo Fontana, Enrico Lavezzo, Stefano Toppo, Carlo Ferrari, Manuel Giollo, Damiano Piovesan, Silvio C.E. Tosatto, Angela del Pozo, José M. Fernández, Paolo Maietta, Alfonso Valencia, Michael L. Tress, Alfredo Benso, Stefano Di Carlo, Gianfranco Politano, Alessandro Savino, Hafeez Ur Rehman, Matteo Re, Marco Mesiti, Giorgio Valentini, Joachim W. Bargsten, Aalt D. J. van Dijk, Branislava Gemovic, Sanja Glisic, Vladmir Perovic, Veljko Veljkovic, Nevena Veljkovic, Danillo C. Almeida-e-Silva, Ricardo Z. N. Vencio, Malvika Sharan, Jörg Vogel, Lakesh Kansakar, Shanshan Zhang, Slobodan Vucetic, Zheng Wang, Michael J. E. Sternberg, Mark N. Wass, Rachael P. Huntley, Maria J. Martin, Claire O’Donovan, Peter N. Robinson, Yves Moreau, Anna Tramontano, Patricia C. Babbitt, Steven E. Brenner, Michal Linial, Christine A. Orengo, Burkhard Rost, Casey S. Greene, Sean D. Mooney, Iddo Friedberg, Predrag Radivojac, Jiang, Yuxiang, Oron, Tal Ronnen, Clark, Wyatt T., Bankapur, Asma R., D’Andrea, Daniel, Lepore, Rosalba, Funk, Christopher S., Kahanda, Indika, Verspoor, Karin M., Ben-Hur, Asa, Koo, Da Chen Emily, Penfold-Brown, Duncan, Shasha, Denni, Youngs, Noah, Bonneau, Richard, Lin, Alexandra, Sahraeian, Sayed M. E., Martelli, Pier Luigi, Profiti, Giuseppe, Casadio, Rita, Cao, Renzhi, Zhong, Zhaolong, Cheng, Jianlin, Altenhoff, Adrian, Skunca, Nive, Dessimoz, Christophe, Dogan, Tunca, Hakala, Kai, Kaewphan, Suwisa, Mehryary, Farrokh, Salakoski, Tapio, Ginter, Filip, Fang, Hai, Smithers, Ben, Oates, Matt, Gough, Julian, Törönen, Petri, Koskinen, Patrik, Holm, Liisa, Chen, Ching-Tai, Hsu, Wen-Lian, Bryson, Kevin, Cozzetto, Domenico, Minneci, Federico, Jones, David T., Chapman, Samuel, Bkc, Dukka, Khan, Ishita K., Kihara, Daisuke, Ofer, Dan, Rappoport, Nadav, Stern, Amo, Cibrian-Uhalte, Elena, Denny, Paul, Foulger, Rebecca E., Hieta, Reija, Legge, Duncan, Lovering, Ruth C., Magrane, Michele, Melidoni, Anna N., Mutowo-Meullenet, Prudence, Pichler, Klemen, Shypitsyna, Aleksandra, Li, Biao, Zakeri, Pooya, Elshal, Sarah, Tranchevent, Léon-Charle, Das, Sayoni, Dawson, Natalie L., Lee, David, Lees, Jonathan G., Sillitoe, Ian, Bhat, Prajwal, Nepusz, Tamá, Romero, Alfonso E., Sasidharan, Rajkumar, Yang, Haixuan, Paccanaro, Alberto, Gillis, Jesse, Sedeño-Cortés, Adriana E., Pavlidis, Paul, Feng, Shou, Cejuela, Juan M., Goldberg, Tatyana, Hamp, Tobia, Richter, Lothar, Salamov, Asaf, Gabaldon, Toni, Marcet-Houben, Marina, Supek, Fran, Gong, Qingtian, Ning, Wei, Zhou, Yuanpeng, Tian, Weidong, Falda, Marco, Fontana, Paolo, Lavezzo, Enrico, Toppo, Stefano, Ferrari, Carlo, Giollo, Manuel, Piovesan, Damiano, Tosatto, Silvio C.E., del Pozo, Angela, Fernández, José M., Maietta, Paolo, Valencia, Alfonso, Tress, Michael L., Benso, Alfredo, Di Carlo, Stefano, Politano, Gianfranco, Savino, Alessandro, Rehman, Hafeez Ur, Re, Matteo, Mesiti, Marco, Valentini, Giorgio, Bargsten, Joachim W., van Dijk, Aalt D. J., Gemovic, Branislava, Glisic, Sanja, Perovic, Vladmir, Veljkovic, Veljko, Veljkovic, Nevena, Almeida-e-Silva, Danillo C., Vencio, Ricardo Z. N., Sharan, Malvika, Vogel, Jörg, Kansakar, Lakesh, Zhang, Shanshan, Vucetic, Slobodan, Wang, Zheng, Sternberg, Michael J. E., Wass, Mark N., Huntley, Rachael P., Martin, Maria J., O’Donovan, Claire, Robinson, Peter N., Moreau, Yve, Tramontano, Anna, Babbitt, Patricia C., Brenner, Steven E., Linial, Michal, Orengo, Christine A., Rost, Burkhard, Greene, Casey S., Mooney, Sean D., Friedberg, Iddo, Radivojac, Predrag, Friedberg, Iddo [0000-0002-1789-8000], Apollo - University of Cambridge Repository, (ukupan broj autora: 147), Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC), National Science Foundation (Estados Unidos), United States of Department of Health & Human Services, National Natural Science Foundation of China, Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council (Canadá), São Paulo Research Foundation, Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad (España), Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (Reino Unido), Katholieke Universiteit Leuven (Bélgica), Newton International Fellowship Scheme of the Royal Society grant, British Heart Foundation, Ministry of Education, Science and Technological Development (Serbia), Office of Biological and Environmental Research (Estados Unidos), Australian Research Council, University of Padua (Italia), Swiss National Science Foundation, Institute of Biotechnology, Computational genomics, and Bioinformatics
- Subjects
0301 basic medicine ,Computer science ,Disease gene prioritization ,Protein function prediction ,Ecology, Evolution, Behavior and Systematics ,Genetics ,Cell Biology ,05 Environmental Sciences ,600 Technik, Medizin, angewandte Wissenschaften::610 Medizin und Gesundheit ,computer.software_genre ,Quantitative Biology - Quantitative Methods ,Wiskundige en Statistische Methoden - Biometris ,Field (computer science) ,Laboratorium voor Plantenveredeling ,Function (engineering) ,Databases, Protein ,1183 Plant biology, microbiology, virology ,Quantitative Methods (q-bio.QM) ,media_common ,Genetics & Heredity ,Settore BIO/11 - BIOLOGIA MOLECOLARE ,Ecology ,SISTA ,1184 Genetics, developmental biology, physiology ,Life Sciences & Biomedicine ,Algorithms ,Bioinformatics ,Evolution ,media_common.quotation_subject ,BIOINFORMÁTICA ,Machine learning ,Bottleneck ,Set (abstract data type) ,BIOS Applied Bioinformatics ,03 medical and health sciences ,Annotation ,Structure-Activity Relationship ,Behavior and Systematics ,Human Phenotype Ontology ,Humans ,ddc:610 ,DISINTEGRIN ,Mathematical and Statistical Methods - Biometris ,BIOINFORMATICS ,08 Information And Computing Sciences ,Science & Technology ,business.industry ,Research ,ADAM ,Proteins ,Computational Biology ,Molecular Sequence Annotation ,06 Biological Sciences ,Data set ,ONTOLOGY ,Plant Breeding ,030104 developmental biology ,Gene Ontology ,Biotechnology & Applied Microbiology ,FOS: Biological sciences ,Artificial intelligence ,business ,computer ,Software - Abstract
BACKGROUND: A major bottleneck in our understanding of the molecular underpinnings of life is the assignment of function to proteins. While molecular experiments provide the most reliable annotation of proteins, their relatively low throughput and restricted purview have led to an increasing role for computational function prediction. However, assessing methods for protein function prediction and tracking progress in the field remain challenging. RESULTS: We conducted the second critical assessment of functional annotation (CAFA), a timed challenge to assess computational methods that automatically assign protein function. We evaluated 126 methods from 56 research groups for their ability to predict biological functions using Gene Ontology and gene-disease associations using Human Phenotype Ontology on a set of 3681 proteins from 18 species. CAFA2 featured expanded analysis compared with CAFA1, with regards to data set size, variety, and assessment metrics. To review progress in the field, the analysis compared the best methods from CAFA1 to those of CAFA2. CONCLUSIONS: The top-performing methods in CAFA2 outperformed those from CAFA1. This increased accuracy can be attributed to a combination of the growing number of experimental annotations and improved methods for function prediction. The assessment also revealed that the definition of top-performing algorithms is ontology specific, that different performance metrics can be used to probe the nature of accurate predictions, and the relative diversity of predictions in the biological process and human phenotype ontologies. While there was methodological improvement between CAFA1 and CAFA2, the interpretation of results and usefulness of individual methods remain context-dependent., We acknowledge the contributions of Maximilian Hecht, Alexander Grün, Julia Krumhoff, My Nguyen Ly, Jonathan Boidol, Rene Schoeffel, Yann Spöri, Jessika Binder, Christoph Hamm and Karolina Worf. This work was partially supported by the following grants: National Science Foundation grants DBI-1458477 (PR), DBI-1458443 (SDM), DBI-1458390 (CSG), DBI-1458359 (IF), IIS-1319551 (DK), DBI-1262189 (DK), and DBI-1149224 (JC); National Institutes of Health grants R01GM093123 (JC), R01GM097528 (DK), R01GM076990 (PP), R01GM071749 (SEB), R01LM009722 (SDM), and UL1TR000423 (SDM); the National Natural Science Foundation of China grants 3147124 (WT) and 91231116 (WT); the National Basic Research Program of China grant 2012CB316505 (WT); NSERC grant RGPIN 371348-11 (PP); FP7 infrastructure project TransPLANT Award 283496 (ADJvD); Microsoft Research/FAPESP grant 2009/53161-6 and FAPESP fellowship 2010/50491-1 (DCAeS); Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council grants BB/L020505/1 (DTJ), BB/F020481/1 (MJES), BB/K004131/1 (AP), BB/F00964X/1 (AP), and BB/L018241/1 (CD); the Spanish Ministry of Economics and Competitiveness grant BIO2012-40205 (MT); KU Leuven CoE PFV/10/016 SymBioSys (YM); the Newton International Fellowship Scheme of the Royal Society grant NF080750 (TN). CSG was supported in part by the Gordon and Betty Moore Foundation’s Data-Driven Discovery Initiative grant GBMF4552. Computational resources were provided by CSC – IT Center for Science Ltd., Espoo, Finland (TS). This work was supported by the Academy of Finland (TS). RCL and ANM were supported by British Heart Foundation grant RG/13/5/30112. PD, RCL, and REF were supported by Parkinson’s UK grant G-1307, the Alexander von Humboldt Foundation through the German Federal Ministry for Education and Research, Ernst Ludwig Ehrlich Studienwerk, and the Ministry of Education, Science and Technological Development of the Republic of Serbia grant 173001. This work was a Technology Development effort for ENIGMA – Ecosystems and Networks Integrated with Genes and Molecular Assemblies (http://enigma.lbl.gov), a Scientific Focus Area Program at Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, which is based upon work supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of Biological & Environmental Research grant DE-AC02-05CH11231. ENIGMA only covers the application of this work to microbial proteins. NSF DBI-0965616 and Australian Research Council grant DP150101550 (KMV). NSF DBI-0965768 (ABH). NIH T15 LM00945102 (training grant for CSF). FP7 FET grant MAESTRA ICT-2013-612944 and FP7 REGPOT grant InnoMol (FS). NIH R01 GM60595 (PCB). University of Padova grants CPDA138081/13 (ST) and GRIC13AAI9 (EL). Swiss National Science Foundation grant 150654 and UK BBSRC grant BB/M015009/1 (COD). PRB2 IPT13/0001 - ISCIII-SGEFI / FEDER (JMF)., This is the final version of the article. It first appeared from BioMed Central at http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s13059-016-1037-6.
- Published
- 2016