Search

Causal analysis has become an essential component in understanding the underlying causes of phenomena across various fields. Despite its significance, existing literature on causal discovery algorithms is fragmented, with inconsistent methodologies, i.e., there is no universal classification standard for existing methods, and a lack of comprehensive evaluations, i.e., data characteristics are often ignored to be jointly analyzed when benchmarking algorithms. This study addresses these gaps by conducting an exhaustive review and empirical evaluation for causal discovery methods on numerical data, aiming to provide a clearer and more structured understanding of the field. Our research begins with a comprehensive literature review spanning over two decades, analyzing over 200 academic articles and identifying more than 40 representative algorithms. This extensive analysis leads to the development of a structured taxonomy tailored to the complexities of causal discovery, categorizing methods into six main types. To address the lack of comprehensive evaluations, our study conducts an extensive empirical assessment of 29 causal discovery algorithms on multiple synthetic and real-world datasets. We categorize synthetic datasets based on size, linearity, and noise distribution, employing five evaluation metrics, and summarize the top-3 algorithm recommendations, providing guidelines for users in various data scenarios. Our results highlight a significant impact of dataset characteristics on algorithm performance. Moreover, a metadata extraction strategy with an accuracy exceeding 80% is developed to assist users in algorithm selection on unknown datasets. Based on these insights, we offer professional and practical guidelines to help users choose the most suitable causal discovery methods for their specific dataset.

Robust watermarking tries to conceal information within a cover image/video imperceptibly that is resistant to various distortions. Recently, deep learning-based approaches for image watermarking have made significant advancements in robustness and invisibility. However, few studies focused on video watermarking using deep neural networks due to the high complexity and computational costs. Our paper aims to answer this research question: Can well-designed deep learning-based image watermarking be efficiently adapted to video watermarking? Our answer is positive. First, we revisit the workflow of deep learning-based watermarking methods that leads to a critical insight: temporal information in the video may be essential for general computer vision tasks but not for specific video watermarking. Inspired by this insight, we propose a method named ItoV for efficiently adapting deep learning-based Image watermarking to Video watermarking. Specifically, ItoV merges the temporal dimension of the video with the channel dimension to enable deep neural networks to treat videos as images. We further explore the effects of different convolutional blocks in video watermarking. We find that spatial convolution is the primary influential component in video watermarking and depthwise convolutions significantly reduce computational cost with negligible impact on performance. In addition, we propose a new frame loss to constrain that the watermark intensity in each video clip frame is consistent, significantly improving the invisibility. Extensive experiments show the superior performance of the adapted video watermarking method compared with the state-of-the-art methods on Kinetics-600 and Inter4K datasets, which demonstrate the efficacy of our method ItoV.