A Murder, a Conviction and Doubt: 15 years after a college student was killed, the case remains muddled and a jailed man remains in limbo.

The article discusses the status of the case of Mark S. Fisher, a college student who was shot dead in Brooklyn, New York City on October 12, 2003. Topics discussed include the trial of John Giuca who was convicted of murdering Fisher, the decision of an appeals court to threw out Giuca's conviction on the claims that the trial prosecutors withheld evidence from his lawyers, and the prosecutors' decision to challenge the ruling of the appeals court.