Ideal animal models of human cancers that metastasize to bone would reproduce the genetic and phenotypic changes that occur with human cancers. These include invasion, vascular spread to bone, and proliferation and survival in the bone marrow microenvironment with subsequent modifications of bone structure. In addition, such models would be reproducible and progress rapidly to permit timely investigations. Based on the pathogenesis of cancer in rodents and smaller mammals, this ideal may represent an unrealistic and impractical goal. However, animal models of bone metastasis that mimic selected aspects of human disease have been utilized and refinements to the models will continue to be developed. Because spontaneous bone metastasis in animals is uncommon, most animal models of bone metastasis must be derived experimentally. This limitation has resulted in the development of specific models that represent unique stages of human bone metastasis. Thorough characterization of these animal models is required to permit their appropriate use as a representation of human disease. This review includes information on the rather infrequent spontaneous bone metastasis in animals with mammary and prostate carcinoma, the current uses of these and other animal models of bone metastasis, and recent developments that will better model human disease. There is a role for animal models in the study of bone metastasis, as well as a need for refinement of these models to advance our understanding of this important manifestation of oncogenesis. Cancer progression with resulting bone metastases requires genetic changes that permit tissue invasion at the site of the primary tumor, entry into the vasculature, localization to bone, exit from the vasculature, survival and proliferation in the bone marrow microenvironment, and modification of bone structure and function.1,2 The genetic changes include metastasis-enhancing and suppressing genes, many of which are currently being identified and characterized using animal models. Bone metastasis-enhancing (and suppressing) genes are associated with multiple cellular processes that occur normally during mammalian development. These genes regulate cell shape and migration, interactions with extracellular matrix and stroma, angiogenesis, apoptosis, proliferation, and proteins that are usually associated with normal bone function (such as bone matrix proteins and hormones/cytokines that regulate bone cell activity). Although genes associated with bone metastasis can be identified readily by screening techniques (e.g., gene arrays), the validation and characterization of these genes will require sophisticated animal models that closely mirror the pathophysiology of bone metastasis in humans. Because of the relatively artificial nature of animal models of bone metastasis, it is necessary to define what is considered a bone metastasis. End-stage lesions are readily identifiable and usually reveal tumor cell proliferation in bone that modifies bone structure. These would be comparable to clinically significant bone metastases in humans. Overt lesions can be identified by radiography or histopathology in animals. However, quantification of metastases with these insensitive techniques likely underestimates the actual number of bone metastases. For example, radiography will only detect severe lesions and will not measure all bone metastases. In addition, radiography will not detect bone metastases that fail to induce severe bone lysis or induce formation of mineralized matrix. In contrast, overestimation may result from newer highly sensitive techniques. For example, polymerase chain reaction (PCR) may detect tumor cells in bone that are arrested in blood vessels or quiescent cells in the bone marrow that may not develop into metastases.3,4 Therefore, morphologic assessment is necessary to confirm the incidence and nature of bone metastases in each animal model. Animal models of bone metastasis include spontaneous tumors that arise in rodents or small mammals (e.g., dogs and cats), syngeneic transplantation of spontaneously occurring rodent cancers, chemical induction of cancers in selected strains of rats and mice, newly developed transgenic mouse models, and xenografts of human tumors or cell lines derived from human cancers into immunodeficient rodents (e.g., nude mice and rats, and severely compromised immunodeficient [SCID] mice; Fig. 1). Xenografted tissue or cells can be injected, subcutaneously into the left ventricle of the heart, or directly into the tibia or femur. In addition, xenografts can be implanted into orthotopic locations, such as the mammary fat pad, lungs, or prostate gland. Human bone can be implanted in immunodeficient rodents or bone ossicles can be induced in the subcutis to serve as a site for metastasis or implantation of tumor tissue to investigate the interactions of cancers with bone tissue in a nontraditional site.5,6 Animal models have been used successfully to select variants of cell or tumor lines that have an increased incidence of metastasis to bone. Selection pressure on the derived variants must be maintained to sustain the desired phenotype. FIGURE 1 Animal models of bone metastasis include spontaneous tumors in rodents and domestic animals, such as dogs and cats; spontaneous tumors in inbred strains of rodents that can be maintained as tumor lines in syngeneic hosts; chemically induced tumors in ...