Search

Copyright © The Author 2023. This article for the first time seeks to bring together theoretical insights from Judith Butler and Mikhail Bakhtin in order to strengthen their respective understanding of ethics. First, the article suggests that Bakhtin’s theory of dialogic events and the ‘multiaccentuality’ and thematic nature of everyday utterances can help Butler address criticisms that suggest her work concentrates too heavily on invariant meanings in utterances. Second, Butler’s theory of coalitions can usefully politicise Bakhtin’s ideas on utterances, while her ethics of grief is a crucial way to think about how we forge bonds with the ‘Other’. Correspondingly, Bakhtin’s theory of the ethical ‘I’ adds an important moment of ‘empathy’ to Butler’s account of grief and the ‘Other’. Third, Butler’s theory of state hegemony and counter-hegemonic assemblies can provide an important addition to Bakhtin’s theory, while Bakhtin’s theory of carnivalesque democracy strengthens Butler’s insights on equality in assemblies and occupying a liveable life. Leverhulme Trust Fellowship grant (RF-2020-387)

Leverhulme Trust Fellowship grant (RF-2020-387)

In January 2022, Salford Council in Greater Manchester granted permission to the property and investment business, Legal and General Investment Management, to build a new hotel and offices at Ralli Quays in Salford. Controversially, the plans include closing a 300-year-old riverside public footpath. Pedestrians would instead be diverted through a new walkway through the hotel site, but which would also be shut to the public between dawn and dusk (Richardson 2022). Campaigners soon mobilised to oppose the plans and to argue that people had a ‘fundamental right’ to walk along the river, which ‘should not be sacrificed for private gain’ (Pidd 2022). Their tactics included successfully canvassing for a public inquiry into the potential removal of Public Rights of Way along this section of the river by Ralli Quays.

Sponges (Phylum Porifera) are the oldest extant Metazoans. In the deep sea, sponges can occur at high densities forming habitats known as sponge grounds. Sponge grounds can extend over large areas of up to hundreds of km2 and are biodiversity hotspots. However, as human activities, including deep-water hydrocarbon extraction, continue to expand into areas harbouring sponge grounds, understanding how anthropogenic impacts affect sponges and the ecosystem services they provide at multiplebiological scales (community, individual and (sub)cellular levels) is key for achieving sustainable management. This chapter (1) provides an update to the chapter of Advances in Marine Biology Volume 79 entitled “Potential Impacts of Offshore Oil and Gas Activities on Deep-Sea Sponges and the Habitats They Form” and (2) discusses the use of omics as a future tool for deep-sea ecosystem monitoring. While metagenomics and (meta)transcriptomics studies have contributed to improve our understanding of sponge biology in recent years, metabolomics analysis has mostly been used to identify natural products. The sponge metabolome, therefore, remains vastly unknown despite the fact that the metabolome is a key link between the genotype and phenotype, giving us a unique new insight to how key components of an ecosystem are functioning. As the fraction of the metabolome released into the seawater, the sponge exometabolome has only just started to be characterised in comparative environmental metabolomic studies. Yet, the sponge exometabolome constitute a unique opportunity for the identification of biomarkers of sponge health as compounds can be measured in seawater, bypassing the need for physical samples which can still be difficult to collect in the deep sea. Within sponge grounds, the characterisation of a shared sponge exometabolome could lead to the identification of biomarkers of ecosystem functioning and overall health. Challenges remain in establishing omics approaches in environmental monitoring but constant technological advances and reduction in costs means these techniques will become widely available in the future.

The last two decades have witnessed a complete shift in our perception of the deep sea, from a homogeneous, mostly muddy and unspoiled seafloor to a vast patchwork of diverse and fragile habitats as well as a reservoir of living resources, both energy and mineral. Growing and concomitant awareness of the potential for blue growth and vulnerability of deep-sea ecosystems triggered the implementation of management measures and Marine Spatial Planning (MSP) at national, regional and international levels, which are now cumulating in the UN Decade of Ocean Science for Sustainable Development and the International Conference on Marine Biodiversity of Areas Beyond National Jurisdiction (ABNJ). Based on the best available knowledge collated and produced in the framework of ATLAS, the objective of the present deliverable was to integrate all available data into a common analytical framework for systematic conservation planning at the scale of the North Atlantic. Regional-scale MSP in the deep sea unfortunately suffers from a lack of knowledge on the distribution of species and habitats. Such large-scale endeavours to date have thus been mainly relying on biogeochemical and physiographic proxies to design networks of marine protected areas. In just three years, ATLAS has taken an unprecedented step forward in synthesising the data available for the North Atlantic on the distribution of the most vulnerable deep-sea habitats where fragile and long-lived engineering species, such as corals and sponges, are aggregating. Such a synthesis has been enabled through trans-Atlantic collaboration. The 13 case studies (CS), evenly distributed from north to south and east to west of the northern Atlantic, provided new discoveries of deep-sea vulnerable habitats off Greenland, in the Alboran Sea and the Gulf of Cádiz, as well as on Formigas and Tropic seamounts. Beyond new discoveries, ATLAS CS confirmed and improved knowledge on the distribution, ecology and functionality of those vulnerable habitats in the North Atlantic. For Case Study 1 – LoVe Observatory, 1417 records of Lophelia pertusa coral reefs along the Norwegian coast are included. For Case Study 6 - Bay of Biscay, a total of 450 records of 12 different VME types, including coral reefs, coral rubbles, scleractinians, Antipatharians, gorgonians, seapens or pennatulids, mixed corals, aggregation of actiniarians, sponge community and Xenophyophores, are reported. For Case Study 7, VMEs are reported for two areas: 1) for Seco de los Olivos, in the Alboran Sea, 17 VMEs that include sea pen fields, deep-sea sponge aggregations and diverse coral gardens are reported, and 2) for the Volcano of Gazul, in the Gulf of Cádiz, 16 VMEs are reported, that include diverse coral gardens, mud and sand emergent fauna, cold-water coral reef of Lophelia pertusa / Madrepora oculata and deep-sea sponge aggregations. For Case Study 8, VMEs from different areas of the Azores are included: in the Formigas Seamount, 18 VMEs including diverse coral gardens and deep-sea sponge aggregations are reported. Cavalo Seamount, a ridge on the Mid-Atlantic Ridge, Gigante Seamount, Condor Seamount, Dom João de Castro Seamount, and Mar de Prata Seamount also host various coral gardens; the South of Pico Island hosts a deep-sea sponge aggregation of Pheronema carpenteri. The newly discovered Hydrothermal Vent Luso is also reported as a VME for the Azores. For Case Study 10 – Davis Strait, Eastern Arctic, 8 VME areas of deep-sea sponges, 5 VME areas of large gorgonian corals, 4 of small gorgonian corals and 13 of sea pens are reported. Under Case Study 10, the only known Lophelia pertusa reef in Greenland waters is also reported. For Case Study 11 – Flemish Cap, three VME types were identified by the Northwest Atlantic Fisheries Organization (NAFO) and for each, several VME areas are reported: 13 VME areas for sponges, 6 for sea pens and 7 for large gorgonians. For Case Study 12 - Mid-Atlantic Canyons and SE USA, four VMEs are included: 1) Cape Lookout Coral Banks, dominated by large bioherms built by Lophelia pertusa, 2) Hatteras Middle Slope, a physically and biologically unique area of rugged mini-canyons (composed of consolidated muds), 3) Norfolk Canyon, and 4) Baltimore Canyon and vicinities, two rugged submarine canyons that contain extensive cold-water corals. For Case Study 13 - Tropic Seamount is host to multiple VMEs, including dense patches of reef framework-forming scleractinian, dense aggregations of coral gardens, dense monospecific sponge ground of Poliopogon amadou, mixed deep-sea sponge aggregations, Xenophyophore field, and dense crinoid fields.Knowledge gained from ATLAS CS significantly increases the database of vulnerable marine ecosystem (VME) occurrences in the northern Atlantic but the species that define VMEs have been known about for over a century. In order to get an overview of the distribution of VMEs, data coming from sources as various as historical cruises, by-catch of fisheries surveys and Remotely Operated Vehicle (ROV) surveys must be compiled. The reliability of these data however varies and a confidence index has thus been developed in order to objectively and quantitatively rank the reliability of VME records according to the source of records. The ranking ranges from low, for inferred records, to high, for visually assessed records. In addition, not all VMEs equally meet the criteria of rarity, functional significance, fragility and recovery, which vary according to taxa and the abundance of indicator taxa. A VME index has thus been developed to quantitatively and objectively score the vulnerability of VME records. The VME index and the confidence index have been applied to the records of the VME database created and curated by the joint ICES/NAFO Working Group on Deep-water Ecology (WGDEC). This spatial grid of VME likelihood was completed with the unequivocal VMEs mapped in the ATLAS CS. In general, the VME index provides a simplified, spatially aggregated and weighted estimate of the degree to which an area could be considered to contain VMEs under the Food and Agriculture Organisation of the UN (FAO) definition. The VME index clearly highlights areas where a VME is more likely to occur while the associated estimate of confidence gives an indication of how (un)certain that assessment is. The methodology is transparent, science based and data driven, and the aggregate cells can be explored in greater detail to reveal the individual data points that have contributed to the assessment. It integrates far more information than previous methods and as such, better captures the underlying reasoning for identifying VME areas or benthic deep-sea Ecologically or Biologically Significant Marine Areas (EBSAs). The VME index is expected to be updated each year as new data are submitted and will therefore provide an up to date, repeatable and defensible source upon which to base advice as new information is received. The VME index appears to capture most of the important elements of the VME database. This methodology may be considered as a first step towards a systematic approach for the identification and protection of VMEs and EBSAs in the North Atlantic. Our methodology clearly considered several of the steps proposed by Ardron et al. (2014), namely step 1 on assessing potential VME indicator taxa and habitats in a region, step 3 on considering areas already known for their ecological importance, step 4 on compiling information on the distributions of likely VME indicator species and habitats, step 6 on considering fishing impacts, and step 8 on identify ecologically important areas. However, at least one important aspect of the Ardron et al. (2014) framework is missing in the current VME index which refers to understanding the natural distribution of VMEs before significant impacts occurred. This aspect could be considered in future improvements of the VME index to encompass predicted distribution of VME as discussed in Vierod et al. (2014) and Anderson et al. (2016b). Systematic conservation planning is an explicit, objective-based and quantitative approach for allocating areas for biodiversity conservation, for instance used in Marine Protected Area (MPA) networks design process. It aims to identify priority areas answering specific conservation objectives for each considered species or habitat, whilst minimising the socioeconomic costs of conservation over the study area. For the purpose of systematic conservation planning, data on known or inferred VMEs are still too sparse at the scale of the northern Atlantic. The spatial prioritisation developed here aimed to identify zones of conservation importance for seabed species and habitats associated with VMEs in a comprehensive approach, by complementing the records of unequivocal VMEs and the VME likelihood over the basin resulting from the VME index with supplementary information targeting deep-sea species and habitats. ATLAS modelled the present and future distributions of six coral species indicators of VMEs as well as six exploited fish species (D3.3). Through a collaboration with the H2020 Blue Growth SponGES project, the present and future distribution of one sponge species have also been modelled to provide maps of the distribution of key VME indicator taxa with different environmental requirements, life-history strategies and functional significance. The overlap between the present and future distribution of these species under climate change scenarios furtherallowed the mapping of their future climate refugia, constituting resilient areas that were given a high conservation target in simulations. Although the primary focus of ATLAS is on cold-water corals, there is more at stake in terms of conversation in the northern Atlantic. In order to increase the scope of this systematic conservation planning exercise, chemosynthetic ecosystems that qualify as VMEs as well as large physiographic features known to be functional hotspots such as canyons, seamounts and fracture zones have also been considered. Conservation scenarios integrated current management and human activities aspects over the basin, to combine the conservation and socioeconomic stakes during the prioritisation process. While areas already profiting from conservation designations such as fishing closures, MPAs and EBSAs were favoured, areas situated in major bottom-fishing grounds or within deep-sea mining contracts were penalised. In order to suggest a geographically balanced protection network, conservation objectives were replicated within 13 provinces, which considered the main biogeographic and geographical boundaries over the basin as well as a dissociation between broad shallow (800m) habitats. This regionalisation approach ensured a regional replication and representativity of each conservation feature within the main deep-sea biotopes. Finally, this work addressed benthic connectivity aspects, by using the results of larvae drift models to favour connected networks of conservation as best as possible. Emerging from an incremental scenario complexification process, the final simulation (“all management”, Figure 1) resulted in an ecologically coherent conservation network that gave insight into spatial planning possibilities to better protect seabed vulnerable habitats and species. In particular, continental margin slopes, the Mid-Atlantic Ridge, and shelf areas comporting fishing grounds appeared as crucial zones for preserving deep-sea biodiversity (Figure 1). These identified areas comprised of specific habitats (e.g. canyons, ridges, seamounts), concentrating diverse substrates and representing key areas for nutrient circulation, that sustain VMEs and deep-water fish. Even if their depth range is larger, most of the VME indicator taxa used in this study largely occur between 500 and 2500m depths, which were prioritised here. For some species, including gorgonians (Acanella arbuscula, Acanthogorgia armata), scleratinian coral (Lophelia pertusa) and the sponge species (Geodia barretti), future climate refugia are almost exclusively predicted along margin slopes (ATLAS D3.3), that appeared as the most prioritised areas in conservation scenarios. In addition, the Mid-Atlantic Ridge concentrates sites of hydrothermal activity, giving rise to unique chemosynthetic ecosystems. As all known hydrothermal vents south of the Azores Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ), but also several other VMEs, are located in areas already pre-empted for massive sulphide exploration, these latter contained substantial conservation potential. Identified conservation areas situated within the International Seabed Authority (ISA) contracts could inform the regional management plan to be implemented for preserving the Mid-Atlantic Ridge biodiversity from adverse mining impacts. Finally, the prioritisation results suggest that conservation objectives, especially for demersal fish species, could not be achieved without including large fished areas situated on shelves. This result may promote the development of conservation measures on fishing grounds, from full closures for the most efficient, to species-based catch limitation or minimum fish size. The implementation of such restrictions in EEZs or Regional Fisheries Management Organisations (RFMOs) regulatory areas in Areas Beyond National Jurisdictions (ABNJs) would also contribute to fisheries’ sustainability objectives.Selecting the most prioritised planning units allowed delineation of the main priority areas for deep-sea conservation (Figure 2). Covering approximatively 17% of the study area, these priority areas would answer a relatively high conservation goal for the deep sea, nonetheless they suffer from poor conservation at the moment (Figure 2). Less than 1% of the study area falls into fishing closures and marine reserves that already protect the priority areas for benthic deep-sea ecosystems. For instance, only a few unequivocal VMEs, species climate refugia or canyons currently benefit from some form of protection. In that respect, our systematic planning exercise has shown that, as important as they are, the sum of all Area-Based Management Tools (ABMTs) of the northern Atlantic still suffer from a lack of conservation efficiency, representativity and viability. Moreover, our results highlighted that a more continuous conservation network, displaying corridors or shorter distances between conservation areas, would lead to a more connected and thus more resilient benthic conservation framework. Ultimately, climate change pressures are likely to largely affect deep-sea oceanography and biodiversity, and the ability of current ABMTs to preserve them. Protecting the priority areas herein identified, which hold substantial resilience potential to future environmental changes through the central place of climate refugia in scenarios, could promote the long-term viability of the deep-sea conservation for the North Atlantic.To our knowledge, this study is the first in systematic conservation planning to address the conservation of deep-sea benthic and demersal biodiversity across a whole oceanic basin. These results contribute to the development of systematic approaches for large scale MSP, such as the conservation management of ABNJs currently the object of ongoing international discussions. Lacking of a coordinated framework as well as efficient, permanent and recognised protection measures, the North-Atlantic high seas conservation network could benefit from the suggestions provided by our scientific evaluation. Finally, this basin scale prioritisation will provide general material for local conservation, through a transfer to the MSP work implemented for ATLAS case studies in ATLAS Work Package 6.&nbsp

Seamounts provide oases of hard substrate in the deep sea that are frequently associated with locally enhanced biological productivity and diversity. There is now increasing recognition of their ecological and socio-economic importance. However, management strategies for these habitats are constrained not only by limited ecological understanding but by the general public’s understanding of the pressures facing these ecosystems. This study adds to the growing literature on willingness to pay for conservation of deep-sea ecosystems and species by undertaking a stated preference survey to assess tourist’s awareness of seamounts and their preferences for protection within the Galapagos Marine Reserve. Visitors’ perceptions of seamount biodiversity must be studied because tourists are key drivers of the Galapagos economy and account for 41% of the Marine Reserve budget. Our survey captured the attitudes, perceptions and willingness to pay of tourists for an increase in the entrance fee to the Galapagos Marine Reserve. Results showed tourists were willing to pay on average US$48.93 in addition to existing entrance fees. The results of this study support the willingness to develop a multiuse management plan for the Galapagos Marine Reserve, balancing conservation, local communities livelihoods and sustainable tourism. Our results evidence a willingness to support and fund conservation, which is of critical importance to both the Galapagos National Park and local non-governmental organizations heavily reliant for their work on entrance fees and donations respectively. Overall, the conclusion from this study is that, despite limited knowledge, visitors of the Galapagos Islands attach positive and significant values to the conservation of seamount biodiversity.

Report of the in-situ hydrodynamics, abiotic variables, and suspended particles near the seafloor and sedimenting particles from bottom traps to identify organic matter transport pathways for different case study sites and a qualitative comparison with output from the high‐resolution hydrodynamic models during periods of strong and weak AMOC.

Community respiration rates based on in situ O2 consumption as a function of key physical parameters (flow, temperature, dissolved oxygen) and in relation to biogeochemical characteristics of the OM and faunal characterization (community composition, biomass) at the different study sites.

The North Atlantic is a dynamic space with increasing human uses, the emerging impacts of climate change and numerous policy developments that occur along different timelines at national, regional and global scales. The breadth of expertise within the ATLAS consortium has allowed ATLAS research to inform a wide array of policy discussions, which ultimately aim to balance the needs of a developing Blue Economy and the protection of vulnerable marine ecosystems found throughout the North Atlantic. ATLAS engagement in policy discussions provides a tangible example of the Galway Statement in practice and how ocean science can help to address the most pressing ocean management issues. In brief, this report aims to: Summarise the policy-relevant outputs from each ATLAS Work Package Provide an account of how the ATLAS Project has engaged with policy discussions and informed decision-making. In addition to the examples of policy-engagement outlined within this report, it is important to note that scientific advances and policy development operate on different timelines. Every effort has been made to publish Project results; however, policy developments, especially those involving intergovernmental negotiations, do not always operate within the 4-5 year schedule afforded to scientific research projects. As a result, ATLAS research will continue to inform policy discussions well after the project has officially ended. By summarising the policy-relevant outputs from each Work Package, this report represents the policy-related legacy of ATLAS and provides an overview of ATLAS results that can be used within on-going negotiations.

Ocean acidification is a threat to the net growth of tropical and deep-sea coral reefs, due to gradual changes in the balance between reef growth and loss processes. Here we go beyond identification of coral dissolution induced by ocean acidification and identify a mechanism that will lead to a loss of habitat in cold-water coral reef habitats on an ecosystem-scale. To quantify this, we present in situ and year-long laboratory evidence detailing the type of habitat shift that can be expected (in situ evidence), the mechanisms underlying this (in situ and laboratory evidence), and the timescale within which the process begins (laboratory evidence). Through application of engineering principals, we detail how increased porosity in structurally critical sections of coral framework will lead to crumbling of load-bearing material, and a potential collapse and loss of complexity of the larger habitat. Importantly, in situ evidence highlights that cold-water corals can survive beneath the aragonite saturation horizon, but in a fundamentally different way to what is currently considered a biogenic cold-water coral reef, with a loss of the majority of reef habitat. The shift from a habitat with high 3-dimensional complexity provided by both live and dead coral framework, to a habitat restricted primarily to live coral colonies with lower 3-dimensional complexity represents the main threat to cold-water coral reefs of the future and the biodiversity they support. Ocean acidification can cause ecosystem-scale habitat loss for the majority of cold-water coral reefs.

Many of the marine policy frameworks developed to protect biodiversity in deep-sea areas, including areas beyond national jurisdiction (ABNJ), include indicators to assess policy objectives. These frameworks often have specific guidance on how the indicators should be applied and interpreted. Selection of indicators is an important process and those with strong scientific underpinnings are more likely to produce the expected outcomes. We reviewed three policy and assessment frameworks which include ABNJ regions or were developed specifically for ABNJ: (1) Oslo and Paris Convention for the Protection of the Marine Environment of the North-East Atlantic (OSPAR) ecosystem assessments, (2) the frameworks adopted to implement the UN General Assembly (UNGA) sustainable fisheries resolutions for the management of bottom fisheries to prevent Significant Adverse Impacts on vulnerable marine ecosystems, and (3) the Aichi Biodiversity Targets adopted by Parties to the Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD). We examined whether an assessment approach based on evaluation of Good Environmental Status (GES) under the European Union’s Marine Strategy Framework Directive (MSFD), could be applied to ABNJ. We examined each MSFD descriptor for its applicability to deep-sea habitats considering the work of two European projects concluding that the MSFD could be applied to ABNJ to support OSPAR, UNGA and CBD policy objectives towards a common approach to the assessment of the status of deep-sea ecosystems in ABNJ. In achieving this we also introduce readers outside of Europe to the work conducted within the MSFD.

In the last two decades the use of species distribution modeling (SDM) for the study and management of marine species has increased dramatically. The availability of predictor variables on a global scale and the ease of use of SDM techniques have resulted in a proliferation of research on the topic of species distribution in the deep sea. Translation of research projects into management tools that can be used to make decisions in the face of changing climate and increasing exploitation of deep-sea resources has been less rapid but necessary. The goal of this workshop was to discuss methods and variables for modeling species distributions in deep-sea habitats and produce standards that can be used to judge SDMs that may be useful to meet management and conservation goals. During the workshop, approaches to modeling and environmental data were discussed and guidelines developed including the desire that 1) environmental variables should be chosen for ecological significance a priori; 2) the scale and accuracy of environmental data should be considered in choosing a modeling method; 3) when possible proxy variables such as depth should be avoided if causal variables are available; 4) models with statistically robust and rigorous outputs are preferred, but not always possible; and 5) model validation is important. Although general guidelines for SDMs were developed, in most cases management issues and objectives should be considered when designing a modeling project. In particular, the trade-off between model complexity and researcher’s ability to communicate input data, modeling method, results and uncertainty is an important consideration for the target audience. RÉSUMÉ. Au cours des deux dernières décennies, le recours à la modélisation de la répartition des espèces pour étudier et gérer les espèces marines a considérablement augmenté. La disponibilité des variables prédictives à l’échelle mondiale et la convivialité de ces techniques de modélisation ont entraîné la multiplication des recherches sur la répartition des espèces en haute mer. La traduction des projets de recherche en outils de gestion pouvant servir à prendre des décisions dans le contexte des changements climatiques et de l’exploitation accrue des ressources en haute mer est moins rapide, quoique nécessaire. Cet atelier visait à discuter des méthodes et variables pour la modélisation de la répartition des espèces dans les habitats en haute mer, et à établir des normes pour évaluer les méthodes de modélisation pouvant aider à atteindre les objectifs en matière de gestion et de conservation. Pendant l’atelier, les approches envers la modélisation et les données environnementales ont fait l’objet de discussions, et des lignes directrices ont été élaborées. Celles-ci comprenaient les caractéristiques souhaitées qui suivent: 1) les variables environnementales devraient être choisies selon leur importance écologique a priori; 2) l’ampleur et l’exactitude des données environnementales devraient être prises en compte durant la sélection d’une méthode de modélisation; 3) dans la mesure du possible, les variables substitutives, comme la profondeur, doivent être évitées si des variables causales sont disponibles; 4) les modèles dont les résultats sont statistiquement solides et rigoureux sont privilégiés, mais leur utilisation n’est pas toujours possible; 5) la validation du modèle est importante. Même si des lignes générales sur la modélisation de la répartition des espèces ont été mises au point, les objectifs et enjeux de gestion devraient généralement être pris en compte pendant la conception d’un projet de modélisation. En particulier, le compromis entre la complexité du modèle et la capacité du chercheur à communiquer les données d’entrée, la méthode de modélisation, les résultats et les incertitudes sont des facteurs importants pour le public cible.

Determining the scale of anthropogenic impacts is critical in order to understand ecosystem effects of human activities, within the context of changes caused by natural environmental variability. We applied spatial eigenfunction analysis to disentangle effects of anthropogenic drivers from environmental factors on species assembly in the Faroe-Shetland Channel (FSC), in the northeast Atlantic. We found that the species assembly considered here was structured at both small and large spatial scales. Specifically, substrate types, distance to oil wells and pipelines, the presence of objects and demersal fishing (both static and mobile) appeared significant in explaining large spatial scale species assembly structures. Conversely, temperature and variance in temperature shaped the species community across smaller spatial scales. Mobile scavenger species were found in areas impacted by demersal fishing. Oil and gas structures seemed to provide a habitat for a range of species including the commercially important fishes Molva sp. and Sebastes sp. These results demonstrate how the benthic ecosystem in the FSC has been shaped by multiple human activities, at both small and large spatial scales. Only by sampling datasets covering several sites, like in this study, can the effects of anthropogenic activities be separated from natural environmental controls.

Cold-water coral carbonate mounds, created by framework-building scleractinian corals, are also important habitats for non-scleractinian corals, whose ecology and role are understudied in deep-sea environments. This paper describes the diversity, ecology and role of non-scleractinian corals on scleractinian cold-water coral carbonate mounds in the Logachev Mound Province, Rockall Bank, NE Atlantic. In total ten non-scleractinian species were identified, which were mapped out along eight ROV video transects. Eight species were identified as black corals (three belonging to the family Schizopathidae, one each to the Leiopathidae, Cladopathidae, and Antipathidae and two to an unknown family) and two as gorgonians (Isididae and Plexauridae). The most abundant species were Leiopathes sp. and Parantipathes sp. 2. Areas with a high diversity of non-scleractinian corals are interpreted to offer sufficient food, weak inter-species competition and the presence of heterogeneous and hard settlement substrates. A difference in the density and occurrence of small vs. large colonies of Leiopathes sp. was also observed, which is likely related to a difference in the stability of the substrate they choose for settlement. Non-scleractinian corals, especially black corals, are an important habitat for crabs, crinoids, and shrimps in the Logachev Mound Province. The carrier crab Paromola sp. was observed carrying the plexaurid Paramuricea sp. and a black coral species belonging to the genus Parantipathes, a behavior believed to provide the crab with camouflage or potentially a defense mechanism against predators. More information on the ecophysiology of nonscleractinian corals and fine-scale local organic matter supply are needed to understand what drives differences in their spatial distribution and community structure.

The extent ofmarine litter andmicroplastic occurrence across ocean biomes and species remains poorly characterised, particularly in remote deep-water ecosystems. The present study in the East Mingulay Special Area of Conservation (a Marine Protected Area in the Sea of the Hebrides, western Scotland) used historic surveys and benthic samples to obtain baseline levels of anthropogenic debris and microparticle ingestion. Most debris identified in the MPA was fisheries-related. A total of 11% of benthic macrofauna from Mingulay Reef Area 1 and Banana Reef had ingested microplastics, with no statistically significant effect of feeding guild, station, or reef, on ingestion rates. However, the ingestion rate was highest at a station located in a topographic hollow along a gentle sloping area with strong variable ocean currents where fine-scale interactions between bathymetry and hydrography may have helped trap and focus microparticles. Raman spectroscopy of microparticles revealed several types of polymers being ingested, tentatively identified as polypropylene (PP), polyurethane (PU), polystyrene (PS), and polyethylene terephthalate (PET). Besides establishing a baseline assessment of marine litter and microparticles in a deep-water setting, the approach demonstrates the utility of using historic data and specimens collected for other purposes to expand the geographic and ecosystem coverage for larger more regional-scale and even basin-wide assessments such as those needed to inform Good Environmental Status in European waters, as called for by the Marine Strategy Framework Directive.

The Hatton-Rockall plateau in the northeast Atlantic Ocean has long been the subject of interest for fishers, prospectors, conservationists, managers, planners, and politicians. As a feature that straddles national and international waters, it is subject to a multitude of competing and confounding regulations, making the development of a holistic management plan for sustainable use fraught with difficulty. Here, the various stakeholders in the area are collated, together with the rules they have created or must abide by with respect to biodiversity assets, maritime resources, and governance frameworks. Blue Growth envisages optimal use of sea areas, including potential for additional commercial activities. Current research and stakeholder engagement efforts to achieve this integration are described, and the contribution of the EU-funded ATLAS project is analyzed. In particular, more precise, ground-truthed information has the potential to inform systematic conservation planning, providing the basis for sustainable development and improving adaptive management. By scrutinizing and exposing all the elements in this example of a spatially managed area we show how the expectations of each stakeholder can be better managed.

An efficient connectivity-based method for multi-objective optimization applicable to the design of marine protected area networks is described. Multi-objective network optimization highlighted previously unreported step changes in the structure of optimal subnetworks for protection associated with minimal changes in cost or benefit functions. This emphasizes the desirability of performing a full, unconstrained, multi-objective optimization for marine spatial planning. Brute force methods, examining all possible combinations of protected and unprotected sites for a network of sites, are impractical for all but the smallest networks as the number of possible networks grows as 2m, where m is the number of sites within the network. A metaheuristic method based around Markov Chain Monte Carlo methods is described which searches for the set of Pareto optimal networks (or a good approximation thereto) given two separate objective functions, for example for network quality or effectiveness, population persistence, or cost of protection. The optimization and search methods are independent of the choice of objective functions and can be easily extended to more than two functions. The speed, accuracy and convergence of the method under a range of network configurations are tested with model networks based on an extension of random geometric graphs. Examination of two real-world marine networks, one designated for the protection of the stony coral Lophelia pertusa, the other a hypothetical man-made network of oil and gas installations to protect hard substrate ecosystems, demonstrates the power of the method in findingmulti-objective optimal solutions for networks of up to 100 sites. Results using network average shortest path as a proxy for population resilience and gene flow within the network supports the use of a conservation strategy based around highly connected clusters of sites.

Highly connected networks generally improve resilience in complex systems. We present a novel application of this paradigm and investigated the potential for anthropogenic structures in the ocean to enhance connectivity of a protected species threatened by human pressures and climate change. Biophysical dispersal models of a protected coral species simulated potential connectivity between oil and gas installations across the North Sea but also metapopulation outcomes for naturally occurring corals downstream. Network analyses illustrated how just a single generation of virtual larvae released from these installations could create a highly connected anthropogenic system, with larvae becoming competent to settle over a range of natural deep-sea, shelf and fjord coral ecosystems including a marine protected area. These results provide the first study showing that a system of anthropogenic structures can have international conservation significance by creating ecologically connected networks and by acting as stepping stones for cross-border interconnection to natural populations.

Maritime industries routinely collect critical environmental data needed for sustainable management of marine ecosystems, supporting both the blue economy and future growth. Collating this information would provide a valuable resource for all stakeholders. For the North Sea, the oil and gas industry has been a dominant presence for over 50 years that has contributed to a wealth of knowledge about the environment. As the industry begins to decommission its offshore structures, this information will be critical for avoiding duplication of effort in data collection and ensuring best environmental management of offshore activities. This paper summarises the outcomes of a Blue Growth Data Challenge Workshop held in 2017 with participants from: the oil and gas industry; the key UK regulatory and management bodies for oil and gas decommissioning; open access data facilitators; and academic and research institutes. Here, environmental data collection and archiving by oil and gas operators in the North Sea are described, alongside how this compares to other offshore industries; what the barriers and opportunities surrounding environmental data sharing are; and how wider data sharing from offshore industries could be achieved. Five primary barriers to data sharing were identified: 1) Incentives, 2) Risk Perception, 3) Working Cultures, 4) Financial Models, and 5) Data Ownership. Active and transparent communication and collaboration between stakeholders including industry, regulatory bodies, data portals and academic institutions will be key to unlocking the data that will be critical to informing responsible decommissioning decisions for offshore oil and gas structures in the North Sea.

This article explores the concept of “other effective area-based conservation measures” (OECMs) in the context of the UN Convention on Biological Diversity (CBD) Aichi Biodiversity Target 11 on marine protected areas and OECMs and its linkages to the Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs). It argues that mainstreaming biodiversity through CBD Aichi Biodiversity Targets’ implementation into the SDGs can contribute to a more systemic and comprehensive implementation of SDG 14.5 on conservation of at least 10% of marine and coastal areas. It argues that OECMs can complement MPAs and contribute to ecologically representative and effectively managed marine protected areas systems integrated into broader governance systems such as marine spatial planning. Selected global and local sectoral conservation measures are therefore highlighted in this analysis as potential forms of OECMs. At the local level, a case study of ecologically or biologically significant marine areas managed as locally managed marine areas (LMMAs) in Mozambique is discussed. This case study explores how multipleuse LMMAs, which respond to short-term fisher's needs and targeted biodiversity conservation, could contribute to the achievement of specific SDGs on food security, poverty elimination and resilient ecosystems if properly supported by long-term investments, strong institutions and integrated oceans management.

Peroxyacetyl nitrate (PAN) is an important chemical species in the troposphere as it aids the long-range transport of NOx and subsequent formation of O3 in relatively clean remote regions. Over the past few decades observations from aircraft campaigns and surface sites have been used to better understand the regional distribution of PAN. However, recent measurements made by satellites allow for a global assessment of PAN in the upper troposphere-lower stratosphere (UTLS). In this study, we investigate global PAN distributions from two independent retrieval methodologies, based on measurements from the Michelson Interferometer for Passive Atmospheric Sounding (MIPAS) instrument, on board Envisat from the Institute of Meteorology and Climate Research (IMK), Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, and the Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Leicester (UoL). Retrieving PAN from MIPAS is challenging due to the weak signal in the measurements and contamination from other species. Therefore, we compare the two MIPAS datasets with observations from the Atmospheric Chemistry Experiment Fourier transform spectrometer (ACE-FTS), in situ aircraft data and the 3-D chemical transport model TOMCAT. MIPAS shows peak UTLS PAN concentrations over the biomass burning regions (e.g. ranging from 150 to > 200 pptv at 150 hPa) and during the summertime Asian monsoon as enhanced convection aids the vertical transport of PAN from the lower atmosphere. At 150 hPa, we find significant differences between the two MIPAS datasets in the tropics, where IMK PAN concentrations are larger by 50-100 pptv. Comparisons between MIPAS and ACE-FTS show better agreement with the UoL MIPAS PAN concentrations at 200 hPa, but with mixed results above this altitude. TOMCAT generally captures the magnitude and structure of climatological aircraft PAN profiles within the observational variability allowing it to be used to investigate the MIPAS PAN differences. TOMCAT-MIPAS comparisons show that the model is both positively (UoL) and negatively (IMK) biased against the satellite products. These results indicate that satellite PAN observations are able to detect realistic spatial variations in PAN in the UTLS, but further work is needed to resolve differences in existing retrievals to allow quantitative use of the products.

International efforts are underway to establish well-connected systems of marine protected areas (MPAs) covering at least 10% of the ocean by 2020. But the nature and dynamics of ocean ecosystem connectivity are poorly understood, with unresolved effects of climate variability. We used 40-year runs of a particle tracking model to examine the sensitivity of an MPA network for habitat-forming cold-water corals in the northeast Atlantic to changes in larval dispersal driven by atmospheric cycles and larval behaviour. Trajectories of Lophelia pertusa larvae were strongly correlated to the North Atlantic Oscillation (NAO), the dominant pattern of interannual atmospheric circulation variability over the northeast Atlantic. Variability in trajectories significantly altered network connectivity and source–sink dynamics, with positive phase NAO conditions producing a well-connected but asymmetrical network connected from west to east. Negative phase NAO produced reduced connectivity, but notably some larvae tracked westwardflowing currents towards coral populations on the mid-Atlantic ridge. Graph theoretical metrics demonstrate critical roles played by seamounts and offshore banks in larval supply and maintaining connectivity across the network. Larval longevity and behaviour mediated dispersal and connectivity, with shorter lived and passive larvae associated with reduced connectivity. We conclude that the existing MPA network is vulnerable to atmospheric-driven changes in ocean circulation.

In recent years, the public sphere, which represents a realm in civil society where people can debate and discuss a range of issues and common concerns important to them, has become a key area for research in the humanities and social sciences. Arguably, however, Marxist theory has yet to advance a theoretical account of the most abstract and simple ideological properties of the capitalist public sphere as these appear under universal commodity relationships. The paper therefore tentatively seeks to develop such an account. Specifically, the paper theoretically derives a peculiar public sphere under capitalism, which is mediated between at least two commodity owners who also possess distinctive personalities driven by desires to own commodities. The paper then explains in more detail how the social form of this public sphere develops through other elements of commodity relations and their contradictions.