1. Racial differences in systemic sclerosis disease presentation: A European Scleroderma Trials and Research group study
- Author
-
Jaeger, Veronika K, Tikly, Mohammed, Dong, Xu, Siegert, Elise, Hachulla, Eric, Airò, Paolo, Valentini, Gabriele, Matucci Cerinic, Marco, Distler, Oliver, Cozzi, Franco, Carreira, Patricia, Allanore, Yannick, Müller-Ladner, Ulf, Ananieva, Lidia P, Balbir-Gurman, Alexandra, Distler, Jörg H W, Czirják, Laszlo, Mengtao, Li, Henes, Jörg, Jimenez, Sergio A, Smith, Vanessa, Damjanov, Nemanja, Denton, Christopher P, Delgaldo, Francesco, Saketkoo, Lesley Ann, Walker, Ulrich, A, Randone, Sb, Bannert, B, Iannone, F, Maurer, B, Jordan, S, Dobrota, R, Becker, M, Mihai, C, Becvarare, R, Tomčík, M, Bielecka, Ok, Gindzienska-Sieskiewicz, E, Karaszewska, K, Cutolo, M, Pizzorni, C, Paolino, S, Sulli, A, Ruaro, B, Alessandri, E, Riccardi, A, Giacco, V, Messitini, V, Irace, R, Kedor, C, Casteleyn, V, Hilger, J, Hoeppner, J, Rednic, S, Szabo, I, Petcu, A, Avouac, J, Camelia, F, Desbas, C, Vlachoyiannopoulos, P, Montecucco, C, Caporali, R, Cavagna, L, Stork, J, Inanc, M, Joven, Be, Novak, S, Anic, F, Varju, C, Minier, T, Chizzolini, C, Allai, D, Kucharz, Ej, Kotulska, A, Kopec-Medrek, M, Widuchowska, M, Dolnicar, As, Coleiro, B, Gabrielli, A, Manfredi, L, Benfaremo, D, Ferrarini, A, Bancel, Df, Hij, A, Lansiaux, P, Lazzaroni, Mg, Hesselstrand, R, Wuttge, D, Andréasson, R, Martinovic, D, Bozic, I, Radic, M, Braun-Moscovici, Y, Monaco, Al, Furini, F, Hunzelmann, N, Moinzadeh, P, Pellerito, R, Caimmi, C, Bertoldo, E, Morovic-Vergles, J, Culo, Im, Pecher, Ac, Santamaria, Vo, Heitmann, S, Codagnone, M, Pflugfelder, J, Krasowska, D, Michalska-Jakubus, M, Seidel, M, Hasler, P, Kretschmar, S, Kohm, M, Bajocchi, G, Salvador, Mj, Silva, Japd, Stamenkovic, B, Stankovic, A, Selmi, Cf, Santis, M, Ceribelli, A, Garzanova, L, Koneva, O, Starovoytova, M, Herrick, A, Puppo, F, Negrini, S, Murdaca, G, Engelhart, M, Szücs, G, Szamosi, S, de la Puente, C, Grande, Cs, Villanueva, Mjg, Midtvedt, Sø, Hoffmann-Vold, Am, Launay, D, Sobanski, V, Riccieri, V, Vasile, M, Ionescu, Rm, Opris, D, Sha, A, Woods, A, Gheorghiu, Am, Bojinca, M, Sunderkötter, C, Ehrchen, J, Ingegnoli, F, Mouthon, L, Dunogue, B, Chaigne, B, Legendre, P, Cantatore, Fp, Corrado, A, Ullman, S, Iversen, L, von Mühlen CA, Pozzi, Mr, Eyerich, K, Lauffer, F, Wiland, P, Szmyrka-Kaczmarek, M, Sokolik, R, Morgiel, E, Madej, M, Vanthuyne, M, Frédéric, H, Alegre-Sancho, Jj, Aringer, M, Herrmann, K, Günther, C, Westhovens, R, Langhe, E, Lenaerts, J, Anic, B, Baresic, M, Mayer, M, Üprus, M, Otsa, K, Yavuz, S, Granel, B, Radominski, Sc, De, C, Müller, S, Azevedo, Vf, Mendoza, F, Busquets, J, Popa, S, Agachi, S, Zenone, T, Pileckyte, M, Stebbings, S, Mathieu, A, Vacca, A, Sampaio-Barros, Pd, Stamp, L, Solanki, K, Silva, C, Schollum, J, Barns-Graham, H, Veale, D, O'Rourke, M, Loyo, E, Tineo, C, Paulino, G, Mohamed, Waaa, Rosato, E, Gigante, A, Oksel, F, Yargucu, F, Tanaseanu, Cm, Popescu, M, Dumitrascu, A, Tiglea, I, Foti, R, Visalli, E, Benenati, A, Amato, G, Ancuta, C, Villiger, P, Adler, S, Fröhlich, J, Kayser, C, Eduardo, Al, Fathi, N, Alii, S, Ahmed, M, Hasaneen, S, Hakeem, Ee, de la PG, Lefebvre, P, Martin, Jjg, Sibilia, J, Chatelus, E, Gottenberg, Je, Chifflot, H, Litinsky, I, Galdo, Fd, Abignano, G, Eng, S, Seskute, G, Butrimiene, I, Rugiene, R, Karpec, D, Pascal, M, Kerzberg, E, Bianchi, W, Bianchi, Bv, Bianchi, Dv, Barcellos, Y, Castellví, I, Millan, M, Limonta, M, Rimar, D, Rosner, I, Slobodin, G, Couto, M, Spertini, F, Ribi, C, Buss, G, Marcoccia, A, Bondanini, F, Ciani, A, Kahl, S, Hsu, Vm, Martin, T, Poindron, V, Meghit, K, Moiseev, S, Novikov, P, Chung, L, Kolstad, K, Stark, M, Schmeiser, T, Thiele, A, Majewski, D, Zdrojewski, Z, Zaneta, S, Wierzba, K, Martínez-Barrio, J, López-Longo, Fj, Bernardino, V, Moraes-Fontes, Mf, Rodrigues, Ac, Riemekasten, G, Sommerlatte, S, Jendreck, S, Arnold, S, Levy, Y, Rezus, E, Cardoneanu, A, Burlui, Am, Pamuk, On, Puttini, Ps, Talotta, R, Bongiovanni, S, Poormoghim, H, Andalib, E, Almasi, S, Kötter, I, Krusche, M, Cuomo, G, Danzo, F, Masini, F, Gaches, F, Michaud, M, Cartos, F, Belloli, L, Casu, C, Sfikakis, P, Tektonidou, M, Furst, D, Feldman, Gr, Ramazan, Am, Nurmambet, E, Miroto, A, Suta, C, Andronache, I, Huizinga, Twj, de Vries-Bouwstra, J., Chizzolini, Carlo, Jaeger, Veronika K, Tikly, Mohammed, Xu, Dong, Siegert, Elise, Hachulla, Eric, Airò, Paolo, Valentini, Gabriele, Matucci Cerinic, Marco, Distler, Oliver, Cozzi, Franco, Carreira, Patricia, Allanore, Yannick, Müller-Ladner, Ulf, Ananieva, Lidia P, Balbir-Gurman, Alexandra, Distler, Jörg H W, Czirják, Laszlo, Li, Mengtao, Henes, Jörg, Jimenez, Sergio A, Smith, Vanessa, Damjanov, Nemanja, Denton, Christopher P, Delgaldo, Francesco, Saketkoo, Lesley Ann, Walker, Ulrich A, University of Zurich, Cerinic, Marco Matucci, Walker Ulrich, A, Randone, Silvia Bellando, Bannert, Bettina, Iannone, Florenzoaa, Maurer, Brittaab, Jordan, Suzanaab, Dobrota, Rucsandraab, Becker, Mikeab, Mihai, Carinaa, Becvarare, Radima, Tomcik, Michala, Bielecka, Otylia Kowala, Gindzienska-Sieskiewicz, Ewaa, Karaszewska, Katarzynaa, Cutolo, Maurizioa, Pizzorni, Carmena, Paolino, Sabrinaae, Sulli, Albertoa, Ruaro, Barbara, Alessandri, Elisa, Riccardi, Antonella, Giacco, Veronica, Messitini, Valentina, Irace, Rosaria, Kedor, Claudia, Casteleyn, Vincent, Hilger, Julia, Hoeppner, Jakob, Rednic, Simona, Szabo, Iulia, Petcu, Ana, Avouac, Jérome, Camelia, Frantz, Desbas, Carole, Vlachoyiannopoulos, Panayioti, Montecucco, Carlo Maurizio, Caporali, Roberto, Cavagna, Lorenzo, Stork, Jiri, Inanc, Murat, Joven, Beatriz E., Novak, Srdan, Anic, Felina, Varju, Cecilia, Minier, Tunde, Allai, Daniela, Kucharz, Eugene J., Kotulska, Anna, Kopec-Medrek, Magdalena, Widuchowska, Malgorzata, Dolnicar, Alenka Sipek, Coleiro, Bernard, Gabrielli, Armando, Manfredi, Lucia, Benfaremo, Devi, Ferrarini, Alessia, Bancel, Dominique Farge, Hij, Adrian, Lazzaroni, Maria Grazia, Hesselstrand, Roger, Wuttge, Dirk, Andréasson, Kristofer, Martinovic, Duska, Bozic, Ivona, Radic, Mislav, Braun-Moscovici, Yolanda, Monaco, Andrea Lo, Furini, Federica, Hunzelmann, Nicola, Moinzadeh, Pia, Pellerito, Raffaele, Caimmi, Cristian, Bertoldo, Eugenia, Morovic-Vergles, Jadranka, Culo, Ivana Melanie, Pecher, Ann-Christian, Santamaria, Vera Ortiz, Heitmann, Stefan, Codagnone, Medeleine, Pflugfelder, Johanne, Krasowska, Dorota, Michalska-Jakubus, Malgorzata, Seidel, Matthia, Hasler, Paul, Kretschmar, Samuel, Kohm, Michaela, Bajocchi, Gianluigi, Salvador, Maria João, Da Silva, JoséAntonio Pereira, Stamenkovic, Bojana, Stankovic, Aleksandra, Selmi, Carlo Francesco, De Santis, Maria, Ceribelli, Angela, Garzanova, Ludmila, Koneva, Olga, Starovoytova, Maya, Herrick, Ariane, Puppo, Francesco, Negrini, Simone, Murdaca, Giuseppe, Engelhart, Merete, Szücs, Gabriela, Szamosi, Szilvia, De La Puente, Carlo, Grande, Cristina Sobrino, Villanueva, Maria Jesus Garcia, Midtve, Øyvindbw, Hoffmann-Vold, Anna-Mariabw, Launay, Davidbx, Sobanski, Vincentbx, Riccieri, Valeriaby, Vasile, Massimilianoby, Stefantoni, Katia, Ionescu, Ruxandra Maria, Opris, Daniela, Sha, Ami, Woods, Adrianne, Gheorghiu, Ana Maria, Bojinca, Mihai, Sunderkötter, Cord, Ehrchen, Jan, Ingegnoli, Francesca, Mouthon, Luc, Dunogue, Bertrand, Chaigne, Benjamin, Legendre, Paul, Cantatore, Francesco Paolo, Corrado, Ada, Ullman, Susanne, Iversen, Line, Von Mühlen, Carlos Alberto, Pozzi, Maria Rosa, Eyerich, Kilian, Lauffer, Felix, Wiland, Piotr, Szmyrka-Kaczmarek, Magdalena, Sokolik, Renata, Morgiel, Ewa, Madej, Marta, Vanthuyne, Marie, Frédéric, Houssiau, Alegre-Sancho, Juan Jose, Aringer, Martin, Herrmann, Kristine, Günther, Claudia, Westhovens, Rene, De Langhe, Ellen, Lenaerts, Jan, Anic, Branimir, Baresic, Marko, Mayer, Miroslav, Üprus, Maria, Otsa, Kati, Yavuz, Sule, Granel, Brigitte, Radominski, Sebastião Cezar, De Souza Müller, Carolina, Feijóazevedo, Valderílio, Mendoza, Fabian, Busquets, Joanna, Popa, Sergei, Agachi, Svetlana, Zenone, Thierry, Pileckyte, Margarita, Stebbings, Simon, Jordan, Sarah, Mathieu, Alessandro, Vacca, Alessandra, Sampaio-Barros, Percival D., Stamp, Lisa, Solanki, Kamal, Silva, Cherumi, Schollum, Joanne, Barns-Graham, Helen, Veale, Dougla, O'Rourke, Marie, Loyo, Esthela, Tineo, Carmen, Paulino, Glenny, Mohamed, Walid Ahmed Abdel Atty, Rosato, Edoardo, Gigante, Antonietta, Oksel, Fahrettin, Yargucu, Figen, Tanaseanu, Cristina-Mihaela, Popescu, Monica, Dumitrascu, Alina, Tiglea, Isabela, Foti, Rosario, Visalli, Elisa, Benenati, Alessia, Amato, Giorgio, Ancuta, Codrina, Villiger, Peter, Adler, Sabine, Fröhlich, Johanne, Kayser, Cristiane, Eduardo, Andrade Lui, Fathi, Nihal, Alii, Safa, Ahmed, Marrow, Hasaneen, Samar, El Hakeem, Eman, De La Peña Lefebvre, Paloma García, Martin, Jorge Juan Gonzalez, Sibilia, Jean, Chatelus, Emmanuel, Gottenberg, Jacques Eric, Chifflot, Hélène, Litinsky, Ira, Del Galdo, Francesco, Abignano, Giuseppina, Eng, Sookho, Seskute, Goda, Butrimiene, Irena, Rugiene, Rita, Karpec, Diana, Pascal, Melanie, Kerzberg, Eduardo, Bianchi, Washington, Bianchi, Breno Valdetaro, Bianchi, Dante Valdetaro, Barcellos, Yeda, Castellví, Ivan, Millan, Milena, Limonta, Massimiliano, Rimar, Doron, Rosner, Itzhak, Slobodin, Gleb, Couto, Maura, Spertini, Françoi, Ribi, Camillo, Buss, Guillaume, Marcoccia, Antonella, Bondanini, Francesco, Ciani, Aldo, Kahl, Sarah, Hsu, Vivien M., Martin, Thierry, Poindron, Vincent, Meghit, Kilifa, Moiseev, Sergey, Novikov, Pavel, Chung, Lori, Kolstad, Kathleen, Stark, Marianna, Schmeiser, Tim, Thiele, Astrid, Majewski, Dominik, Zdrojewski, Zbigniew, Zaneta, Smolenska, Wierzba, Karol, Martínez-Barrio, Julia, López-Longo, Francisco Javier, Bernardino, Vera, Moraes-Fontes, Maria Francisca, Rodrigues, Ana Catarina, Riemekasten, Gabriela, Sommerlatte, Sabine, Jendreck, Sebastian, Arnold, Sabrina, Levy, Yair, Rezus, Elena, Cardoneanu, Anca, Burlui, Alexandra Maria, Pamuk, Omer Nuri, Puttini, Piercarlo Sarzi, Talotta, Rossella, Bongiovanni, Sara, Poormoghim, Hadi, Andalib, Elham, Almasi, Simin, Kötter, Ina, Krusche, Matrin, Cuomo, Giovanna, Danzo, Fiammetta, Masini, Francesco, Gaches, Franci, Michaud, Martin, Cartos, Florian, Belloli, Laura, Casu, Cinzia, Sfikakis, Petro, Tektonidou, Maria, Furst, Daniel, Feldman, Gary R., Ramazan, Ana-Maria, Nurmambet, Emel, Miroto, Amalia, Suta, Cristina, Andronache, Iulia, Huizinga, Tom W. J., De Vries-Bouwstra, Jeska, and Walker, Ulrich A.
- Subjects
Male ,Vital capacity ,Organ manifestations ,systemic sclerosis ,Type I ,race difference ,Systemic scleroderma ,Gastroenterology ,Scleroderma ,immunology ,0302 clinical medicine ,Diffusing capacity ,middle aged ,pulmonary hypertension ,Medicine ,Pharmacology (medical) ,030212 general & internal medicine ,organ manifestations ,races ,skin and connective tissue diseases ,Lung ,race ,pathophysiology ,African Continental Ancestry Group ,ddc:616 ,integumentary system ,disease course ,Hazard ratio ,Races ,10051 Rheumatology Clinic and Institute of Physical Medicine ,Pulmonary ,Middle Aged ,Blacks ,cohort analysis ,Autoantibodie ,3. Good health ,Asians ,female ,priority journal ,DNA Topoisomerases, Type I ,Black ,centromere ,Cohort ,Hypertension ,organ manifestation ,Systemic sclerosis ,Female ,systemic sclerosi ,Human ,Adult ,Asian Continental Ancestry Group ,medicine.medical_specialty ,Hypertension, Pulmonary ,European Continental Ancestry Group ,Black People ,610 Medicine & health ,complication ,Caucasian ,White People ,Article ,lung ,03 medical and health sciences ,Black person ,Rheumatology ,Asian People ,forced vital capacity ,Internal medicine ,geographic distribution ,Humans ,controlled study ,human ,DNA topoisomerase ,Aged ,Autoantibodies ,030203 arthritis & rheumatology ,Scleroderma, Systemic ,Asian ,business.industry ,Whites ,Systemic ,Odds ratio ,medicine.disease ,Pulmonary hypertension ,major clinical study ,mortality ,clinical feature ,business ,DNA Topoisomerases ,autoantibody - Abstract
Objectives Racial factors play a significant role in SSc. We evaluated differences in SSc presentations between white patients (WP), Asian patients (AP) and black patients (BP) and analysed the effects of geographical locations. Methods SSc characteristics of patients from the EUSTAR cohort were cross-sectionally compared across racial groups using survival and multiple logistic regression analyses. Results The study included 9162 WP, 341 AP and 181 BP. AP developed the first non-RP feature faster than WP but slower than BP. AP were less frequently anti-centromere (ACA; odds ratio (OR) = 0.4, P < 0.001) and more frequently anti-topoisomerase-I autoantibodies (ATA) positive (OR = 1.2, P = 0.068), while BP were less likely to be ACA and ATA positive than were WP [OR(ACA) = 0.3, P < 0.001; OR(ATA) = 0.5, P = 0.020]. AP had less often (OR = 0.7, P = 0.06) and BP more often (OR = 2.7, P < 0.001) diffuse skin involvement than had WP. AP and BP were more likely to have pulmonary hypertension [OR(AP) = 2.6, P < 0.001; OR(BP) = 2.7, P = 0.03 vs WP] and a reduced forced vital capacity [OR(AP) = 2.5, P < 0.001; OR(BP) = 2.4, P < 0.004] than were WP. AP more often had an impaired diffusing capacity of the lung than had BP and WP [OR(AP vs BP) = 1.9, P = 0.038; OR(AP vs WP) = 2.4, P < 0.001]. After RP onset, AP and BP had a higher hazard to die than had WP [hazard ratio (HR) (AP) = 1.6, P = 0.011; HR(BP) = 2.1, P < 0.001]. Conclusion Compared with WP, and mostly independent of geographical location, AP have a faster and earlier disease onset with high prevalences of ATA, pulmonary hypertension and forced vital capacity impairment and higher mortality. BP had the fastest disease onset, a high prevalence of diffuse skin involvement and nominally the highest mortality.
- Published
- 2020